AN: I was asked to do another chapter for this and here it is. I know some of you wanted a chapter with strap ons, I think the next upload will be right up your alley ;)
Kara is buzzing around her apartment at super-human speed. She needs this place to be spotless before their family dinner tonight. It's Friday and Eliza is visiting her this weekend. They made plans to have a family dinner with Alex and Maggie tonight and Kara is so excited for it. They still haven't managed to tell Alex about their relationship, but Eliza is confident that even if Alex is mad at first, she will get over it eventually.
It's getting late and the sun is slowly starting to set outside her windows. She checks her watch quickly, 6:47 pm. Eliza should be here any minute now and Alex and Maggie will be here quarter after seven. She scans the apartment around her. The kitchen could use a last minute clean up. She zips into the kitchen with a cloth in hand and is just about to wipe down every surface she sees when a knock on her door sends her heartbeat into overdrive.
She can't believe she didn't hear Eliza's heartbeat on the way up. She really must have been distracted with the cleaning and was slacking with her hearing. She X-rays the door.
"What?" she asks herself when she doesn't see Eliza waiting outside for her, but instead finds her sister and Maggie standing there with bags and Tupperware in hand. She walks to the door and opens it. "Alex, Maggie, you guys are here early," she says happily as she steps to the side giving them room to walk in and put their stuff down on the kitchen counter. She is happy to see them even if it means she won't get any alone time with Eliza before dinner now.
"Yeah sorry," Alex grunts as she lifts the heavy bags of food onto the counter. "This one," she starts tilting her head toward Maggie, "wanted to help you cook. So here with are, with supplies."
Kara smiles happily as she closes the door behind them. She follows them into the kitchen and looks on as they unpack all the food and ingredients they have brought. "Great, I wasn't sure how to make a vegan dinner for Maggie, so now she can just help me." Maggie smiles in return and Kara matches it easily. They have been on really good terms lately and Kara couldn't be happier about that.
"You don't know how to cook a vegan meal?" Maggie asks incredulously. "How dare you," she feigns offense and teases Kara easily. "That's okay kid; I'll teach you some really easy stuff."
They fall into easy conversation as Maggie teaches both Kara and surprisingly Alex how to make vegan lasagna. When they are almost done prepping the food and getting ready to put it in the oven, Kara hears familiar footsteps coming down her hallway. She eagerly smiles but waits patiently for the knock on her door.
She all but skips to the door before swinging it open quickly. The sight that greets her makes her mouth go dry. Eliza is in a beautiful flowered sun dress with her thick blonde hair falling over her shoulders in light curls. Kara's smile could blind people if she isn't careful.
Eliza immediately hears Alex and Maggie's voices inside the apartment and edits her hello accordingly. "Hi, sweetheart," she says as her eyes trail noticeably up and down Kara's body. Kara is wearing skin tight jeans the hug her body in all the right places and a long sleeve shirt with a v-neckline that gives Eliza just a peek of what she can't wait to devour for dessert.
Kara finally draws her eyes away from staring at the short hemline of Eliza's dress to make eye contact with her secret girlfriend. "Hi Eliza," she says with a smile on her lips. She steps to the side allowing Eliza to come into the apartment before she closes the door and takes Eliza's bag and jacket. She wordlessly takes the items into her room to get them out of the way and Eliza can't help but appreciate the view of Kara's ass as she disappears through the doorway of her bedroom.
While the two pans of lasagna cook side-by-side in the oven, the four women sit in the living room with glasses of wine and catch up. Alex tells them all about the new sun grenade she is working on with Winn. Kara complains about Snapper and having to cover fluff pieces every day at CatCo. Maggie mentions the increasing sightings of Guardian out on patrol at night. Eliza talks about a conference she is going to attend in Switzerland and how excited she is to see the country for the first time.
When the food is ready, Eliza and Alex set the table while Maggie and Kara pull it from the oven and set it down on potholders in the center of the four plates. Eliza sits next to Kara and Alex and Maggie take their places opposite them. They eat and talk about life casually as they do.
