Same Old Love

The glee club where sitting in the choir waiting for Mr Schue to come. Rachel was sitting with Santana at the piano away from everyone else with two pairs of eyes on them. Puck and Finns.

"What are they talking about?" Finn said looking at the girls and then at Puck

"I have no clue man, but I want to know why Rachel is acting weird with me" Puck stared straight at his best friend

"Yeah, I want to know why San won't talk speak to me too" He said looking at their girlfriend and best friend

"Alright guys, let's get today's practice started. Does anyone have anything they want to show us, maybe something for sectionals?" Mr Schue said walking in rubbing his hands together like he normally does

"We do Mr Schue" Rachel said looking at Santana and back to Mr Schue

"Okay Rachel and Santana, take it away" He said walking over to sit next to Puck and Finn

Rachel/Santana/Both

Take away your things and go
You can't take back what you said, I know
I've heard it all before, at least a million times
I'm not one to forget, you know

Puck looked at his best friend as she started singing a type of song he hadn't heard her sing before, he looked at Finn before looking back as Santana started singing

I don't believe, I don't believe it
You left in peace, left me in pieces
Too hard to breathe, I'm on my knees
Right now, 'ow

I'm so sick of that same old love, that shit, it tears me up
I'm so sick of that same old love, my body's had enough
Oh, (that same old love) [2x]
I'm so sick of that same old love, feels like I've blown apart
I'm so sick of that same old love, the kind that breaks your heart
Oh, (that same old love) [2x]

Mr Schue smiled to himself as he realised these two girls might have just choosen the right song that could win them sectional.

I'm not spending any time, wasting tonight on you
I know, I've heard it all
So don't you try and change your mind
Cause I won't be changing too, you know

You can't believe, still can't believe it
You left in peace, left me in pieces
Too hard to breathe, I'm on my knees
Right now, 'ow

Quinn looked at her two best friends as they sang. Wondering what had made them choose this song.

I'm so sick of that same old love, that shit, it tears me up
I'm so sick of that same old love, my body's had enough
Oh, (that same old love) [2x]
I'm so sick of that same old love, feels like I've blown apart
I'm so sick of that same old love, the kind that breaks your heart
Oh, (that same old love) [2x]

I'm so sick of that, so sick of that love

I'm so sick of that, so sick of that love

I'm so sick of that, so sick of that love

I'm so sick of that, so sick of that love

I'm so sick of that same old love, that shit, it tears me up
I'm so sick of that same old love, my body's had enough
Oh, (that same old love) [2x]
I'm so sick of that same old love, feels like I've blown apart
I'm so sick of that same old love, the kind that breaks your heart
Oh, (that same old love) [2x]

Everyone clapped as the girls finished singing, they hugged each other after giggling.

"Girls that was amazing, how did you's decide on that song?" Mr Schue said smiling

"Well I just love the song and when Rae asked me to sing it with her, I couldn't say no" Santana said smiling at her best friend and then looking at all their friends

"And why did you choose the song Rachel?" Mr Schue said surprised that it was Rachel that chose it.

"I'm just sick of all the same old love" Rachel said shrugging her shoulders, glaring at Santana when she elbowed her in the side "And which is why I agreed to let Santana here give me a makeover, meaning no more grandma outfits" She giggled as Santana squealed

Everyone started talking about everything and anything when Rachel felt a hand on her arm pulling her out of the choir room

"What do you mean your sick of all the same old love?" Puck said looking at her confused

"Everything. I mean I keep choicing the wrong guy, I keep getting my heart broken. I'm fed up with all that, I want a new start and Santana showed me that I can do that, I'm taking my life into my own hands not letting all the bullies control it anymore. I can't wait Noah" She looked up at him, biting her lip

"So you're saying I was the wrong guy, that I broke your heart when we went out last year. Cause if you remember it was you that dumped me, I didn't want to break up. I'm happy that your doing that but Rach you don't need a makeover, your beautiful like this" Puck said looking at her, moving closer to her

"No I'm not saying that, you didn't break my heart. Your the only one that hasn't broke my heart, which is one of the reasons why I want to do this" She said looking at him

"What do you mean by that?" Puck said moving a hand up to move a strand of hair out of her face

Puck seen how quickly she turned nervous and scared...

"Because I want to be what you want, I want to be what you want. I broke up with you last year because I felt like I wasn't good enough for you Noah. I want to do this because..because I still love you" Rachel said looking down biting her lip

Puck cupped her cheek in his hand tilting her face up to look at him before leaning down and kissing her passionately before pulling away "I love you too princess, just the way you are. Your everything I want and you are far than enough for me which now makes you my girl now you do realise that?"

"Yeah, I realise that" Rachel giggled looking up at him "But I'm still going ahead with this makeover, it wasn't just for you it's for me aswell"

Puck laughed before nodding his head leaning down and kissing her again just as Mr Schue and everyone came out to see if everything was alright with them.