What ifs? Part Two
"Your here, in Lima...with a child?" He said looking at her and Levi
"Yeah, this is my son..Levi" She said looking at him, nervously
"Your son, that's great..your married?" Puck asked looking at the little boy
"No i'm single, it's just me and him" She said looking at him
"Oh, is Santana back aswell?" He looked at her
"Yeah she's at home with Taylor, I should get going it's his bedtime soon" She said bending down picking levi up
"Yeah okay, maybe we could go for a cup of coffee sometime?" Puck said looking at her, wondering who taylor was
"Yeah maybe, i'll text you... see you later" Rachel said walking away from him
Who's Taylor?, Santana's moved on from Finn and Rachel has a son. Has she moved on from me? Obviously if she has a son, and how's she going to text me, does she still have my number...
Rachel walked straight past her fathers house taking the long way home, in shock after meeting him..She got to her apartment carrying a sleeping Levi to his bedroom, before walking back into the living room where Santana was sitting watching tv...
"I bumped into him" Rachel said quickly standing at the living room door
"And who's him exactly?" Santana said giggling at her
"Puck, I seen Puck on my way to my dads" She looked at her with a straight face
"What?!" Santana stood up looking at her, shocked
"I know and he wants to go for coffee with me" Rachel started pacing back and forward "He was asking about you, about Levi, he asked me if i was married?"
"What'd you say when he asked about me?" Looking at her scared
"That you were at home with Taylor. He didn't ask who Taylor was" Rachel said as she looked out the window
"Are you going to go for coffee with him?" Santana said walking over to her
"I don't know, i kinda want to but do i tell him about Levi being his?" looking at Santana, worried
"Rach i don't know the answer to that, i think that if you were going to tell him then i wouldn't tell him straight away" Santana said reaching over to take her hand
"I need to think about it some more before i make a decision, thanks tana" She smiled squeezing her hand before walking to her bedroom
Rachel sat in her room looking at pictures of her and puck back in high school before picking up her phone texting Puck... "Tomorrow at the little cafe outside of lima?"
I was sitting in my apartment looking at pictures of me and Rachel from high school, when my phone went off 'Rachel x' I text her back saying "The one on the corner? Sounds good..say 12 o'clock?"
Rachel texted him back saying alright and she'd see him then. After that Rachel got ready and went to bed...
The next day Rachel asked Santana to watch Levi while she went and met Puck. Rachel walked all the way to the cafe to see Puck already sitting there..
"Hi" Rachel said as she sat down, looking at him nervously
"Hey, how are you?" he said smiling softly
"I'm good, you?" Rachel looked at him smiling
"Can I ask you something?" He looked at her
"Of course" Looking at him, nervously
What is he going to ask me? He's going to ask why we left, Do I tell him the truth? We both found out we were pregnant and were terrified yous would hate us so we ran
"Why did you and Santana leave after graduation? Didn't yous love me and Finn?" He looked at me
"I-Of course I loved you Noah" Rachel looked at him, nervously feeling her eyes beginning to water "I can't tell you why, you'll hate me even more than you probably already do"
"I don't hate you, i could never hate you, I just don't get why you'd leave me?" Looking at her "please tell me Rach"
"We both found out we were..we were pregnant" looking down at her hands, scared "I'm so sorry"
"You mean that little boy you were with yesterday is, is my son?" Puck looked at her annoyed "You kept my son from me for 3 years!"
