A few hours later, Sam arrived at Kelly's to meet up with Lucky who was too busy eating ice cream to notice her walking through the door. Sam desperately wanted to turn around and wanted to go home. She starts to turn around walk back out the door until Lucky notice her. "Hey Sam" he shouts. "Oh crap, here we go" she thought to herself. "Come over here and take a seat." Lucky says to her. Sam scoots across the floor over to his table. She sits down slowly like her backside was hurting.
"Do you want some ice cream?" He offered.
"No thanks. I'm good" She answered.
"What's wrong?" He asked not ignoring his ice cream.
"I-I…I have something I have to tell you." Sam reluctantly admits.
"I know I had fun too." Lucky jokes, still not letting up on his bowl of ice cream. "I'm sorry, go ahead Sam."
"You're right. I had so…so much fun and I want that more often. And in order to…to have fun together. I will have to be as honest with you as you are with me. So here it goes." Sam sets up. Lucky is interested in what Sam has to say, but still can't give up on his ice cream. "There's not easy way of saying this, but you need to know. I-I slept with Jason."
"Well duh, you didn't think I knew that?" Lucky says.
"You already knew? What did Elizabeth tell you or something?" Sam asked relieved that Lucky isn't upset.
"Elizabeth didn't have to tell me, I just knew. It was so obvious." Lucky says with a mouth full of ice cream.
"I'm so happy that you understand and you forgive me." Sam says with a little tear in her eyes.
"Of course I understand and forgive you. It was before us." Lucky says still not finished with that ice cream.
"What do you mean? Before today?" Sam asked worried that Lucky didn't understand.
"Before we even realized our feelings for one another and before we even had a thing." Lucky explains.
"I'm confused." Sam says with a face to match.
"Sorry to say, but I didn't think that you and Jason would have dated for 3 years and never done it. I mean I don't want to think about you two doing it, but I mean that's over now and we're together." Sam wanted to leave it just like it was, but it was like her conscious slapped her in the face to set Lucky straight.
"Yes we did it back then….but..." Sam says just as tears began to fall from her eyes.
"But..." Lucky asked.
"We did it recently." Sam cries. Lucky drops his spoon in his ice cream. He starts to speak, but wipes his mouth before doing so.
"How recent?" Lucky asked with his serious look on his face.
"Last night." Sam admits.
"What? When? After I left you guys at Jake's?" Lucky whines.
"Yes…" Sam cries. She places her head on the table and lets out one loud cry then quiets down. She lifts her head up and sees Lucky staring back at her about to cry.
"Lucky, I'm so sorry." Sam breaks the silence.
"Sorry, that's all you can say?" Lucky asked. "How could you do this to us? Or yeah I forgot we weren't together so it didn't matter who you slept with."
"We shared tequila and one thing lead to another." Sam tries to explain.
"Don't blame this on tequila. She's been such a great friend to you and she's with Coop, why would she want you too." Lucky states.
"Lucky, you just confused tequila, the alcohol, with Maxie, my friend." Sam points out.
"I knew that. You just want to make me feel stupid, just like everyone else." Lucky says as he stands up from the table. "I'm out of here."
"Lucky wait, I want to talk this out." Sam says grabbing his arm in hopes that he would stay.
"Why talk this out? It's clear to me that you've already made your choice." Lucky insists yanking his arm away from Sam.
"But Lucky I…." Sam sobs.
"Please don't even finish that line." Lucky says in disgust as he walks out of Kelly's and away from Sam. Sam beings to cry softly as she falls back down into her chair. She pulls Lucky's bowl of ice cream closer to her and takes a whiff before getting up and practically running out of Kelly's wiping her eyes as she goes. Over at the table in the corner, a woman with a paper to her face pulls it down when Sam moves away. It's Elizabeth; she heard the whole conversation and is surprisingly begins to feel sympathetic toward Sam and her situation.