"- Here you are, grandma, you can touch him and stop winning "
And saying this, Cristy handcuffed Misha into the chair, and uncovered his eyes and his mouth. The actor was in complete shock. He saw Jensen and Jared handcuffed to the bed, but said nothing, remaining quiet, with his eyes wide open. The old woman promptly shoved her hands into his face, and moved them down, feeling every inch of his body. "- Hmmmmm... he's delicious..." - She said.
Sam and Dean were extremely surprised. How that woman, silly and clumsy, was able to find Misha wherever he was, and brought him to Chicago in less than 1h? The boys knew that the filming of the eighth season of Supernatural had come to an end. It was expected that the actor was back in the U.S., however he didn't even live in Chicago... Misha lived in Los Angeles.
Cristy then told them that just like Misha, many friends and family of Jensen and Jared were in Chicago, all collaborating with the police and waiting for information about their disappearance. The news had been spread by the media. All she needed to do was to figure out in which hotel Misha was staying at, and that was an easy task for a stalker fan like herself.
- But how did you manage to bring Misha without even drugging him, as you did to us? - Sam asked incredulously. - You don't even carry a gun... Didn't he try to resist?
Cristy exhibited her plastic gun, and smiled. Misha had fallen for that poorly made replica ... The two hunters found it inconceivable, but nobody can really blame the guy - after all he was just an actor, and was not used to guns and violence.
Cristy then added "- And I didn't drug you... I was just lucky that you were sleepy when I found you..."
A shiver went down Sam's spine. He knew that he and his brother had been drugged, otherwise it would have been impossible for Cristy to kidnap hunters as capable as themselves... So who the hell did it? He then recalled that Mr. Guttorp, their "lawyer", was having a coffee in their house minutes before... It could only have been him... Damn! What was that bastard planning against them?
- Mr. Guttorp… - he said in a low voice, talking to himself.
Grandma Matilda, who had acute hearing, heard the words that came of Sam's mouth. She remembered Dr. Guttorp, a well known psychiatrist who treated people in that region for years.
- You know Dr Guttorp? – The old woman asked.
Before Sam could answer, Cristy spoke for him. "Yes, they both do. On the day I kidnapped them, I saw the doctor leaving their place"
- Ahh! – Said the old woman – He is a great psychiatrist, you can be certain of that... It was him who cured my granddaughter. It may seem impossible, but Cristy was not always that example of mental health...
Sam and Dean looked at each other, stunned. So Guttorp had never been a lawyer, he was a psychiatrist, and apparently a terrible one. This meant that Misha had not believed their story, and had sent the doctor to watch over them. So that was why they had been drugged: psychiatrists enjoy giving strong medicine to their patients! Apparently that crazy doctor did it, even without their consent!
Dean felt betrayed, and for a moment forgot that Misha was not able to answer questions. The hunter was about to open his mouth to confront him when Sam rushed to speak first.
- Dr. Guttorp is great. Jensen and I were confused, but he also healed us. Now we are fine!
Sam gave Dean the look, and the older brother got the message. If Misha had not believed them before, there was no reason to insist now. None of them wanted to be sent to a mental institution.
After touching Misha long enough, Grandma Matilda asked Billy to help her undress the actor. He needed to be put into diapers. Cristy released Misha's hands and Billy grabbed him to prevent the prisoner to scape.
Sam and Dean looked terrified when the old woman and her granddaughter undressed Misha completely, as the actor, still in shock, did not react. Seeing Misha totally naked made Dean blush shamefully, due to the physical resemblance between him and Castiel.
Misha was dressed with only a white shirt and diapers. After some discussion of where to place the guy, they decided to lay him in bed with the other hostages. They squeezed the three guys together in bed, with Dean in the middle. The poor hunter felt shaky and nervous, being placed so close to Misha. He could smell him and feel his warmth, and could not pay attention to anything else. What on earth was happening to him?! The hunter sighed and tried to calm himself down, not to let it show. He was embarrassed.
- Great, let's continue with our "Supernatural Marathon"? - Cristy suggested enthusiastically. Billy and Matilda agreed excitedly.
With just over five minutes passed, however, Misha started to get restless. He was finally getting rid of the torpor, while the feeling of panic began to invade his body. In a short time Misha was screaming, crying and writhing.
