A/N: I don't own anything other than my original character
A week later, Evie and Carlos walked into Dragon Hall to find Heather, the daughter of the Queen of Hearts, leaning up against the locker next to Lefi's with a flirtatious grin on her face. "Um... What is this?" Evie whispered, narrowing her eyes. Carlos shrugged.
"They used to hang out last year, I think." he said, causing Evie to turn her head toward him. "I don't really know the details."
"I'm going to find out." the blue-haired girl replied. The moment Heather walked away, she made a beeline for her girlfriend.
"Hey." she said. Lefi smiled as Evie leaned up against her recently closed locker. "So... What were you talking about with Heather?" Evie asked. Lefi shrugged.
"Nothing important." she said. Evie bit her lip. "What's wrong?"
"Do you and Heather have a past?" the blue-haired girl whispered, looking past her girlfriend and seeing Heather down the hall before turning back to the blonde. Taking a deep breath, Lefi nodded. "Did you date?"
"What? No, of course not. Evie, I barely knew what dating was before our relationship started." the blonde replied. Evie sighed. "It wasn't exactly a relationship, but we did have a casual thing."
"How casual?" Evie asked.
"Casual enough, but it's over now."
"How over?" the taller girl questioned, earning a chuckle from her girlfriend. Taking her girlfriend's face in her hands, Lefi kissed her softly.
"Completely." she whispered, a smile on her face. Evie nodded slowly, unable to stop her eyes from flicking to the redhead down the hall. When Evie looked back at her, the blonde winked as she removed her hands from Evie's face and wrapped her arms around her waist. "You, Princess," Evie chuckled as the blonde lifted her hand and tapped her nose. "Have absolutely nothing to worry about."
"Promise?"
"I promise." Evie smiled softly. "Come here." Lefi whispered, pulling the taller girl even closer and kissing her. Pulling away, she grinned. "I have to go, Jay and I have some stuff to steal."
"Okay." Evie whispered, pressing a kiss to Lefi's cheek before the girl walked away. Watching her girlfriend walk down the hall, Evie leaned up against the row of lockers as someone approached her from behind.
"Are you okay?" Jumping at the voice, Evie looked over in surprise when she heard Mal's speak. "I'm trying this new thing where I'm not a colossal bitch to my sister's girlfriend." the purple-haired girl explained, seemingly knowing why she was confused.
"A capital idea." Evie replied. Mal chuckled.
"What's going on with you?" she asked. Evie sighed.
"What do you know about Lefi and Heather?" Mal shrugged.
"I know they hooked up a few times last year, but it was never anything serious. I think it was strictly a physical thing." she explained. Evie raised an eyebrow. "I don't think you have anything to worry about, Evie. Lef loves you." Evie paused.
"She what?" she asked. Realizing what she'd said, Mal shook her head. "She loves me?"
"Um..." Evie stared at the purple-haired girl. "I-I don't know what you're talking about."
"You just said that Lefi loves me." Evie whispered.
"No, I didn't." Mal replied, shaking her head. Evie nodded. "Nope. Never said that."
"Mal, does your sister love me?" the blue-haired girl asked. Letting out a sigh, Mal nodded. "Oh, my god." Evie whispered, smiling softly.
"You can't say anything to her about this. She wants to tell you on her own terms." the purple-haired girl said. Evie nodded.
"I won't say anything, I promise." Nodding, Mal walked away, leaving Evie with a wide smile on her face.
That night, Lefi was getting ready for bed when she was pulled into a kiss. "Hi." she whispered, pulling away and sitting on her bed.
"Hi." Evie replied, jumping onto the spot next to her girlfriend. Lefi grinned as she was pulled into another kiss, with Evie pushing her down and laying down on top of her. "Tell me you love me." Evie whispered, pressing a kiss to Lefi's jaw. Freezing, Lefi pulled away slowly.
"Wha... What?" she asked, searching Evie's eyes for answers. "I don't understand. Where is this coming from?"
"I was talking to Mal earlier and..." Trailing off, Evie rolled her eyes at herself. "I should've known I couldn't trust her. I should have known that this was another one of her pranks." she mumbled.
"Calm down, it's okay. What did Mal say to you?" Lefi asked.
"It doesn't matter. I'm going to go." Evie replied. Watching her girlfriend jump out of the bed, Lefi shook her head and reached for her hand. "Don't, Lef. I have to go."
"Evie, wait." Lefi replied, getting out of the bed and attempting to stop her girlfriend from leaving the room. Before she could grab her hand, Evie was slamming the door in her face. Running a hand over her face, Lefi fell back on her bed, letting out a groan of frustration. A few minutes later, her door swung open. Thinking it was Evie, the blonde sat up with a grin on her face only to sigh when she saw that it was Mal.
"What the hell just happened? Evie grabbed her bag, shoved everything she brought with her into it, and climbed out of my window." the purple-haired girl asked. Lefi glared at her sister. "Why are you mad at me?"
"What did you say to Evie about me? She thinks you're playing a prank on her." the blonde explained. Brow furrowed, Mal shook her head.
"I'm not playing a prank on her. I did accidentally tell her that you love her, but that's not a lie." she replied, causing her sister to close her eyes as she sat down.
"You told Evie that I love her?" Lefi asked. Mal nodded. "Oh, god."
"You do love her, though, you told me you did." Mal said. Lefi nodded.
"You're right, I do. I just haven't told her yet. I haven't been able to find the right time." she explained. Mal sat down next to her sister. "Evie told me she loved me when we had our first kiss. I've never said it back, but... I've known she was different from the moment that we met. If I'm being honest with myself, I've always loved her." Lefi whispered.
"Then tell her that." Mal replied. The blonde looked over at her sister. "Lef, her face lit up when I told her. I'm sure she'd be even happier to hear the words from you." Thinking for a minute, Lefi nodded.
"Yeah, she will. Let's go find her." she said, standing up and walking out of her room. Taking a deep breath, she led her sister out of the house, determined to find her girlfriend.