Chapter Four

Spencer was about to tell Toby about her answer before Cassie walked though the door.

"Hey Tobes, did you miss me?" Cassie said; pulling her red suitcase though his apartment door, as he broke his gaze from Spencer

"Hey. What are you doing back so soon, I thought you were staying in LA for the next two weeks." He replied walking over to her and gave her a kiss on the cheek.

"I go away for two months, and I come back to get a cheek kiss. If I wanted a cheek kiss I would have asked my grandparents. I expect a better kiss from the man I love."

"Alright." They kissed for about 10 minutes; forgetting Spencer was there. She stood there awkwardly, as she was about to confess that she liked Toby as more than just friends, but forgetting about Cassie.

"Ah-hum." Spencer said coughing awkwardly, in to her fist sideways.

"Sorry Spence, forgot you were there." Toby replied.

"So boyfriend, what you want to do? You know a special days coming up in a few days." she said

"I know, it's our three year anniversary."

"Sorry to interrupt, but I'm going to Toby so I'll call you later, bye Cassie."

"Now that she's gone. We can get back to what we were doing."

"There's something I have to tell you Cass." Toby said.

"What?"

"Well last Friday, I kissed Spencer, and I know it was wrong, I need you to trust me and believe me when I tell you that my heart is with you."

"Toby a kiss always means something."

"Yeah but you got to know your my girlfriend, Spencer just my bestfriend okay? Your the one I love." He told her.

"Look I saw the way you looked at her and the way you looked at me. Trust me they were two completely different looks. As far as my theory goes, you and Spencer were meant for each other. You have been by far the best boyfriend I could ever ask for. Go tell Spencer how you feel about her. I always knew you liked her. Don't be afraid to show her how you feel. I always knew but I just wanted to know how it felt two be someone's special girl. And I felt that way with you for two years, and I thank you for that. But I have to let you go. But don't you forget that I will always love you no matter what happens. I got your back Cavanaugh." She explained as she kissed his cheek. "Friends?" She asked.

"Friends. Thank you for being the best girlfriend I could ask for. Will you be here when I get back here?"

"Oh yeah Ofcourse."She said popping a grape in her mouth. "I'm not sure I'll ever leave. You have the best channels in the house. I guess your stuck with me."

Hanna, Emily and Aria sat in the Café. "I never felt this way with Toby ever, and when he kissed me. Everything changed. That's when I knew I liked Toby more than just friends. But he's with Cassie, so it doesn't matter." Spencer told them.

"This is great, the birth of Spoby!" Hanna squealed.

"Hanna hold your horses, they aren't officially a couple yet. So just keep that under-wraps for now." Aria told her.

Wren appeared though the window of the café. He knocked on the glass to make sure Spencer would notice.

"Can we talk." He said under his heavy accent.

"Okay."

"What do you want to talk about?" She asked.

"Breaking up with you was so stupid. I just want to tell you that I'm still crazy in love with you Spence. I guess I never stopped. Ever since we broke up. I've been having this empty hole in my heart for weeks. I miss you Spence."

"I'm sorry Wren, but I'm not in love with you, and I guess I will. I used to be, but that love was only one way. I love Toby now." She explained to him.

"Oh, okay." He said walking away.

"Hey, Spencer have you seen Aria?" Jake asked.

"Yeah, she's inside the café." She pointed inside.

"Are you okay?" he asked.

"No, I'm not, because I think I'm in love with Toby, but Wren just told me he still loved me, and I guess I still love him, but I don't know what to do. I feel like the bachelorette." Spencer asked.

"Well Spencer, who do you think will treat you better? Who do you acutally feel in love with? Those are the questions you should be asking."

"Thanks Jake." she told him.

Spencer was torn between Wren and Toby, she didn't know what to do? Wren's already been her boyfriend, not a great one but still her boyfriend. On the other hand Toby and her have been friends for a long time, they already know each other.

She grabbed her jacket; as she walked to clear her head, and make a decision what's next? She kept walking until she found outside Rosewood going into Ravenswood. The sign read: Welcome to Ravenswood; population: 487,000. She ran her arms around her coffee she bought a few kilometers back.

She turned around and headed back to Rosewood. She made a decision, she found herself walking back to Rosewood. Welcome to Rosewood population 689,000. Sheheaded towards a big brown building. She entered the building towards the elevator, she entered the elevator pushed in the 2nd floor button. As soon as the elevator was done with the first floor she proceed to get off the first stop on the second. She got out, throw away her stryofoam cup in the garbage. As she headed to the apartment door. She took a deep breath as she walked towards the door. She knocked on the door. She knew she making the right decision.

He opened the door.

"Hi." They both said in unison.

Review. Was the to quick? That Spencer gained feelings for Toby? Who'd she choose Toby or Wren?