North and Bunny were in North´s palace when Jack came in.

Until a few hours ago the guardians were discussing about Hiccup being or not a spy. Then Tooth and Sandy went to work and Jack flew away with no particular reason.

"North, I´m back!" Jack yelled when he entered the globe room.

"Jack, boy, we were worried about you" The guardian said while he hugged the winter spirit

"I wasn´t" Bunny said

"Thanks for your love, but I have news" Replied the younger one

"About what?" North asked

"About Hiccup"

"I knew he was a spy!" Bunny exclaimed

"Whoa! Slow down! Who said he was a spy?" Said Jack

"But I thought you said you had news"

"I didn´t said what type of news, come on, let´s call Sandy and Tooth"

….

"But what does 'finish him' means?" North asked to no one in particular.

"I don´t know, maybe it´s a way of saying kill him" Bunny suggested

"It didn´t seemed like it though" Jack said.

Hiccup´s story did give answers, but also questions, and the guardians didn´t like unsolved mysteries.

"Sandy, what do you believe?" North asked Sandy

The guardian of dreams only did a question mark over his head.

….

Hiccup loved the dawn. It was so peaceful, and so… magical.

"I should know you would be here" Said a voice from behind him

Hiccup turned to see who was there "Pitch? What are you doing here?"

"Oh, just checking on you, I can´t afford you being in the war against me"

"Nice, ´cause I am in the war and I am against you" Hiccup answered, mocking Pitch.

"Aren´t you going to apologize?" Asked Pitch, slowly getting closer Hiccup

"Why should I?"

"Well, after all you betrayed me" Pitch was now less than a meter away from Hiccup

"I betrayed you? I wasn´t the one who sent more than a thousand nightmares to attack one single spirit"

"We all made mistakes in the past, I hope you could forgive me for attacking you when you were less expecting it, and with no apparent reason. The thing is that the moon told me you were planning taking over the world with the help of the nightmares" Pitch sat next to Hiccup

"So, you didn´t mean any harm?" Hiccup asked

"No, I thought I was stopping you from becoming evil. You know, we can still be a team. Now that there are no more hostilities."

"No, it´s too late. You harmed innocent people. You use the nightmares to your own good, you use them for evil. And I can´t forgive that" Hiccup stand and walk away from him.

"Come on! Don´t give me one of your classes of philosophy, you know I hate them" As Hiccup didn´t answer Pitch continued "There is no good and evil, just power, and those who are too weak to search for it (notice my harry potter reference)"

"What happened with the spirit who showed me that I am not alone?"

"It is still here, only that you don´t want to see it" Pitch put a hand in Hiccup´s shoulder

Hiccup walked away from Pitch "No, you are not the same, you changed. You are… darker, in more than one way"

"I gave you one chance to join me in good terms and you didn´t accepted it. I will have to do this the other way" Pitch did a signal and lots of nightmares appeared from the shadows and surrounded Hiccup

"You betrayed me!" Hiccup yelled

"Yes, what did you expected? Did you really believe the moon told me to attack you? For the oldest spirit apart from MIM, you are pretty innocent."

The nightmares attacked and Hiccup started fighting them but there were too much of them. Slowly, Hiccup started losing. One nightmare attacked from behind and Hiccup passed out

….

finished. I love cliffhangers! please review. So, Pitch betrayed Hiccup. All the guardians know hiccup´s story. please review!