I do not own Ouran High School Host Club. I only own Tiffani and Lexi. I also own Eric Williams.
Story start
"Oh look what I found," Lexi said later when she looked in their bags. Lexi smiled at Kyoya, who looked thankful that his notebook had not been destroyed. Tiffani was cowering behind Honey when Lexi walked over to Kyoya with his notebook in her hand.
Kyoya gently accepted the notebook from Lexi and looked inside. A breath of relief left him when he saw all of the data that he was writing earlier. "It was just a joke," Tiffani muttered and Kyoya gave her a glare.
"Thank you," Kyoya said softly to Lexi before he acquired his usual stern look and looked at Tiffani.
"Don't give me that look young man," Tiffani yelled before yelping and hiding behind the twins at the look she received from Kyoya. "Help me get away from him or calm him down and I'll do what you want," Tiffani whispered to the twins, who smirked at her in agreement.
Tiffani grabbed Lexi and they raced towards the limo that the twins called for them while the twins distracted Kyoya. "Why did you drag me along?" Lexi yelled once they were in the limo.
"Reflex," Tiffani said with a shrug before locking the limo doors and the limo drove away from the pool.
"Well he can still get you tomorrow at the club," Lexi said and Tiffani's eyes grew wide.
"Crud," Tiffani said before she started messing around with the buttons in the limo.
The next day, Lexi entered the third music room with a happy smile. Tiffani crept in behind her wearing a cloak to hide from Kyoya. Tamaki screamed when he saw Tiffani, who he thought was Nekozawa.
"You should have brought a puppet," Lexi said and Tiffani snickered.
"I forgot," Tiffani said before she ran into the kitchen at a look from Kyoya. "I'll never do it again. I'll leave your precious black book alone," Tiffani screamed in terror before disappearing into the kitchen.
Everyone in the club froze as they stared at the kitchen door. Lexi shook her head before smiling and saying, "Hey everyone."
"Hello Lexi," Haruhi said with a smile before Lexi waved and entered the kitchen. She entered to find Tiffani holding a bag of marshmallows in one hand and a marshmallow in the other. "What are you doing?" Lexi asked with a raised eyebrow.
Tiffani looked down at what was in her hands before looking back at Lexi. "Well I was going to use these to attack Kyoya if he came after me, but since he didn't well then I'm going to eat them," Tiffani said before sticking the marshmallow in her mouth.
"Well I'm sure Kyoya won't kill you in front of the customers so time to work," Lexi said before grabbing a marshmallow out of the bag.
"I'm keeping these close by just in case," Tiffani said putting the bag of marshmallows by her work area.
Lexi laughed at Tiffani before she started working on a cake.
"I'm bored," Tiffani said and Lexi looked away from the cupcakes she was decorating.
"What do you want to do? There is not much that we can do in here," Lexi asked before focusing back on the cupcakes.
Tiffani paused before a smirk grew on her face. "Let's dare each other to do stuff," she said while taking a cake out of the oven.
"I'm daring you first," Lexi said as she set down the cupcakes on a tray.
"Bring it on," Tiffani said as she took off her apron.
"I dare you to dress like a boy, go over to the twins, grab Kaoru, kiss him, and then say to Hikaru that Kaoru is your lover and no one should touch him," Lexi said grinning mischievously at Tiffani.
"That's easy," Tiffani said with a laugh as she ran out of the kitchen and to the changing rooms. She changed out of her dress and into the male uniform. She put on a hat and fixed her hair under it so she would look like a boy. Lexi stepped out of the kitchen with the tray of cupcakes so she would not look suspicious just standing around to watch Tiffani do the dare.
Tiffani snuck out of the changing rooms and the third music room. She then opened the third music room and walked over to the twins with a frown on her face. The twins were in the middle of their brotherly love act, which made this even better. Tiffani grabbed Kaoru's hand and pulled him away from Hikaru. Hikaru and Kaoru looked shocked for a moment at the person who just pulled Kaoru away.
They did not know it was Tiffani. Lexi was watching with shock as well to play along, while everyone else stared in silence. Kaoru went to say something before Tiffani pulled him into a kiss. Tiffani wrapped an arm around Kaoru's waist and put her other hand on the back of his head. Her fingers ran through his hair as she kissed him.
