Disclaimer: I don't own anything, but I did use some lines from the last episode!
I hope you enjoy the update! Thanks so much for all the follows/favorites/reviews!
"I don't understand. How can she just disappear like that?" Troian questioned.
"She didn't just disappear, you scared her away! I can't believe that you followed me here!" Shay shouted back angrily, just as in character as her fiancée.
"I thought you were putting yourself in danger!" The brunette said, simply trying to explain.
"Yeah, well you thought wrong!" Shay yelled back with fire in her eyes.
"I know, I thought wrong, I'm sorry!"
"You're gonna have to work harder than that. I betrayed Alison, she's never gonna reach out to me again." Shay said seriously, trying to ignore the adorably quirked eyebrow of her fiancée.
"She's still playing games with us." Troian retorted simply.
"What are you talking about?"
"Ali sucked you back in. She knew that you were pulling away and that's why she picked you. She wanted to make you feel special so that you wouldn't give up on her." She logically responded as Shay reacted perfectly.
"That's sick."
"No, it's brilliant." Troian responded in character, acting slightly impressed.
"It wasn't like that. It was different tonight. She was sincere." Shay said confidently.
"She can trust you, but she's not sure about the rest of us? Don't you get it? She's trying to divide us." The brunette shot back.
"She wouldn't do that."
"Wouldn't she?" Troian asked Shay seriously.
"Wait. You were listening? This whole time?"
"We can't let her come between us." Troian assured the tanned girl as she inched forward slightly.
"I'd say you're doing a really good job of that all on your own." Shay shot back.
"I'm sorry, Shay." The brunette said as she reached out to grab Shay's arms.
"Don't!" She yelled, throwing her arms up in the air and storming off, leaving Troian standing there, breathing heavily.
Troian quickly improvised as she turned and passionately kicked something that was off to her side.
"That was great, ladies. Except for one problem." Norman, their director said with a smirk as they both walked over to him to watch the replay.
"What was wrong?" Troian asked as she stared at the screen intently.
He replayed the whole thing and Troian groaned as they got to her last line.
"No! I said Shay instead of Emily!" The brunette exclaimed as Shay rubbed her fiancée's back with a small smile.
"But that kick at the end of the scene was brilliant." Norman added with a smile as Troian smiled back gratefully.
"I guess I'm just so used to apologizing to this one over here that I just slipped up." Troian exclaimed as Norman chuckled.
"Enough out of you, Miss Bellisario! And for the record, you rarely apologize." Shay said good naturedly, slapping Troian's arm lightly.
"Well what do I need to apologize for?" She scoffed, feigning disbelief.
"For being so perfect and smart all the time. And so gorgeous." Shay said sincerely as Troian picked up an incredibly large smile and leaned in to kiss her quickly on the lips as Norman pretended to not be watching them.
"You want us to take it from the top?" Troian asked him tiredly once she stepped back from Shay.
"Please, and kick that thing again. It was good." He said as the two walked back over to their marks.
"I'm sorry, Shan." Troian said as they got set up for another take.
"Hey, don't be sorry! Everyone makes mistakes. Plus, I'm here with you, so I don't consider it a problem." The raven-haired beauty said as Troian smiled.
"Why are you so awesome?" She asked with a smirk.
"That's a good question." Shay said seriously before breaking into a huge smile.
"That was a fun scene to shoot. Just the two of us." Troian smiled fondly as Shay continued to frantically respond to people's tweets.
"And look at those incredible, incredible legs. And that hot bod! Oh my gosh, who is this creature?" Troian said exasperatedly as they watch Emily storm away from Spencer on the TV.
"Stop!" Shay whined happily, "You're too good at flattery! And I can't afford to get incredibly distracted by you at this moment. The fans demand replies!"
"Well I demand your attention once the episode is over." Troian said sultrily as she ran her hand up Shay's thigh, making the girl shiver slightly.
"Oh, you will have my undivided attention, I assure you." She said after she finished typing out her tweet.
She quickly leaned over to kiss Troian softly before she got back to responding to people.
