A/N: I just want to thank everyone who has Favorited/Followed/Reviewed/Read my story. It really is fun. I have an idea for a real chapter fic, and I don't know how it will affect my weekly updates. I will try my hardest to keep it up, but this idea really wants to get out. I will officially have a chapter where the Guardians find out that Jack and Phil are friends. Right now, they don't realized that all this time it has been the same yeti. North may have but he hasn't really been paying attention. Anyways, on to the story. Hope you all like it.

Jack slipped a small smile to Phil as they both entered the room. The winter spirit had his hands full with a silver tray, filled to the brim with cookies. A chocolate and minty scent rose from them, and he couldn't help but savor the smell. By the way they looked, he wanted to take one of these for himself but he couldn't do that. These were made especially for the guardians, all of whom were waiting for the winter spirit to get back.

Sandy was the first to notice when Jack entered the room, which worked perfectly with the winter spirit's plan. He smiled at the little man and offered the cookie tray to him. Sandy beamed and floated over to him. When he reached forwards to grab one, Jack lowered the tray and put it in a position where Sandy could easily grab one of the three biggest ones.

"Wha's that, Frostbite?"

Jack had to repress the smirk that wanted to come, and he turned and offered the tray to the other three Guardians. They had all come closer now, and could see the treats that Jack held.

"Cookies, made them myself." He said proudly.

North looked impressed. These looked like masterpieces. He didn't think the winter spirit would be such a good cook. He reached for one of the cookies, trying to pick a larger one, but Jack rotated the tray so the Russian wouldn't take notice of the two remaining big ones in the back.

Tooth looked nervous, but Jack expected that. She didn't do to well with sugar.

"Come on, Tooth. Its just one, and I will personally help you make sure everyone cleans their teeth after this." Jack flashed her a sweet smile, and she had to give in. Who could say 'no' to those teeth? She reached for one, but Jack didn't need to worry about keeping the large cookies out of her grasp. The fairy made sure to grab one of the smaller ones that were on the tray.

Bunny was the last. He looked suspicious. The other Guardians stared at him expectantly. They wouldn't take a bite out of theirs until Bunny got his. "Wha's in them?" His nose twitched as he tried to find something wrong with them.

"Nothing, these ended up exactly like they were supposed to."

That caught Bunny's attention. "An' wha are they supposed to be?" He eyed the boy closely, trying to see any signs of a prank or trick.

North's hand suddenly grabbed another cookie from the tray and the big guy pushed it into Bunny's paw. "Ha! They are cookies, what else? Let us enjoy them!"

Bunny sighed and gave in. He took one more look at the winter spirit before putting the cookie in his mouth.

Jack held his laughter in. He had to, or else it would be ruined. His eyes shot between the different Guardians. He kind of wished he didn't do this to Tooth, but the more people he got with this, the more confusing it would be. He didn't dare breathe as the Guardians ate his treats. The cookies barely touched their tongues when each of their eyes widened in disgust and the cookies were thrown to the ground. Everyone's, except Sandy's. He finished his cookie with a smile, and licked his lips. He saw the other's reactions and stared at them strangely. Those were really good, how did none of the others like them?

The rest of the Guardians were staring giving the Sandman looks that said they thought he was crazy. How could he eat that thing?!

Jack tried to stifle a laugh, but Bunny heard it and immediately turned on the boy. Deep emerald eyes pierced the winter spirit. "What?" Jack asked.

Sandy, meanwhile, wanted another one. That last one was just incredible. He went closer to Jack and made a sand cookie above his head. Jack turned the tray towards the little man and handed one of the two remaining larger cookies. Bunny caught sight of it and eyed it cautiously. His ears flattened and he reached for the last big one. Jack tried to keep it out of his grasp, but that made it that much more obvious that it was different from the rest.

When Bunny got a hold of it, he smirked. "No more of ya' tricks." He was about to enjoy a real cookie, when he caught sight of Jack's eyes. They held that same mischievous glint in them... that made his hesitate. Was this really a cookie? He looked back at Jack and decided to try something else.

"Here," He offered it to the winter spirit. "You have one, mate"

He watched closely, trying to see how Jack would react. The kid just gave a smirk.

"Okay." He reached for it, but Bunny pulled it out of his reach.

The Pooka let out a moan of frustration, and he heard North laugh behind him. What the heck was going on with these cookies?! What ever Sandy got, it was obviously really good. Bunny wanted to try what Sandy had tasted, because they often enjoyed the same types of foods, but this annoying kid was making that extremely difficult!

