My Pirate
Elaine knew Guybrush was a keeper when he attempted to rescue her, the first time he witnessed her being kidnapped by LeChuck. The rescue attempt failed; she had already escaped, but he hadn't known that at the time. No one else had come after her and tried to save her in the past. She'd always had to rely on herself before then. Guybrush, her new boyfriend she didn't even know properly at the time. He was head over heels for her as she was for him. Never did she imagine she'd end up with a pirate, despite being one herself.