During the next commercial, Shay was still tweeting, so Troian decided to spend some time checking her twitter as well.
She smirked when she saw the latest tweet from her fiancée.
Ohhh Spencer, you're in trouble now! If looks could kill…. #PLLaywithShay
Troian quickly thought of a comeback and sent it off into the Twitterverse with a smirk on her face.
Better Spencer than Troian.
She replied with a smile before she added another tweet.
When Shay looks at you like that…it's never a good thing. Trust me.
Troian stealthily took a picture of the two of them without Shay even noticing; she added a caption and posted it to Instagram and Twitter.
Lucky for me, she's only looked at me like that once. And that was long ago. Check out this incredible beauty.
Troian uploaded the picture after glancing it over one last time. It was of Shay typing something on her phone with a smile and her glasses on while Troian smiled and pointed happily at her fiancée.
Shay 'awwed' a minute later and then typed something out furiously before she set her phone down at kissed Troian properly.
"I love you." She said, pulling the brunette in for another kiss.
"I love you, too." Troian said, happy that her picture made Shay happy.
Many hours later, Troian picked up her phone one last time before she headed to bed and smiled when she saw the response from her fiancée about that picture.
What can I say? I know how to pick 'em. You and your incredible beauty astound me every day. xx
"What are you doing, babe?" Shay asked tiredly as she wrapped her arms around Troian's waist, placing short kisses along the brunette's shoulders and neck.
"Nothing. I'm just heading to bed. You ready?"
"Oh yeah." She said with a soft smile as she linked her fingers with Troian's and walked them to their bedroom.
"Okay, so I've got to ask…" Ashley started off as she and Troian sat down in the Hastings' living room, getting ready for a scene.
"Yeah?"
"When has Shay ever looked at you like that? I would probably freak out if she looked at me like that." The blonde said as Troian smirked.
"Yeah, it wasn't great, but it also wasn't completely my fault." The brunette said firmly as Ashley nodded and scoffed happily.
"I'm sure it wasn't, T." The blonde said, not believing her friend.
"Okay, so this was probably like 2 months into our relationship." Troian started off as Ashley looked at her intently.
"Hey T, what are you up to?" Shay asked as she walked into Troian's dressing room, after having just finished changing in her own dressing room.
"Hi babe." Troian said from the bathroom, with the door slightly cracked open.
Shay smiled brightly when the 'babe' flowed so smoothly out of her somewhat-new girlfriend's mouth.
"Do you want to come back to mine and we can watch a movie or something?" Shay asked hopefully.
"I would love you, but I literally have nothing in my fridge anymore. I've been putting off shopping for like two weeks. So I really need to go. Movie tomorrow night?"
"Oh, yeah. Of course." Shay said with a smile that didn't quite meet her eyes.
"You can always come with me to the store. I'm not promising anything interesting though." Troian offered as Shay nodded slowly.
"I'd love to go. I know we worked together all day, but it's not the same." The tanned girl admitted with a shrug.
"It's not. I like being with Shay more than Emily." Troian responded as she shut off her bathroom light and made her way over to Shay and placed a lingering kiss on her lips.
"You ready?" The raven-haired girl asked as she squeezed Troian's hips.
"Yeah, let's go for it. Do you want to drop off your car at mine and then we can go?" Troian asked as she remembered that Shay had her own car.
"How about I leave it here and I'll just come into work tomorrow with you." Shay suggested as Troian smiled even brighter.
"Are you suggesting what I think you're suggesting, Shannon?"
"I believe I am, Troian." She said with a chuckle as she leaned forward and kissed Troian's cheek. "I really like sleeping next to you."
"I like it, too. But it's never going to happen if we don't leave. Shall we?" The brunette asked, holding the door open for her girlfriend.
"Babe, I forgot to get some fruit that I wanted, I'll be right back." Troian said quickly as she looked through their cart and waited for Shay to nod before she left.
It was nearing 10:30pm on a Wednesday, so the store was pretty desolate, which was somewhat nice because they were able to shop quickly.
