It had happened the first day, it had happened the second day, so it wasn't a surprise to Erin that she saw Andy on the elevator the morning of her third day at work.

"Fancy meeting you here." He said to her.

"I guess it is." Erin replied.

"So, how's work going?"

"Good, I guess." Erin sighed.

"You guess?"

"Well, I always think the second and third days are almost more nerve wracking than the first day." Erin confessed.

"Riddle me that." Andy said.

"What?"

"Riddle me that, you know, explain what you mean." Andy said as if it were obvious.

"Oh, right," Erin said, wondering why he didn't just ask her to explain in the first place instead of using this weird lingo. "Well, see, the thing is, if you do something wrong on the first day, people are like, 'oh, that's okay, you new.' But if you do something wrong on the second day, they get mad, even though you're still new. And you have to make even better impressions on everyone."

"Wanna know my three tips do do great here at Dunder Mifflin?"

"Riddle me that." Erin teased.

Andy smiled. "One. Name repetition."

"Name repetition?"

"Introduce yourself." Andy commanded.

"Hi, I'm Erin Hannon." She said awkwardly, shaking his hand.

"Hello, Erin Hannon." Andy said, she giggled.

"What's step two?

"Personality mirroring. So, keep going with our conversation."

"Um, so what's up, Andy Bernard?"

"What's up with you, Erin Hannon?" He said, and they both laughed.

"So, what's step number three?"

"Never breaking off a handshake."

"Never breaking off a handshake? How does that even work?"

"Well, let's just say, because I refuse to break off the handshake, so have you, and we have kept this conversation going, making it possible that we have gotten to know each other a little better. Oh, and, the elevator doors have been open for at least thirty seconds, and you didn't even notice because you've been so intrigued with out handshake and conversation." Andy said smoothly.

"Wow, you're good." Erin said admirably. "You're really good."

"Eh, I try. I mean, I went to Cornell, didn't I?" Andy said none to modestly.