To Earendil, Lord of Sirion,
Greetings.
My Brothers and I are aware that you have in your possession the Silmaril which Beren and Princess Luthien took from Morgoth's crown.
I understand your plight. After all, this is an heirloom to the Sindarin Royal Family. Lady Elwing's ancestors risked much and survived more in order to succeed in their quest. But a stolen treasure rescued from a thief does not belong to the rescuer.
King Thingol had no right to demand a Silmaril, and Beren had no right to keep it. The Silmarils were created by my father, back when your grandfather, King Turgon was young. Morgoth stole them after he murdered our High King. An age ago my father swore by the Valar to reclaim them. He died before he was able to complete this task. My brothers and I are bound by this same Oath.
I am confident we can negotiate a peaceful settlement between our people.
May you walk under the light of the stars.
Maedhros, Prince of Tirion, Lord of Himring
