She's Mine

Summary: When Amy's abusive ex-boyfriend comes back to hurt her and to get his revenge, who will help her? Will her ex-boyfriend become successful or will anyone protect her?

Characters: Amy Dumas, Randy Orton, Greg Davis (OC), Paul Levesque, Trish Stratigias/Chris Irvine, Lilian Garcia/Eddie Guerrero, Lisa Marie Varon, Dave Bautista, Candice Michelle, John Cena, Dawn Marie Psaltis/Jason Reso and some OCs

Disclaimer: I do not own anyone you recognize. I only own Greg Davis and the other OCs

Author's notes: Thanks to those who reviewed! I hope you'll like this fourth chapter! Like what I said, they all live near each other. Don't forget that! Haha. Please review! If you have any suggestions or comments, please let me know!

Chapter Five: Almost Over

xoxoxo

"Paul?"

The blonde man lifted his head from the vegetables he was chopping. "Something wrong?" He asked, turning his head to look at the redhead.

"There's something I've gotta tell you…" Amy exchanged a look with Randy. "Actually, there's something we need to tell you."

An eyebrow arched; Paul suddenly having a feeling that he knew what she was about to say. He knew there was a reason why Randy was in his house. "What is it?"

She bit her lower lip for a moment. "Randy and I are together…"

"You two are together…" He faced forward once more before he faced the two again with his back leaning against the counter; the knife he was using still to chop the vegetables in his hand. "When did you start dating?"

"Three hours ago." Randy replied, silently praying that Paul wouldn't go on his overprotective mode. "It's kinda a long story actually…"

Paul didn't say anything. He was just looking at them with this expression on his face that both she and Randy couldn't name. Amy was beginning to get nervous now. She didn't know how Paul would react and that didn't help her any better.

"Let me make this clear, Orton." Paul broke the silence, surprising the newly formed couple as he took a few steps forward. "You and I are friends but once you do anything that would hurt Amy, no matter how small or big it is? I will hurt you." He pointed the knife he was holding towards Randy, as if using it to make sure that the brown haired man got his point.

Amy couldn't help but roll his eyes. "Too much violence, Paul…"

"Dude, relax… Don't do anything with that knife." Randy raised his hands in defense. "I won't hurt her. I promise, Paul. I could never do that to her. You have my word." A beat passed. "Besides, I wanna save myself from all the headache and the ass-kicking that eleven people will give me if I hurt her."

"I'm holding you to that promise, Orton." He carefully dropped the knife on the table. "Take good care of her."

The redhead walked towards the blonde man she always considered as her older brother while Randy let out a sigh of relief behind her before he silently left for the living room. He knew that Paul and Amy needed to talk privately about everything that happened for the past days. "You okay?" She asked. "You're too quiet."

"Everything that happened just surprised me a lot, that's all." He wrapped an arm around her shoulders. "First, I find out about what Greg to you. God knows how much I wanna kill him right now but I know you don't want any more trouble. Now, I find out that you and Randy are dating."

"Do you think it's wrong that we're dating?" Questioning hazel eyes looked up at him. "You aren't in favor of us being together?"

He shook his head. "It's not that. Randy's a good guy, despite his immaturity and the other things wrong with him." He smirked when the redhead nodded in agreement. "It's just that… Everything happened so fast these past days."

"I decided to date Randy because I know I'm falling for him. It feels so right." A smile graced her face. "I know I made the right decision."

"I'm happy that you're happy." Paul gave her shoulders a gentle squeeze. "And I wanna say sorry for the way I acted when you told us about Greg. I know I shouldn't have forced you. I know I shouldn't have gotten mad at you. I'm sorry, Ames."

She wrapped an arm around his waist and rested her head on his chest. "You don't have to worry about it. I understand."

He opened his mouth to say something but he decided to do otherwise when Randy appeared in the kitchen once more. "Can we help you?"

"Actually, you can." Blue eyes rolled. "I was wondering if you guys are done. I want to spend time with my girlfriend."

The blonde man raised an eyebrow once more. "And do you mean you want to spend time with her without me around?"