A couple of elves came into the room. They froze when they saw the plate full of cookies, and the guardians. They each gave a smile to each other, than turned to give one to the guardians. North grew worried... It wasn't a cheerful happy smile like they normally gave. It was mischievous... conniving... creepy. They started snickering at them, and it made all the guardians uncomfortable. Why were they acting like that? Sandy grabbed another cookie from the plate, and offered it to them. Immediately they screamed and fled before anything else could happen.

Now Bunny seriously didn't know what to think of these things... He saw a yeti standing nearby and came up with a new idea. Striding right up to him, he shoved the cookie into the yeti's paws. "You'r a cook, righ'? You tell me wha's wrong with this." He knew the yetis were in charge of making all the treats here at the pole. This guy would sort this all out.

Phil smirked and sniffed it, taking it into his paws. He eyed it carefully, trying to make it seem like he didn't know what to think of it. He gave a small glance towards Jack and tossed the cookie in his mouth. He had missed the warning look Jack had been trying to give him, but he knew instantly that something went wrong. He tried not to gag. He had to make this look real, otherwise this all would fall apart. Their whole set up would be ruined. He faked chewing, and pretended to swallow the demon cookie. All the while, he felt his tongue growing numb from it's taste. He needed water. Oh Man! Water was needed in about three minutes... come on, stop watching so he could leave and get rid of this thing that was attacking his mouth! Note to self... never get involved in these kind of pranks again. Why hadn't he gotten the normal cookie? He had been waiting for it, they were actually really good. Jack was a quick learning and cooking was a fun way to pass the time for him. Phil was seriously just about to drop this whole thing and spit out the cookie when he heard a sigh.

Bunny had bought his bluff and now had a face of disbelief. The guardian turned back towards the winter spirit to try and figure this out. Phil, right when he was no longer the center of attention, turned towards an exit. He wanted to just bolt for it, to wash this awful taste from his mouth, but he restrained himself. He lasted this long, he could last five more seconds.

Jack, meanwhile, gave an apologetic look to the fleeing yeti, then tuned his attention back to the other guardians. They all had their eyes on him, and he decided to use this change of events in his favor. Sure, it wasn't their original plan, but it would still work out in the end.

Jack grabbed a hold of the last remain 'safe' cookie and took a bite out of it. He heard Tooth gasp, and North had looked like he was going to stop him. Bunny looked really pissed off, and Sandy... He was the most confused of all of them.

He looked at the four of them, and sighed. "I don't know what your problem is, guys. These are pretty good for a first timer, but whatever. If you don't want anymore, I'll just put these back in the kitchen." He finished off his cookie and started to leave the room.

When he was out of their sights, he shoved his plate into a passing yeti, yelling back "Don't eat them, throw them out. Trust me." He than flew off, speeding through the halls searching for Phil and where he went off to.

"Phil!" He called out, trying to find his lost friend. He passed by the kitchens, and decided that the yeti deserved a real treat after taking that for Jack. He grabbed two cookies from the plate that held the cookies that Sandy had eaten, and he grabbed a large glass of milk, along with a glass of water. Jack knew he would need to wash the taste out, and its better to do that with water... The milk was for the other two cookies. He was out of the kitchen in a flash and out looking for Phil.

:::

Sandy looked at the other guardians as they stared at the door Jack had just left.

He created a ? above his head.

"So wait... were those cookies all the same? Or..." Tooth fluttered hesitantly, looking at the others.

North shook his head in confusion. What had those elves been snickering at? After his first taste of the cookies, he thought it was just a prank, but Sandy... Phil... and then Jack himself...

Bunny knew for sure something was going on here. He just needed to figure out what. He stormed out of the room, ignoring the calls of North and Tooth, and tried to find out where Jack ran off to.

It only took a couple of minuets to figure out which way Jack had gone. Bunny got close and heard him talking. He paused in his steps, and waited, eavesdropping on Jack's conversation.

"-thought I could catch your attention. I am so sorry. Thanks for keeping with it though. I think we pulled it off quiet nicely."

A growl responded, and Bunny realized he was talking to the yeti that had taken one of the cookies, and had said it was good. He leaned closer, to make sure he caught every word.

"Yeah." Jack continued, replying to something the yeti had growled out. "We probably can't do something like that for awhile though. Bunny almost got it figured out which cookies were real, and which were my little demon ones." Jack gave a chuckle.

Bunny decided that he was done hiding. He jumped out from behind the corner and grabbed Jack before he could run off. "Ah'ha!" He exclaimed. "I knew it! Ya' lit'le bugga'! I knew there was something wrong with those things. Why'd ya give Sandy the real ones?"

