Quinntana FanFiction: Can't Stay Away From You
Chapter 10: Truth or Dare
The boys moved the dining table back into the kitchen while the girls sat around forming a circle. Puck brought out a bottle of vodka and put it in the middle of the circle.
"Whoever fails to do a dare, or lies about a truth, has to take a shot" explained Puck. Everybody agreed that it was fair, so they started the game.
Finn was the one to start it. He spun the bottle and it landed on Puck.
"Truth or Dare?" asked Finn.
"Dare" replied Puck.
"I dare you to go in the middle of the street and yell at the top of your lungs saying that you love booze and had sex with a dog." said Finn.
Suprisingly, Puck got up and actually did it. Everybody watched as he did what he was told. After yelling, a couple of the neighbors started yelling back and telling him to shut up. When Puck spun the bottle, it landed on Brittany. Brittany chose to do a dare.
"I dare you to make out with Santana for a full minute" said Puck. Santana's eyes widened at the mention of her name. She made contact with Brittany's blue eyes and she knew that she was asking for permission. If Santana wasnt taken, she would have gladly agreed. But she was. She turned to Quinn.
"Do you trust me?" asked Santana.
"Of course I do. Only for a minute. And then after that, you have to disinfect your mouth" said Quinn. Everybody else didnt know they were dating.
Brittany moved so that she was infront of Santana. Making sure Quinn had a good view. Brittany gave Quinn a little smirk. That made Quinn's blood boil. Her face was starting to turn red and her knuckles white as she clenched her fists at her sides.
"Go" said Puck.
Brittany moved closer to Santana and leaned in. Their lips were mere inches apart before Rachel yanked Brittany out of the way. Rachel was a couple centimeters away from Santana's lips but was yanked away by Quinn and crashed her lips with Santana's. Santana was shocked but glad it was her girlfriend she was actually kissing.
"Woah! It was Brittany's dare. Not yours or Rachel...Although, I have to admit. It was hot!" said Puck.
"San and I are dating and I couldnt just let anyone else kiss her" she shot both Brittany and Rachel a look. Everyone gasped at the news.
"Then why did Rachel try to kiss her?" asked Puck.
"Because she has a crush on Santana too" replied Kurt.
Everyone's jaw hung slightly open. Eyes were wandering from Brittany, to Santana, to Quinn, to Rachel and back around. Santana just totally blanked out. Her face was expressionless. But her brows were knitted together. A headeache started to form. But it wasnt from the alcohol. She was completely sober.
"Everybody is gay for you Lezpez" commented Puck.
"When did all of this happen?" asked Blaine.
"Yeah. How did all of this happen?" asked Tina.
"You're such a womanizer Santana" replied Finn.
Santana couldnt take the pressure and heat and all of the interrogation anymore so she got up and quickly ran out of the loft. Quinn tried to get up but Kurt stopped her.
"I'll go check on her. I think you need to fix some things in here" said Kurt before he followed after Santana. He spotted Santana right away but decided to give her space and follow behind her.
Back at the loft, all three girls were ready to explode. Everybody else stayed seated waiting for the drama to spill out.
"This is all both of your fault!" yelled Quinn. Pointing at Brittany and Rachel. All three were standing by now.
"How? We didnt actually do anything!" yelled back Rachel.
"Yes you did! You guys wouldnt back the fuck off! Santana is mine! You knew that but you guys keep butting in!" yelled Quinn.
"I broke up with Sam to be with her only to find out she chose you!" yelled Brittany.
"How was I suppose to know that? You chose Sam over her when she asked you to leave him! Now that she found someone else, you decide to crawl right back to her?!" yelled Quinn. At the corner of her eye, she can see Rachel trying to hide.
"And you! Dont try to hide when you have as much to blame!" yelled Quinn as she pointed at Rachel.
"Well, its not my fault I started to have feelings for her!" yelled Rachel.
"But kissing her the first time was bad enough! Didnt you learn how to back off from that cold slap!? I'll gladly replay it to see if you learn your lesson this time" replied Quinn as she walked closer to Rachel. She suddenly felt slender arms pull her back. She spun around to be found with brown orbs staring at her.
"Thats enough babe" said Santana calmly. Quinn couldnt help but soften at the Latina's words.
"Look. I dont know how this happened. I dont know how this got really out of hand. But I'm sick and tired of you guys fighting over me. It hurts because you guys are really close friends of mine. And given the ability to make or break your heart is not something I want to do." said Santana.
"Brittany. I will always love you and I will always have a spot for you in my heart. But only as a friend. It was nice when we were a couple, but after we broke up, it destroyed our friendship. And I miss that. I miss having my best friend around. Now we're left with jealousy and awkward conversations. It will never be back to how it used to be but I would love it if it happened" said Santana.
Brittany just stared into Santana's brown orbs. Brittany felt guilty about trying to get in between Santana and Quinn. They were her best friends and they clearly loved each other.
"I'm sorry San. I miss being your best friend too. I just feel so lost and lonely because you're not by my side anymore. I hope you forgive me. I never meant to cause any trouble" said Brittany. Santana knew Brittany's apology was genuine so she walked over and hugged Brittany. At least she got her best friend back.
"As for Rachel. Over the past few months, i do admit that we have gotten closer as friends. Thats why when it came to the Brody and the other situation, I had to step in and help you out because I cared about you. I know you can't help but take all those caring actions the wrong way. I didnt even know you were gay. But please understand that I only want you as my best friend also. Nothing more, nothing less" said Santana.
"You're right. I should have stopped the first time. It was wrong to get in between you and Quinn. I promise. I will stop and control myself a little better. No jealousy rampages or suprising kisses" replied Rachel.
"Are you sure? You said you wouldnt try to kiss me again but you did" asked Santana.
"Yes. I promise" said Rachel. Santana walked over and hugged Rachel. They locked pinkies to keep the promise.
"Besides, I think you and Brittany would make a good couple" suggested Santana. It made both Brittany and Rachel blush.
"Now that all that is resolved, I think we should call it a night" announced Kurt.
Everybody helped and cleaned around the loft. It was really late and nobody wanted to go home so they all decided to sleep over.
"I call the couch!" shouted Mercedes.
"I want the couch!" shouted Puck.
"Too bad. I called it first" replied Mercedes.
"Whatever. I'll just sleep on the coffee table" said Puck.
Kurt came out and dumped all of the extra blankets and pillows in a pile. He quickly ran out of the way when everyone else rushed to the pile to make sure they had their own. Mike and Tina shared a blanket and cuddled together by the bookshelf. Puck settled on the coffee table while Finn settled next to it.
"Dude, you know that you might fall off of the table" said Finn.
"Im not worried about it. I barely move around when I sleep" replied Puck.
"Suit yourself" said Finn.
Blaine slept behind the couch after being rejected by Kurt when he asked if he could sleep with him. Brittany slept with Rachel again and Santana with Quinn.
"Maybe this reunion wasnt such a good idea after all" said Quinn.
"You think? We weren't even drunk and shit happened" said Santana.
A/N I never actually played a real truth or dare. In the next chapter, they will play another game. Can anyone guess what it is? Hint: Girls vs Boys. Anyway, tell me what you think. Please review and submit ideas. Thanks for reading!