Hikaru's jaw dropped and Kaoru was in a bit of a daze when Tiffani pulled away from the deep kiss. Tiffani looked straight at Hikaru and made sure that her voice was boyish sounding. "Keep your hands off of my lover," Tiffani growled before giving Kaoru another kiss. Hikaru looked like a fish while Kaoru just slowly raised a hand to his lips when Tiffani spun around and left the room.
"Takashi, I didn't know Kaoru had a lover," Honey said cutely up to Mori who was staring silently.
"Ah," Mori said in a tone that said he did not know either. Excited whispers and giggles erupted in the room and Lexi made her way back to the kitchen. Tiffani snuck back in and changed into her dress when no one was looking. She ran into the kitchen as sneakily as she could. On her way to the kitchen, she saw Kaoru sitting next to Hikaru who was asking him who was that.
"That was perfect," Lexi said laughing after the kitchen door closed behind Tiffani.
"It's your time now," Tiffani said with a smirk and Lexi listened curiously at what she was going to have to do.
"I'm not running around naked," Lexi said in a blunt tone since Tiffani was taking a while to come up with her dare.
"That's my job anyways," Tiffani said and they both laughed. "Alright, I know what I want you to do. I dare you to go out there to Kyoya and try to feed him a bite of his favorite cake," Tiffani said triumphantly.
"You mean feed him like a little kid?" Lexi asked Tiffani with a crazy look.
"Well you don't have to make any airplane or train noises but yeah like a kid," Tiffani said and laughed.
"There is no way I'm going to make airplane or train noises," Lexi said but sighed as she accepted the tray holding Kyoya's favorite cake. She gave Tiffani a small glare before leaving the kitchen. Tiffani followed her with a tray of strawberry cake. Tiffani headed over to Honey and Mori's table with the tray. She was going to have front row seats to this dare.
Lexi made her way to Kyoya's table and prayed that she would survive. "Kyoya-san, I made your favorite cake, but it cooked a little differently this time. I was wondering if you would try a bite for me and see if it tastes the same. I'm not an expert on this type of cake like you are," Lexi said as she held out the fork with a bite of cake on it towards Kyoya.
Kyoya looked away from his notebook to look at Lexi. He then looked at the fork holding the cake before looking back at Lexi. She gave a little smile to keep from being nervous. She felt as if a bunch of butterflies were dancing in her stomach.
Kyoya was silent before he leaned forward and ate the bite of cake off the fork. Lexi was surprised before moving the fork away. Kyoya chewed and swallowed the cake before looking back at Lexi. "The cake tastes the same," Kyoya said before going back to his notebook.
"Well that's good," Lexi said with a smile before setting the plate of cake down on the table. She set the fork down as well, but a hand on top of hers stopped her from moving away from the table. Lexi looked at Kyoya wondering what was going to happen next.
"I'm busy at the moment and do not have time to eat the cake, but with your assistance I will be able to," Kyoya said throwing a smirk Lexi's way. Lexi froze before she took a seat the offered chair by Kyoya. She could tell Kyoya was not kidding when he placed her hand on top of the fork again.
Tiffani was giggling between Mori and Honey. She was trying to muffle her giggles in Mori's blazer. "Tiff-chan, why are you giggling so much?" Honey asked cutely while Mori looked down at the two.
"Lexi and I are playing a little game," Tiffani said with another giggle she tried to smother in Mori's blazer so her voice was a little muffled.
"Can I play?" Honey asked cutely and Tiffani smiled at him.
"Are you sure you want to?" Tiffani asked and Honey nodded excitedly.
"Alright this is what I dare you to do," Tiffani whispered the dare in Honey's ear. Honey smirked deviously before his bubbly look returned. He jumped off the couch before disappearing into the room where everyone kept their stuff.
Tiffani smiled innocently at Mori, who was shaking his head, before she disappeared back to the kitchen. Lexi joined her later looking like a bright red tomato. Lexi was embarrassed about having to feed Kyoya, but it felt so right to be by Kyoya's side even if he was smirking the whole time at her.
"Who did this to my bear?" Tamaki's yell sounded at the end of the club period. The two in the kitchen ran out to the main area of the music room. Tamaki was holding his stuffed bear, which was dressed in a pink bunny costume.
Tamaki's sad face made the two girls bust out laughing and Honey gave them a little smile. Lexi looked at Tiffani as if asking if Honey really did that and Tiffani nodded with a wink.
"What a crazy day," Haruhi said from Mori's side before Tamaki tried to hug her because he was upset and needed comfort.