Thanks so much for reading/reviewing! I hope you enjoy this chapter! I made up all the questions/answers in the later part of this chapter, so I have no clue if any of it is actually true!
Disclaimer: I do not own PLL or any affiliate in any way, unfortunately.
"Mhmm, this is nice. I feel like I haven't seen you in forever." Shay said as she snuggled deeper into Troian, her head resting in the crook of Troian's neck.
"I know, it definitely feels like it's been a while. Why don't you live with me again?" The brunette asked with a smirk, her eyes still closed as she ran her arms under Shay's shirt and up her back gently.
"I don't know. I want to, but at the same time, I love my house and I feel bad about leaving Michaela."
"Well what happens when we get married?"
"T-of course I'll be moving in with you."
"Well what do you want to do? We can live here, we can find a new place that the two of us choose? We could move into yours and let Michaela have this place." Troian suggested as Shay hummed at all of her options.
"Yeah, maybe. I really don't know. All I know is that I'm really glad to be waking up to you on this fine morning." She said with a silly smile, leaning to kiss Troian softly.
"I love you, you weirdo." The brunette said, ruffling Shay's hair with one hand.
"I love you, too. Even if it is 5:30am and we have to be at work soon." The raven-haired girl said with a smirk as Troian groaned slightly.
"We should get up then. Soon." She said, making no effort to get up as Shay giggled slightly.
"You two are extra adorable this morning, what's up?" Ashley said as she watched Shay and Troian exchange light laughs and touches.
"Just happy, that's all." Troian answered for the both of them.
As the two continued to sit curled up with each other on the couch at 'The Brew' during a scene set-up, Ashley decided to take some pictures and upload them to Instagram for fun.
She snapped a picture of them together, their legs touching and their fingers intertwined.
By the fifth uploaded picture of them being adorable, Lucy had caught on and was trying to stifle her laughs.
She uploaded the next one of them, Troian kissing Shay's cheek sweetly as the girl smiled happily, with the caption 'They still have no idea I'm doing this.'
The blonde laughed when she saw Lucy holding up her phone, Instagram feed up, pointing to the newly uploaded photo of Shay and Troian.
The blonde quickly took a picture of Lucy and uploaded it to Instagram as well. 'See, even Lucy knows I'm doing it.' The blonde captioned it with a smirk.
Finally, Shay looked over at her best friend as Ashley was in the middle of taking a picture of them. The tanned girl gave her an odd look, causing Troian to look at her as well, looking equally as unsure as her fiancée did.
'They may be onto me. I'll report back later.' The blonde signed off with, chuckling and smiling at the couple.
"So, a lot of fans have been asking us to get ButtahBenzo back together for a Ustream, and I think we should. You up for it Shay?" The blonde asked as her best friend smiled happily.
"Always."
"You know, you guys should make a game out of it." Lucy suggested as they all looked at her, allowing her to share her idea.
"You should do like a game show or something, you know? Like the Newlywed game or something." The small brunette suggested as the girls all smiled slightly.
"What if we do me and Tyler vs. Shay and Ashley? Just asking like random trivia or something. It could be a lot of fun." Troian said with a smile as Ashley looked excited.
"Yes, that sounds awesome! Let's do it! Shay?" Ashley said excitedly as Lucy smiled happily.
"Definitely! Luce, you should be like the judge/question asker!" Shay suggested sweetly.
"Oh, I'm so there! This is going to be fabulous, but also really competitive!" The short brunette exclaimed as everyone laughed.
"We should do like pre-set questions, and throw in some fan questions. It could be like that 'Friends' episode where Chandler and Joey wanted to prove that they knew Monica and Rachel better than the girls knew them. It was hilarious." Troian said with a smirk as Shay patted her thigh happily.
"Should we do it on set or at someone's place?" Lucy asked, allowing everyone to think about how it would work.
"How about like Saturday afternoon at my place?" Shay suggested as everyone nodded happily.
"I'll text Tyler and ask, but that works for me!" Ashley said happily.
"We will provide pizza and wine if everyone is interested." Troian said as the girls all smiled and nodded.
A few short days later, Tyler and Ashley were ringing Shay's doorbell, followed by Lucy a few minutes later.
"Luce do you have all the questions ready?" Troian asked with a smile as she handed her friend a glass of wine.
"Yup. I went around and got the correct answers from everyone on set, so I'm hoping no one ruined the fun and told each other the correct answers." Lucy said, fake glaring at the couples in the room.
"I forgot what you asked me like right after we were done." Ashley said with a smirk, causing everyone to laugh as Tyler nodded.
"And I wanted this to be a fair game, so I didn't tell Shannon anything." Troian said with a smile, sitting on the arm of the couch that Shay was sitting next to.
"You ready, T?" Tyler asked with a smirk as he high-5ed the brunette.
"Most definitely! We are going to own this!" She responded as Shay and Ashley both shook their heads, certain that they were going to win.
"Awesome, let's get started then!" Lucy said since Shay had already set everything up, all Lucy needed to do was click 'begin.'
Once they began it, Shay had everyone stop and tweet about it, that way they could gain followers on the Ustream.
They all talked aimlessly for 5 minutes before they decided to start the actual 'competition.'