- Be quiet! - Cristy ordered, pausing the episode – I can't hear anything if you keep screaming!
But Misha continued to scream hysterically... Cristy, Matilda and Billy decided to leave the room until he got tired.
Dean turned to Misha and tried to calm him down: "-Hey, don't worry... no one will hurt you ..." - He said. "-Take a deep breath, and please don't cry anymore...". Misha, however, didn't seem to pay any attention to him. All the previous inertia of the actor had turned into an uncontrolled desperation.
Dean gave up the attempt, and looked penalized. Sam noticed that Dean's eyes were filled with tears, and he was about to cry anytime too.
Sam was annoyed. Obviously the fact that Misha looked identical to Castiel touched his brother, and clouded his judgment. Misha was acting like a sissy, doing a horrible girly attack. Dean would look with contempt at man who acted that way. Well, apparently except Misha, because Dean couldn't bare to see Castiel crying... Didn't he realize that Misha, indirectly, should be blamed to put them in that situation? After all it was him who put Dr. Guttorp into both of their lives. So Sam, impatiently, spoke to the actor:
- Hey man, control yourself, look at how it affects our friend!– He said pointing to Dean, who now displayed a single tear running down the right side of his face.
Sam's "revenge" was not understood by Misha, of course. The blue eyed man still took a while to calm down. Then he finally asked:
- Are these people very cruel? Are you hurt?
- No... I told you they aren't... - Dean replied, in a gentle and pious voice – Don't worry, okay? Nothing will happen to you, I promise!
Sam then said ironically:
- You really have no reason to worry... So far there has only been threats. I almost got raped by Billy, and Jensen almost lost his penis. He was really, really close to lose it... But hey, they "love" us… They are our fans... psychopaths ...
Misha squeaked in pain. Dean looked at Sam reproachfully: "- What are you scaring him for?"
- I'm just telling the truth - Sam replied, dryly - and be quiet now, the "Ghostly Trio" is on its way, I can hear their footsteps.
Sure enough, a few seconds later Cristy Kelly, her grandmother and Billy arrived with popcorn. The girl put the DVD to play, and everyone went back to watch. There were hours and hours of film, with small breaks for bathroom, changing diapers and a few hours of sleep. Other than that, they would only stop to feed the prisoners, as they didn't have free hands to eat by themselves. The "Ghostly Trio" ate watching TV.
Misha soon got used to the routine, and did not understand how Jensen and Jared could suffer so much watching the show. Perhaps they were more vulnerable because they were kidnapped for a lot longer than himself.
In the final episode of the fifth season things got ugly. Dean cried so much that Sam and Misha both begged for a break, and "fought" to see who could console him first. Then came the sixth season. Soulless Sam left Dean devastated again. And many other sad moments ensued, with the death of Bobby tearing many tears from both Winchester brothers.
Cristy had the eighth season complete, downloaded from the internet, and duly recorded in DVD format. Sam and Dean remembered everything until the time that Sam had done the first task to close the gates of Hell. After that, everything was new to them. Garth became the main character, doing the brothers work. Castiel barely appeared. He was hiding protecting the angel's tablet. It was mentioned that Sam and Dean were not right in their heads and had retired temporarily.
- How does this Garth look like? - Asked old Matilda.
- He is skinny and weird - said her granddaughter - Sorry, kidnapping him is out of question. DJ Qualls is already in Canada for the filming of the ninth season ...
- I want Sam and Dean back in the ninth season! - complained the old grandma.
Sam took advantage of what she said:
- Unfortunately, by the way, you will not see Sam, Dean and Castiel back in the ninth season ... We should already be in Canada for the filming... - He said.
Misha and Dean supported Sam's idea enthusiastically. With this argument they finally managed to convince Cristy to let them go.
The kidnapper allowed them to get rid of the diapers and dress normally. Cristy, her old grandmother and Billy said goodbye to the three of them, with tears in their eyes, and made sure to hug them, kiss them, lick them and grope them. "- Send me a postcard from Canada!" – old Matilda said before letting them go.
Cristy left them on the verge of a deserted road. It was she herself who called the police anonymously to report the whereabouts of the boys. Soon they were rescued. Finally they were on their way to Jared and Jensen's house.