A/N: Hey I just want to say I love you all for your likes, reviews, and questions! I know some of you are going to be mad but this is a Cooperfeld chapter. As an avid Faking it Fanfic reader I thought you guys deserved a warning. That being said, don't lose hope or skip out Karmy lovers.

Don't judge me. I know less than an hour ago I was begging Karma to be with me and to speak up. Karma and I agreed to give this "us" thing a try but we didn't say we were dating. Not that it mattered any, Lauren didn't care either way. As soon as she came in my room, she asked me if I was dating Karma. I know I should've spoken up but I couldn't. A naked Lauren Cooper was standing in my doorway. I wasn't even sure what she asked until she repeated it.

"N-No. Where did you get that from?" I barely managed to get out. She was doing what she did best, being the intimidating Lauren Cooper.

She walked over to my bed and straddled me before saying, "Are you sure? You guys seemed pretty intimate earlier."

"We talked about pursuing more but we aren't actually dating." I wasn't sure exactly why I told Lauren that. I didn't need to defend myself. It wasn't actually Lauren's business but my subconscious wanted Lauren to know that I was available. It didn't help that Lauren was naked, straddling me, and pouting. Any one of those things were enough to break me, all three together were enough to get whatever she wanted from me.

"Good because I wouldn't want you to end our little arrangement for some girl who's just going to break your heart." Lauren knew just how to fuel a fire and I might as well been covered in gasoline.

"You don't have to be mean just because you are jealous." I quipped back, surprised that I could even respond because of her hold on me.

"Maybe I am jealous Raudenfeld. Where does that leave us?"

I was shocked by her question. Yesterday I wasn't sure either girl liked me but tonight both girls told me they wanted me. I never actually expected to be having this conversation with Lauren ever. So I answered honestly.

"Honestly Lo, I don't know. I care about you and I care about her."

"Then I'll share you for now until you can make a choice."

"Lo, that's not fair to you."

"At least I know. And honestly I don't know if I could stay away from you if I tried. I feel like I come in your room every other night."

Lauren was being genuine and sincere with me. I adored that. It was moments resembling that that truly made me like Lauren. She always looked me in the eyes and it made me seem like she saw the real me. Not the hard exterior that most people saw. Not the goofy, womanizing basketball player. The companionship that I felt with Lauren was enough to want to be with her. Not to say that the sex wasn't good, it was great. Lauren had no quips in the bedroom. Other than the step sister thing, I didn't really see a reason not to be with her. There was no fear of Lauren breaking my heart or playing with my emotions. I don't know if I could say the same for Karma but it was that fear that drove me toward Karma. Love is about taking risks and I think Karma is worth it. Not to say that there weren't dangers with Lauren too.

Both girls gave me that free falling feeling. You know that feeling where you feel like you jumped off of a bridge and the only person who could save you was the person who gave you that feeling. Both girls made me was to send emojis with heart eyes and kissy faces versus the purple devil one with the smirking face that I sent to hook ups. Maybe this was the best plan, share them both until I made a decision. Karm wouldn't be happy if she thought we were dating but I am not ready to dive in with either girl, until I know which girl to free fall for. I'm not one for playing games but if 2/3 of the group knew what was going down, it wouldn't end too bad right? I know I'll regret this later but I told Lauren let's do this.

Lauren was right, aside from the fact that we live together, I honestly don't think I could stay away from her. After she kissed me, I knew that I couldn't stay away from her. All I could think about was Lauren Cooper. All I could smell was Lauren Cooper' shampoo and breathe. All I could hear was Lauren Cooper's panting and breathing. All I could taste was Lauren Cooper's Coconut Chap stick. All I could feel was Lauren Cooper's soft skin against my hands, her body so close to mine. Lastly, when we broke apart, all I could see was Lauren Cooper in my arms, looking at me the way I look at donuts. Lauren Cooper keeps leaving me breathless.

Fuck, this is going to end badly.

"Just spend the night with me. I don't want to do anything more than make out."

Despite the fact I was the one who said it, I could barely contain myself when Lauren kissed me again. If she'd spoken aloud what her kiss said, it would go something like this, "Hmm no sex tonight? I like your intentions but I'm going to make you regret it."