Eliza is telling Alex about a new study she is thinking about doing. "Yeah there are going to be a few doctors involved in the process…" Then she feels Kara's hand gently rest on her knee. She doesn't think anything of it until it starts sliding up her thigh rapidly. She falters in her speaking, but Kara's hand freezes on her leg when she does and she realizes she has to keep speaking if she wants this to continue. She starts talking again and Kara's hand ventures higher on her thigh. If she keeps going she will be in for a real treat.
Kara is acting like nothing is happening as her hand finds the hem of Eliza's dress and slides it up with her fingertips. She reaches further between Eliza legs and where she expects to stroke her through her panties, she is instead met with Eliza's wet folds eagerly awaiting her. She chokes on her food instantly. She was not expecting that one bit.
Alex and Maggie both look at her with concern and Eliza takes a drink from her glass of wine to hide the smirk stretching across her face.
"Are you okay?" Alex asks innocently but with worry on her face.
Kara quickly gathers herself. "Yeah, sorry, just went down the wrong pipe," she explains as she stands up from the table. "I'm gonna grab a glass of water." She stands up and goes to the cupboard. "Keep going, Eliza," she throws over her shoulder as she grabs a glass and Eliza goes back to talking to Alex and Maggie.
She sits back down at the table. She sets her glass down and doesn't hesitate in putting her hand right back where it was before she left. Her fingertips lightly graze Eliza's thigh before meeting the destination they have been looking for. She tries to fight the smile on her face as she strokes her middle finger once up through Eliza's moist lips. Eliza, to her credit, doesn't falter at all. She continues talking to Alex and Maggie like nothing is happening and Kara knows a challenge when she sees one.
She tries her hardest to distract Eliza while also keeping her other company oblivious to what is happening beneath the table. She slides her ring and middle finger to Eliza's entrance and teases it gently a few times before dragging her fingers achingly slow up to the older woman's clit. The bud is hardened and waiting for her when she reaches it. She rolls her middle finger over it very softly and Eliza only grips her fork tighter. If you were listening to Eliza speak you would have no idea she was so aroused and being touched under the table.
Kara smirks. Eliza is better at this than she anticipated. She strokes her lips up and down once more to gather some wetness then rolls her finger over Eliza's clit once more, this time with more pressure. Eliza's speech doesn't even change an octave, but her thighs clench around Kara's hand and the younger woman knows she is really affecting her lover.
Eliza finishes talking and Kara takes the chance to talk about her recent interview with Lena Luthor. As she speaks her finger rolls over Eliza's clit continuously. Her pressure continues to get stronger and stronger until Eliza's left hand grabs hers tightly under the table. She pulls Kara's hand away from the throbbing clit to give herself a reprieve from the constant teasing. Kara just keeps telling her story like nothing has changed.
Shortly after Kara finishes her story, everyone is done eating and she stands up to take some of the plates to the sink. Once she sets the plates down, she turns to face the table and Eliza's eyes are locked on hers. She brings her middle and ring fingers to her lips and licks off the wetness that is still there from Eliza. She sees Eliza visibly blush and bite her lip as she ducks her eyes down to the table.
A little while later, the door finally closes behind Alex and Maggie and they are alone at last. Kara acts as if nothing has changed. She clears the table and brings the rest of the dishes to the sink with her. Eliza is watching her with disbelief. How can Kara go from practically fucking her under the table to ignoring her when they are finally alone?
She smirks as she walks up behind Kara and presses her front flush to the other woman's back. "What are you doing, babe?" she husks. Her breath rushes over Kara's neck and ear causing her to shiver, but that is her only reaction to Eliza's presence. She continues washing the dishes like nothing is happening. Eliza can't stand it. She reaches her hands around Kara's waist and slides her right hand easily into the front of Kara's jeans. Kara only pauses what she is doing for a moment until she goes back to washing the plate in her hand. Eliza brings her lips to the base of Kara's neck and starts slowly kissing towards the younger woman's ear as her hand cups Kara through her already damp thong.