Shay grabbed a few things off the shelves that she liked to snack on, that way she would have some at her girlfriend's house. Once she was done, she started to head over to the produce section to find her girlfriend.
When she got closer she noticed that there was a very pretty blonde who was talking to said girlfriend.
Troian was holding a few bags of fruit, but had stopped to talk to this girl, which was typical of the very friendly brunette. However, this blonde was all over her girlfriend, laughing at things that Troian said and constantly touching her arm, it was starting to irritate Shay.
She really wanted to just storm over there and kiss her girlfriend firmly, but since the two hadn't gone public with their relationship, she opted against that.
Shay had planned to just linger until they were done talking, but once she saw the blonde grab and squeeze her girlfriend's hand, she walked over there, slightly more determined than normal.
"Oh my gosh, you're Shay Mitchell." The blonde stated when she made her way over to the two.
"That's me." Shay said, trying to be nice.
She shot the blonde a small smile while Troian was setting her bags in the cart.
"Well it was nice to meet you, Amber, but we'd better get going. It's getting late." Troian said sweetly as the blonde touched her arm once more time and Troian shot her a nice smile.
"Okay, can you please just tell me what I did wrong?" Troian asked as she and Shay dumped all of the groceries on her counter.
She looked up at Shay who had a very scary, very serious look on her face.
"Okay, I feel like you're trying to melt my eyes or something. That's a very harsh look for someone who hasn't done anything." Troian said quickly as Shay continued to glare at her angrily.
"You're serious?" The raven-haired beauty asked incredulously.
"Yes! I don't know what you're so mad about, I promise." Troian added sincerely.
"That blonde in the store!"
"She was a fan, what's the big deal?" Troian asked with a shrug.
"She was all over you!"
"What are you talking about? Everything's fine!"
"No, it's not okay! Because everyone thinks you're single and gorgeous! And she was totally flirting with her and you didn't stop her!" Shay said, looking down at her feet.
"Oh please, she was not flirting with me!" Troian said with a laugh, brushing it off.
"Oh, she totally was, Troi. She was laughing and smiling at everything you said and she kept touching you." The tanned girl pointed out.
"She said she liked my cardigan." The brunette answered slowly as she looked down at her cardigan confusedly.
"Seriously?" Shay asked with a pointed look.
"Shay, I'm not being facetious, I swear! I didn't know that she was flirting with me, I was just having a normal conversation with her, alright? Why would I need to be flirting with anyone now that we're dating? Can we please just forget about this?" Troian asked, not knowing what else to say.
"Fine. I'm sorry for getting so worked up over nothing." Shay said slowly, letting her anger dissipate.
"It's not nothing if it's bothering you, okay? I'm sorry for just being oblivious while grocery shopping."
"Come here. I'm sorry." Shay said again, opening her arms for her girlfriend to step into them.
"Yeah, after that look you shot me, you should be sorry." The brunette said good-naturedly as Shay laughed into Troian's neck.
"Yeah, that sounds like Shay." Ashley answered with a laugh. "She gets really jealous sometimes."
"No she doesn't, she's always awesome about everything." The brunette said as Ashley's eyes widened. "Alright, spit it out, Benz."
"I wasn't supposed to say anything because she doesn't like to show you her jealous side a ton."
"Are you serious?" Troian asked as Ashley nodded. "She trusts me though, doesn't she?" The brunette added.
"Of course she does! She honestly trusts you with her life. Jealously is a somewhat normal thing though, I wouldn't take it too seriously." Ashley offered up as Troian nodded slowly.
"So I should probably tell her now that I signed up to do this acting project for one night called 'The Blind Date,' huh?" Troian asked, already knowing the answer.
Ashley laughed relatively hard for a few seconds as Troian looked more and more confused.
"Good luck with the look you'll get after you explain that one to her." Ashley said, patting Troian's back.
So I just got a review asking about a prequel to this story; would any of you be interested in that? And at what point would you want me to start it? Beginning of the show? Or just a few months before they started dating? Let me know if you're interested in that!