Jack glared at his captor, and didn't bother trying to get free. This guy's grip was solid. "Sandy was the first one who came up to me. I didn't want to chance giving him a bad one and have him eat it before you guys got yours. If he took a bite, you all would have known something was up with them." He explained, giving only a half truth. Sandy had been the only one of the guardians to really pay him any attention through his 300 years alone. He wanted to do something nice for him, and not playing a prank on him seemed like a good start.

Bunny meanwhile, just rolled his eyes. "So, did you really cook all the cookies? Or did you have this guy make the edible ones?" He asked as he pointed to the yeti.

Jack looked offended. "No way! All of those were made by me, and my skill. If you don't believe me, lets go in the kitchen and I'll show you!"

From the fire in his eyes, Bunny knew that Jack was telling the truth. "Well... That may be true, but is yer skill any good? Thanks to yer lit'le games, I haven' had the pleasure of tastin' yer cooking."

Jack noticed the look that Bunny gave him, and decided that he'd let him, as well as the rest of the Guardians, get some of his real cookies. They were quite good, according to Phil. In Jack's mind they were nothing compared to the yetis cooking... but then again, they did have a few more years of experience with these kinds of things.

"I'll go grab it." Jack said, though he didn't move to get them yet, seeing as Bunny still had a firm grip on him. Phil, though, interrupted before the winter spirit shot off. He offered that he could get the treats for the Guardians. Bunny seemed to agree with this, and gave a nod of thanks while taking Jack back to the room with the other guardians. The last words Phil heard of the two of them were Jack's complaints, and Bunny's insistence that he go apologize to the others.

When Phil reached the kitchen, he found a yeti in there. That wasn't really a surprise. What was was the fact that the other yeti seemed to just be staring intently at Jack's plate of cookies. Phil growled out a question, asking what in the world he was doing. The yeti only responded that he couldn't see anything wrong with these, yet Jack had said to throw them out. It seemed like such a waste of such good looking treats.

Phil then realized that those cookies were his demon ones, and he quickly grabbed ahold of it before the other yeti got any ideas. The head yeti assured his co-worker that they needed to go. They were anything but good treats. His assurance seemed to convince the other yeti, and he left the kitchen to Phil.

He stood alone in the room, holding the platter of cookies. Now that he saved anyone else from eating these things, he set out for the Guardians, ready to give them Jack's delicious cookies.

It took him a moment, and he was thankful that no one saw, but he realized that he was about to go offer the Guardians the prank cookies again. He laughed at himself a bit, then grabbed the correct plate. After a moments thought, he took one cookie from the other tray and placed it on his own. He than headed back towards the others.

:::

While waiting for their real treats, North was curious as to what was really in those cookies. Jack happily started telling them his recipe. They eyes widened in shock and often times, they let out sounds of disgust at some of the things that went in them. It was amazing that Jack had gotten them to look real. He smirked when they said that. That was his favorite part, that they could pass for real cookies just by looking at them. That's what had given him the most trouble when he first tried making them. There were moments when he almost gave up on the whole idea. Now that the recipe was complete, though, he was glad he stuck through with it till the end.

When the door opened, and Phil came in, all the Guardians turned and looked at the plate in his paws. North, Tooth, and Bunny couldn't wait to try the cookies, and Sandy was eager to have another one.

When Phil reached them, he first offered one to Toothiana. She took one of the smaller ones, like before, but she smiled and didn't hesitate. Jack made these for them, and she was actually excited to try one. North was offered two at a time, since Phil knew the big man would be coming back for more soon enough. Bunny made sure he took his own, just in case Jack had asked the yeti to pull another fast one on him. When Sandy got his, he was the first to finish it, even faster than North. He really liked the cookies.

Jack was a bit surprised when Phil held one out to him, but he smiled and took it. He gave his thanks before taking a large bite out of it. Immediately his eyes widened, and he almost gagged. After spiting the vile thing out, his hand shot towards one of the glasses of milk that had also been brought. It was gone in a flash, and Jack reached for another cup to get rid of that taste.

Bunny broke out into laughter when he saw Jack get a taste of his own medicine. Tooth looked worried, but she was also trying to hide a smile, showing that she thought it was funny as well. North let out a chuckle and gave Jack a strong pat on the back, nearly causing him to choke on his milk, while Sandy gave a look towards Phil.

He shrugged and smiled at the little man. Jack really should have seen that coming.