Kara moans quietly even though she tried to bite her lip to stop it. She knows she has lost their secret battle now. She gives up fighting it and instead leans back into Eliza's front encouraging her to keep going. She reaches for the hand towel next to the sink and dries her hands.
"You know," Kara starts breathlessly, "if you weren't late today, we could have done this before dinner." Eliza hums her agreement as the hand that isn't in Kara's pants grabs her breast roughly. Kara's breath hisses between her teeth. "You wouldn't have had to deal with me teasing you all through our meal then," she taunts.
Eliza is about to respond when suddenly Kara is gone from her grip. Instead she is the one being pinned against the sink and Kara's body is pressed tightly against hers. Kara's hands are fast, sliding under the hem of Eliza's dress and around her body to grab her boobs possessively.
"Honestly though," Kara whispers into Eliza's ear. The older woman's knees buckle and her head drops back onto Kara's shoulder behind her. "I think you kind of liked me touching you all through dinner." Her fingers finally reach Eliza's center and slip easily through her soaked lips. "Oh yeah, I think you definitely liked it."
Without another word two of Kara's fingers slip easily into Eliza. She pushes until she is buried deep in the other woman. Eliza moans loudly and her hips buck into Kara's palm. Eliza wants to speak. She wants to encourage Kara to take her right then and there, but her words are lost as Kara's teeth sink into the shell of her ear.
"Shit," she hisses. Kara doesn't hesitate to set a devastating pace with her fingers. She has to consciously stop herself from ripping Eliza's dress right off of her as the other blonde moans and writhes in her arms.
Kara's fingers slam into Eliza over and over making her hips buck and her body push against Kara's begging for more contact. It's almost embarrassing how close she already is, but she is blaming it on being worked up so much during their meal.
Kara can tell Eliza is close based on the way Eliza's sex is clenching tightly around the fingers Kara's has buried inside her. She doesn't want to stop, but she wants to see the pleasure on Eliza's face more. In the blink of an eye Kara has pulled her fingers out, turned Eliza around and lifts her onto the counter next to the sink. Before Eliza can even process the change Kara's fingers have found their way back inside her and their rhythm barely changes.
Eliza raises her eyebrows slightly at the new position. "You know I like to see you cum," Kara supplies her explanation. Eliza doesn't really care why, all she can think about is the fire building in her stomach. She is about to finish and she knows it; her muscles are tensing on and off everywhere and her breathing is erratic.
Kara feels it too. She brings her thumb up to rub lightly over Eliza's swollen clit. She knows that will do the trick. "Cum Eliza," she all but demands and Eliza can't hold it off any longer.
One final pump of Kara's fingers and a swipe of her thumb and Eliza is screaming Kara's name throughout the apartment. Eliza's head is thrown back almost hitting the cabinets behind her as her body tenses and her fists grip at the edge of the counter she is sitting on. Her pleasure explodes within her and Kara helps her ride out the waves of it by slowing her fingers down until Eliza's body relaxes and she finally stops her fingers all together.
Both of them are breathing heavy. Eliza whimpers at the loss of the hero's fingers as Kara pulls them out and brings them up to her mouth. She licks her fingers clean, moaning as she does.
"Better than dessert," Kara says while smirking. Eliza can't help but laugh as she hunches over on the counter trying to catch her breath. She is shaken by aftershocks every so often. Kara laughs with her before kissing Eliza softly.
Kara walks away from the counter and toward her bedroom. "Where are you going?" Eliza asks sounding breathless and tired.
"Well," Kara says as she turns to face Eliza. She continues walking backward toward her bedroom as she speaks. "I'm going in here," she points her thumb over her shoulder at the dark room behind her. "I'm going to get naked and lay on my bed, and hopefully someone will join me soon." She winks before disappearing into her room. Eliza smiles and shakes her head at the hero. She slides off the counter and is about to start walking when she sees a pair of jeans and a soaked thong being thrown from Kara's bedroom.
"Oh you are mine, Supergirl," Eliza husks under her breath and she knows Kara hears her when she is met with a soft giggle from the dark bedroom.