I did regret what I said but I stood my ground. We made out until we literally couldn't anymore. Then we cuddled with me as the big spoon of course. Who could've imagined two months ago when this started that I'd be with Lauren, holding her like my life depended on it, wishing I could take her on a real date and talk for hours.

Two Months Ago

Reagan was supposed to meet me after the game but she canceled and I was raging horny. I'd decided against going to Shane's party because I was tired of drinking and loud music. I wasn't in the mood to endure all of that just to get laid. I scrolled through my phone but realized most would be at the party. I decided to just watch TV and wait another day. I was tired anyway. Tired and annoyed. I was in the kitchen popping popcorn when Lauren stormed in. . . .

"Who burst your bubble?" I said to her.

"No one really. I was supposed to hang out with some of the squad but they bailed on me for Shane's party that I don't want to go to." She said, which I found out later was a lie.

"Well that makes two of us. Want to watch a move or something?" I asked, half expecting her to say something bitchy or to say no.

"I guess Amy but I get to pick." She said and walked into the living room.

I wasn't planning to hook up with Lauren. It hadn't even crossed my mind. Lately, Lauren and I have been trying this whole sister thing. We didn't have to be enemies. Plus we have to see each other everywhere, school, home, games, and parties. We both were reluctant to getting to know each other when Farrah and Bruce got married. On another night like this, we talked and realized that even though we were kind of opposite, we could be friends. Lauren wasn't as awful as her head cheerleader alter ego.

When I sat down in the living room, Lauren wasn't in there but I realized that she had gone to change into pajamas, a baby blue t-shirt and a pair of white and blue shorts when she came back down. She grabbed the remote and flopped down on the couch only 6 inches away from me and curled her legs under her. We were just close enough for me to be able to feel her body heat. Of course I noticed, I was a literal ball of horniness waiting to explode. She used her Amazon Prime to put on Black Swan. I didn't mind because Natalie Portman is fucking hot and fucking crazy.

STOP READING THIS RIGHT NOW AND GO LOOK UP Natalie Portman Raps on YouTube. The rest of the chapter can wait. Done? Okay good.

Between Mila Kunis, Natalie Portman, and my raging hormones, I was all but staring at Lauren like a piece of meat and when the sex scene that I had forgotten about I couldn't handle it. Lauren's proximity to me was driving me crazy. Throughout the movie, she had involuntarily scooted toward me. Instead of making a move, I decided to try to eat my horniness away. Sounds good right? Wrong. As an alternative of grabbing a handful of popcorn, I accidently grabbed a handful of Lauren's thigh. She didn't flinch or wince in pain, she moaned. Not just any moan but quite possibly the sexiest moan that I'd ever heard in my life. The fact that I was two seconds from dry humping all of the walls in the house, probably contributed to that belief though. With any other girl on any other night, I probably would've teased her about the moan or just squeezed her thigh and continued the movie but that night with Lauren, we didn't need games. I just leaned over and kissed her. She was surprised but that didn't stop her from kissing back.

The kissing was just as hot and heavy as it was tonight. Lauren's lips tasted like cherries back then before she made a shift in Chap Stick flavors. The kissing was just as hot and heavy then as it was tonight. Before I knew it, she was lying on her back on the couch and I was hovering over her, my hair cascading around us. I moved to lift her shirt off of her, revealing a red and black lacy bra. Once her shirt fell to the ground, her hands found their way to my hair. Besides wrapping it around her fingers, I realized that she had a ponytail holder on her wrist. She put my hair into a ponytail, her lips never leaving me. I slipped my hand underneath her and lifted her enough to unhook her bra. As I began slipping off the straps, she immediately stopped kissing me.

"I'm not having sex on the couch Amy. Follow me." She said as I stared at the portion of her breasts that wasn't covered by her bra. She took my hand and led me up the stairs to her room. As soon as the door shut, I backed her up against it and slipped her bra from her shoulders and replaced it with my hands. Lauren let out another sexy moan as I started playing with her nipples, rolling them between my thumb and pointer finger.

I leaned forward so that my mouth was at her ear and whispered "Are you sure about this? We can stop at any time. I won't be mad but I may be bitchy from the serious case of blue balls."

Part of me wished she'd back out while the other part (the crazy horny part) prayed she'd take the rest of her clothes off.

"I want this. It's been awhile since I've gotten off and I know your good from how loud the company is that you have over. Just know this doesn't make us a thing." I hadn't really thought past getting in her panties but it's not like I wanted a relationship either.

