Author's Note: I don't own anything other than my original characters

"Are you okay?" Mal asked. Evie managed a smile, looking over at her best friend. "E, what's wrong?"

"Nothing, I just… I miss Lef." she admitted. Mal rested her chin on her best friend's shoulder.

"I know. I miss her, too." she replied. Evie sighed. "What do you think she's doing right now?"

"Hating me." Evie whispered, looking out towards the Isle.

"Have you noticed a weird vibe between Lef and Heather?" Evie asked as she and Mal left the library a few days later.

"A little bit, but it's most likely nothing. They probably ran into each other on the Isle a few times, that's all. Heather's probably just looking for a familiar face and she hates us." Mal replied. Evie nodded slowly. "If it's bothering you so much, just talk to Lef."

"Yeah, that's a good idea. Are you heading back to the dorms?" the taller girl asked.

"No, Ben and I have a date. Let me know how it goes, though." Mal said. Evie nodded, quickly making her way to the dorms.

…

When Lefi heard a knock on her door, she looked up to find Heather in the doorway. Holding back a sigh, she raised an eyebrow. "What's up?"

"You've barely said two words to me since I got here." Heather replied, stepping into the room.

"That's not true. I've said at least ten." Lefi pointed out. Heather rolled her eyes. "I've been busy; I haven't really had time to talk."

"You seem to have enough time to talk to Evie and Mal." the redhead said.

"You mean my girlfriend and my sister? I make time for them." Lefi replied, looking back at her computer. Heather walked over and sat on the bed. "Can I help you?"

"I missed you." Heather whispered.

"I appreciate that." Lefi replied. Heather sighed, grabbing her hand. "What do you want, Heather?"

"I think we both know the answer to that question." the redhead said. Just as Heather was about to close the distance between them, they heard a slight gasp and the sound of something hitting the floor. Pulling away from the redhead, Lefi stared at her girlfriend as Evie picked up her dropped textbook.

"Eves…" she whispered.

"Don't." Evie snapped, turning around and walking out of the room.

"Evie, wait!" Lefi yelled, running after her girlfriend. She managed to put her foot out in time to stop the door to Mal and Evie's room from shutting, quickly slipping inside before Evie realized what she'd done. "Please let me explain."

"I saw enough." Evie said, not looking at her. Lefi gently turned her head so that they were making eye contact.

"I don't think you did. I would never do anything to betray your trust." she whispered. The taller girl rolled her eyes as she sat down at her worktable. "Evie, I love you."

"Then why were you about to kiss her? I want to know the truth about what happened between you two on the Isle." Evie demanded. Lefi closed her eyes.

"After you guys left and Mal defeated our mom, I started going into town more. I met Heather and we started hanging out." she explained.

"Did you date her?" Evie asked. Lefi sighed.

"We didn't so much date as we did… sleep together." she admitted. Closing her eyes, Evie put her head in her hands. "Evie, you can't be mad at me for that. You were here and you were dating Doug." Lefi said gently.

"You should have told me about this when we got back together." Evie whispered.

"Would it have changed your mind?" the blonde asked

"Of course not." Evie replied. Lefi closed her eyes. "I just… Do you understand how embarrassing this is? I mean… she's not exactly my biggest fan."

"What? Why?" Lefi asked. Evie sighed.

"A couple of weeks before we came to Auradon, Mal and I pulled a prank on Heather. We sort of… She kept a journal and Mal stole it. We read it out loud in front of the entire school." she explained

"What did it say?"

"Things I'd rather not repeat. Let's just say that she made a lot of villains mad." taller girl mumbled. Lefi raised an eyebrow.

"Why'd you do it?"

"It was the Isle of the Lost, Lef. It wasn't that bad of a prank there. I didn't realize how mean it was until we got here." Evie whispered. The blonde nodded as something occurred to Evie. "We are so stupid."

"What?"

"She's trying to get back at me." the blue-haired girl said, looking up at her girlfriend. Lefi narrowed her eyes. "Don't look at me like that. I'm not saying that someone has to be using you to be interested in you. I'm just saying that that might be the case this time."

"Are you trying to offend me? Because it's working." Lefi said Evie rolled her eyes.

"Think about it: she knew that we were friends on the Isle. I humiliate her and get her beat up and then all of a sudden, she's into my girlfriend?"

"I wasn't your girlfriend at the time." the blonde replied.

"Not the point, Lef."

"She didn't know we dated, though." Lefi pointed out.

"But she knew we were best friends. Plus, you're Mal's sister. Now, she's here in Auradon and is well aware of the fact that we're together and she tries to kiss you in your room – which is across from mine – with the door open. It makes sense, doesn't it?" Lefi looked down as she thought about it.

"She was just using me?" she whispered. Yes, she'd been using Heather to get over Evie, but there was something about using another person for revenge that just seemed... cruel. Seeing the hurt in her girlfriend's eyes, Evie grabbed her hand and squeezed it.

"Hey." she whispered. Hearing the gentle tone, Lefi looked up. "Do you want to confront her?"

"I want to go all Isle of the Lost on her." Lefi hissed. Evie smirked; she'd chosen good, but sometimes she missed being evil. She may not have been the evilest of the villain kids on the island, but when she was, she had so much fun. It was part of what had attracted her to Mal's friendship. "You ready to be a villain again?"

"We could get in trouble." Evie warned. Lefi gripped the back of the chair she was standing in front of.

"I don't care. I may not have gotten any attention from my mother, but I did inherit her arrogance and her ego. We both know she had both of those traits." she said. Evie looked up at her girlfriend. "What?"

"You're nothing like your mother." Lefi narrowed her eyes. "It's a good thing, I promise."

"Right now… I'm exactly like my mother." Lefi whispered, resting her chin on top of Evie's head and wrapping her arms around the girl's shoulders. Placing a hand on Lefi's forearm, Evie closed her eyes.

"I'm not going to let her get away with this, Lef." she promised.

Meanwhile, on the Isle, Lefi was staring out toward Auradon. Despite how angry she was with Mal and Evie for leaving her, she couldn't help but miss them. She missed Evie more than she thought was possible. As she took a deep breath, she realized that this was the first time she'd been apart from Evie in ten years.

She didn't know what to do on the Isle without her.