Yay! Second chapter! So, there's more backstory. I swear this story has plot, I just have to get through all of the backstory first.

Disclaimer: I do not own Glee or Little White Lie

"Wait, what?" Kurt demanded, staring at his boyfriend. "What're you talking about, Blaine?"

The curly haired singer sighed. "Kurt, I just told you, my name isn't Blaine. It's Toby."

The countertenor locked eyes with Blaine, er, Toby, whoever it was. "I don't believe you," Kurt said shakily. His boyfriend looked extremely seriously, not like he was about to just start laughing at Kurt's gullible nature. "Prove it and I'll believe you."

The other boy sighed, reaching into his pocket and pulling out his wallet. He slid out his driver's license, holding it out for Kurt to examine. Kurt took it with the realization he had never seen Blaine's license before. He looked down at it, feeling his stomach drop. Right beside picture of his boyfriend read 'Name: Toby Everett Phillips'. He felt his knees weaken.

"Kurt?" Toby asked tentatively. He knew better than to step forward or to move in anyway. Knowing Kurt, he was going to lash out in five…four…three…two…

The porcelain skinned teen slid his phone out of his jeans, furiously tapping a message out before sticking the device back into his pocket. "Alright," he said, gritting his teeth slightly. "Now, Bla- Toby, you are coming with me to the Lima Bean so you can finish your story so maybe I can understand what's happening."

"What about glee club?" Toby asked, thoroughly confused. He enjoyed glee. Plus, he and Kurt were supposed to perform 'As Long As You're Mine' today in class and, knowing Schuester, they wouldn't get another opportunity.

"Mercedes is covering for us," Kurt said, grabbing his partner by the arm and practically dragging him along the corridor. "This is more important than glee."

Toby raised his eyebrows, but said nothing. He allowed Kurt to lead him out of the school to his Navigator. He got in quietly, closing the door gently so his boyfriend wouldn't have a reason to yell at him.

Kurt, however, was a completely different story. He shut his door forcefully, causing Toby to flinch and look over at him, his honey hazel eyes wide with shock. "Well?" Kurt demanded as he cranked up his SUV, pulling out of the parking lot. "Start talking."

"Kurt," Toby started cautiously. He knew the boy next to him was irritated. He just wasn't sure why yet. "Why you mad at me?"

The Navigator jerked to a halt at a red light. Kurt turned his head toward Toby, his bitch glare in place. "Well, let's see. I just found out everything I know about my boyfriend is a lie! Don't you think I have the right to be a little upset?"

Toby winced at the accusation. "Not everything," he defended as the light turned green and the car lurched forward. "Just my name and I have good reason for that."

Kurt stayed silent until they pulled into the Lima Bean. "I take it that reason will be in your story?" Toby nodded. "Alright, let's go then." They got out of the car, walking side by side into the shop. The barista saw them and immediately started on Toby's medium drip and Kurt's Grande nonfat mocha.

"Why don't you go get a table?" Toby suggested as he approached the counter, pulling out his wallet. "I'll get the drinks." Kurt just nodded as he stalked over to their usual table. Toby sighed, taking the drinks from the barista and handing over the money for it with a smile and a 'thank you'. He sat down at the table across from Kurt, sliding him his coffee.

Kurt took a sip from the cup, humming contentedly. "So, last thing you told me was Little White Lie became the coolest band in school."

"Right," Toby nodded, his hands fidgeting with the lid of his coffee cup. "Well, the night after Battle of Bands, Tanya had a party and invited pretty much everyone. Sami showed, but Duder didn't." Toby smile slightly before his expression became serious again. "Well, Tanya and Sami hated each other. So while everyone was talking, Tanya managed to start this rumor that Sami was going to be getting a sex reassignment surgery."

Kurt choked on his coffee. "She told them Sami was getting a sex change?" He hissed; his expression horrified. He didn't even know this girl and her felt bad for her.

"Yeah," Toby shook his head. "Everyone believed it, but they were acting stupidly supportive and one guy called her up next to him and started talking about it. That's how she found how. She ran out of the party." He paused for a second. "I ran after her.

"I apologized; I said I didn't know what Tanya had been thinking, admitted that all of the people in there weren't my friends and I only hung around them because I didn't know anyone else." Toby smiled a little more openly. "Then, Sami invited me to join Little White Lie."

Kurt blinked. "Did you pretend to be hetero so long that you had a crush on Sami?" He asked coldly.

Toby glared at him, hurt in his eyes. "Anyway, I ended up missing the first practice with the band because Tanya wanted me to come over. I was angry at her for what she pulled at the party and she knew that. So I went over and she had everything set up for us to watch 'Pride and Prejudice' and 'The Notebook', which was her idea of making up after a fight." Kurt snorted at the cliché overtone of the whole 'makeup'. Toby rolled his eyes. "So after, I went to Sami's house to apologize for missing practice. Then I noticed her sheet music for all of the songs she had written.

"She had written a love song about herself-"

"Wow," Kurt sneered. "Really conceited isn't she?"

Toby let out an exasperated breath. "Kurt, if you're not going to listen without making snarky comments, why are we here?" Kurt glowered at him. Toby reached across the table and took Kurt's hand in his, taking it as a good sign when Kurt didn't try to flinch away. "Love, please just tell me why you're in such a bad mood. Like, I get I should have told you all of this before, but I was scared to."

Kurt sighed, his shoulders slumping slightly. "I guess I hate knowing that you kept all of this from me." He muttered, looking up at Toby through his eyelashes. "It's just a lot to take in at one time."

"Well," Toby smiled. "Why don't we finish our coffee and catch the last twenty or so minutes of glee club and I'll finish this story sometime later?"

"Agreed," Kurt smirked. "Only on the condition you have to tell everything you've already told me to the rest of the club."

Toby grimaced at the thoughts of how the New Directions would take this news. "Deal."

Reviews are wonderful to receive. ~C.Y.R.