"Yea I know" I said as I pressed my lips to her neck and licked the hollow beneath her ear. She shivered and moved her hands that had been against the door, under my shirt to explore my waist and stomach. Just the light touch of her hand has me ready to hump her leg. I kissed my way down to her collarbone and sucked on the base of her throat.

She moaned louder and pulling at my shirt said "I can't stand for much longer Amy!" I moved back so she could pull my shirt over my head then led her over to the bed where I gently pushed her down and straddled her as I reached back to unhook my bra.

I leaned down until my lip was a breath away from her nipple and looked up into her heavy-lidded blue eyes and whispered "Is that better?" She nodded frantically in response.

Then, keeping eye contact, I pulled her nipple into my mouth and sucked. Lauren squeezed her eyes shut and threw her head back against the bed. I tortured her nipple for a while and then licked my way over to the other one and gave it the same treatment. Her hands slipped into my hair just as I started moving south, my hands moving to the sides of her shorts and urged her to lift her hips so that I could pull them down. Once they were off, I sat up and spread her legs so I could get a good look.

"You're so pretty Lo" I said mesmerized and let one hand glide up her leg to touch her glistening clit.

A flush spread from her face down to her chest as she gripped the sheets and whimpered "Maybe you should get a better look. You're kind of far." I smirked at her neediness and dove in head first to my meal.

She screamed. I actually made Lauren cooper scream. That only amped me up more as I started licking circles on her clit. Her hands moved to grip my hair and I let my tongue glide down to slip inside her. She raised her knees and I swear tried to squeeze my head till it popped as I replaced my tongue with only one finger, since she said it's been awhile. Hey I'm a considerate girl ;). I moved back up to suck on her clit and started fucking her in earnest. I pumped faster and faster and added another finger. I sat up to watch her squirm and groan as my other had reached up to take turns squeezing her breasts.

I could see that she was close so I lead forward to whisper in her ear "Come for me Lo. I want to hear my name on your lips because I made it happen." And she did. Hard. She threw her head back and was so loud I had to kiss her, still working her pussy, to quiet her. I slipped my fingers out of her and wrapped arms around her as she came down.

As soon as her breathing became normal again, she was reaching for my shorts and slipped them down my legs. I didn't think she would be so willing to reciprocate but she actually seemed eager for which I was grateful because by then my pussy was throbbing. She pushed me down so that I was lying flat on my back and all but ripped my panties off.

"You seem pretty confident about this" I quipped at her.

She spread my legs wide and looked up and said "Well, I'm a fast learner and you just taught me one hell of a lesson." Then thrust two fingers into my beyond ready pussy.

She caught me off guard and so I was unprepared for the loud half groan half grunt that escaped my mouth. And she just continued to fuck me, keeping up the same rhythm and letting her other hand roam all over my body from my clit to my breasts.

"I like this. I like the sounds you make, how you feel, how you smell, and" she leaned down to swirl her tongue around my clit and looked up to meet my gaze, "how you taste." And that's all my poor deprived body could take. I exploded around her fingers and on her tongue. She didn't stop pumping into me until I made it to the other side of the wave. We kept switching throughout the night we couldn't keep our hands off of each other. I found out later that night that she'd come home angry because her and Tommy were supposed to hook up but he'd bailed on her. She wouldn't tell me why though but I didn't care. I was grateful I got the benefit of it.

I should've known back then that this would be a recurring thing. But even I couldn't have accounted for this Karma thing. As I lay spooning with Lauren, I thought about all of the possibilities for us and the future. I couldn't help but smile.

A/N: Is Amy going to be able to juggle both girls? Is she even going to want to since she seems so happy with Lauren? Especially since she all but forgot her for Lauren. Sorry Karmy fans. But Cooperfeld shippers don't get too comfortable.

I also wanted to shout out to all of the other Authors! IHeartKarmy is amazing, H.L. Bailey's this was always home I am subscribed to for updates and walkthatlonesomevalley writes nothing but greatness! Shout out to all the authors in general I don't want my note to be too long but honestly I've read tons of faking it fan fics and I love them all! This is my first fic and I love all the love you guys show me and I wanted to show y'all some love! I genuinely love them all. Shout out to the admins who do everything needed to post these amazing stories and showcase these amazing writings.