"You're such a dork." Amy punched his chest playfully. "We'll just be in the living room while you finish dinner, okay? Yell if you need help."

"Am I eating dinner here?" Randy smirked.

"Hell, no." Paul snorted, causing the younger man to glare at him. "You two behave, alright? And stay away from the bedroom."

The couple rolled their eyes once more at him. Paul pressed a kiss on the redhead's forehead before she and Randy exited the kitchen. A sigh his lips as he turned his attention back to the vegetables. He was happy that he was able to apologize to Amy. What made him happier was that Amy was happy, especially now that she was with Randy. He had to admit that Randy wasn't one of his ideal men for the woman who was like a sister to him but when he said that the brown haired man was good guy, he knew he was speaking the truth. But once he hurts her? His life would be hell on earth. I promise that.

xoxoxo

"So, when do you plan on killing her?" A green eyed man asked. "Or you can't do it?"

"It takes time to plan, Dan." Another man replied. "It's not like I can just go to her and kill her, can I? She's surrounded by her friends and she's staying in Paul's house for the meantime."

Dan nodded slowly. "Just do what you have to do, Greg. The more time we waste, the more chances there are of our secret spilling out."

"Trust me." An evil grin graced Greg's handsome face. "I know what to do."

xoxoxo

The next day…

As Randy and Amy had expected from the time they became a couple, their friends, especially Trish, Lilian, Lisa, Candice and Dawn, will go hysterical about their relationship. When the couple told the rest of the gang about it when they were all in Eddie's home, the girls began screaming, hugging the redhead and asking for details about what happened in the beach. Randy, on the other hand, had five pairs of eyes looking at him as if they were telling him not to hurt Amy or else he would pay big time. Paul watched from the door as all of this took place, a smirk forming on his lips before he shook his head.

"Okay, that's enough." He said as he reached behind him to shut the door. "Girls, please stop screaming unless you want everyone to become deaf. Guys, trust me… Randy knows very well what will happen to him if he hurts Amy so stop looking at him like that."

"And what did you do to him?" Dawn raised an eyebrow at the blonde man.

Randy rolled his eyes. "He was in his overprotective mode, trust me. He was holding a knife when he gave me his warning."

"That's because I was chopping vegetables, Orton." Paul sat on the couch. "You didn't do anything bad to her so I won't use that knife yet."

"Violent much…" Candice then sent a questioning look at Randy. "So, when and where do you plan on taking her for your first date?"

His trademark smirk graced his handsome face. "It's a secret. First of all, I wanna surprise Ames. Second, I don't want any of you following us around."

"Make sure you're first date will be good, got it?" Chris shook his finger at him. "If it doesn't? You'll regret it."

"Quit the warnings already." Amy joined her boyfriend on the other couch opposite the one Paul was sitting on. "I think he's got enough of them."

The tattooed man let out a sigh of relief as he took one of her hands in his. "Thank you so much."

"Okay, it's time to watch a movie!" Eddie announced as he, John and Jason rummaged through his DVD collection; the group at large deciding to watch the Exorcism of Emily Rose soon after.

xoxoxo

Greg paced back and forth in his room. He had to do think of something before Dan gets pissed off with all the time and opportunity he was wasting. What am I gonna do now? Killing Amy isn't that easy. Besides, I still want my revenge on her for breaking up with me. He sat on his bed and ran a hand through his blonde hair.

"What the…" His blue eyes fell on his phone. "Whoever you are, make sure you have a good reason to call." He pushed the 'talk' button and brought the phone to his ear. "Hello?"

"Guess what we found out?"

The blonde man frowned, not liking the tone of the man he was talking to. "What?"

"Amy is dating Randy."

"That slut…" Greg said furiously. "I told her that she belongs to me. She doesn't belong to anyone but me."

"So what do you plan on doing now?"

He closed his eyes shut for a moment. "Thanks for telling me, Robin. Hey, listen. I want you and Carlos to go here in my house tomorrow, okay? We have something important to do."

Everything happened so fast these past days.

xoxoxo

Sorry if this chapter is short! )

Thanks to those who reviewed!!