"Alright everyone, we're going to be official here. I'm going to be the host of this little TB^2 (TB-squared) to ButtahBenzo competition. So, I'm Lucy Hale and on team TB^2, we have Troian Bellisario and Tyler Blackburn. On team ButtahBenzo, we have Shay Mitchell and Ashley Benson!"
Everyone took turns saying hi to the camera before they got prepared for the questions that were about to be asked.
"Alright, so I'll ask a question and we'll take turns answering it. Cool? Let's get started! What side wants to go first?" Lucy asked as Ashley looked at Shay.
"Rock, paper, scissors to see who goes first?" The tanned girl suggested.
"Good with me." Everyone else agreed, Shay and Troian going in to do one round of the game. Troian lost, so team ButtahBenzo would be going first.
"Alrighty then. Ashley, what is Tyler's favorite movie?"
"Uh, oh, Forrest Gump." She answered as Troian looked to Tyler to see him nodding his head.
"Tyler, what is Ashley's favorite thing to buy in a store?"
"Bags? Like handbag, purse things?" He asked with a grimace as Ashley laughed slightly at his adorableness.
"That is correct!" Lucy said with a smile.
"Shay, what was the name of the first person Troian ever kissed?" Lucy asked, causing Shay to pout slightly, not wanting to think about her fiancée kissing other people.
"Oh, crap. I used to know this? Jason?" She asked hesitantly.
"Incorrect. The correct answer is Ryan." Lucy said as Troian shrugged, happy that she and Tyler were now leading the game.
"Troian, where is Shay's dream place to live?"
"New York City." The brunette answered quickly, starting to get really competitive.
"Correct! Ashley, what is the most embarrassing thing Tyler has ever done?"
"Um, he once threw up in front of a girl at a party while trying to impress her." The blonde said with a slight grin as Troian laughed at her teammate.
"Unfortunately, that is true." Tyler chipped in as Troian just patted his back gently.
"Tyler, if Ashley were a dog, what breed would she be?"
"Well she has a malti-poo, but I think she would be a yellow lab." He answered, not quite sure if that was correct.
"Oh, incorrect. She said golden retriever." Lucy responded, ignoring Tyler as he mumbled something about them practically being the same dog.
"Shay, name one thing Troian couldn't live without." Lucy said as Shay's face fell.
"Okay, this is going to sound narcissistic, but I'm going to say me?" She said questioningly as Troian tried to hide her proud smile.
"You are absolutely correct!" Lucy added as Ashley watched the couple squirm slightly because they wanted to kiss each other, but didn't want to on camera.
"Troian, what is Shay's favorite snack food?"
"Ketchup lays chips. Don't anyone judge those, they're incredible." The brunette replied, pointing at the screen as Shay nodded and laughed.
After many more questions, they finally ran out and started taking just regular questions from the audience.
"Does Troian ever get jealous of ButtahBenzo?" Lucy asked after reading some questions on the screen.
"Well, obviously." Ashley said as she hugged Shay tightly and crawled into her lap, causing everyone to laugh.
"Troi?" Lucy asked with a smirk.
"No way, I've got Trucy going on." She said as Lucy high-5ed her quickly.
"Troian, what kind of chapstick flavor is Shay wearing right now?"
"Wow, you guys just want to know everything. Also, I know that means you want us to kiss for me to find out, but guess what? It's watermelon. I know that from earlier." The brunette said as Shay laughed loudly.
"Take that little comment how you will, kids." Ashley added with a smirk.
"Ashley, if Tyler were to wear one outfit for the rest of his life, what would it be?"
"His Pink Floyd t-shirt, jeans, and his black vans." She answered as Tyler nodded in agreement.
"Shay, what is the only class that Troian has ever gotten a B in?"
"That's a trick question because my girl was always a straight A student." The tanned girl said with a smirk as Troian winked at her happily.
"Who would you like your characters to end up with?"
"I would like Caleb to end up with Hanna."
"Same." Ashley said easily. "But Travis is pretty cool, too."
"I'd love for Spencer and Emily to end up together, but I doubt that'll happen, so I'm going to go back to season 1 and say Alex."
"Oh, that's a good one. I want Emily to end up with Paige."
"What about you, Luce?" Troian asked, wanting Lucy to get in on the question answering as well.
"Ezra, for sure."
"What are you guys going to do after this?"
"I think we're all going to stick around and eat some pizza probably. Maybe watch some TV or just chat." Troian said slowly, looking around at everyone else, who just smiled.
"Hey, Luce, who won the earlier competition?" Troian asked once they were nearing the end of the Ustream.
"According to my tally skills, team TB^2 won by 2 points!" She said excitedly as Troian and Tyler high-5ed and Ashley and Shay pouted jokingly.
"Awesome job, you guys." Shay said sincerely, smiling happily at her fiancée.
"Alright guys, well I think we're all going to take off now. Have a great rest of your afternoon, and watch PLL always!" Ashley said as she stood up and headed off to Shay's bathroom.
Everyone else said their goodbyes and thank yous until Shay turned off the Ustream and went to sit in Troian's lap.
"That went well, I think." She said as Troian grinned and kissed her gently.
"You're gorgeous." The brunette whispered in her ear, not wanting anyone else to hear what she was saying.
"Alright, lovebirds, I'm starving. Pizza time?" Ashley asked, grabbing Tyler's hand and pulling him up as Lucy chuckled at the couples.
"It's always pizza time." Shay replied, getting off of Troian's lap and pulling the brunette up and into her arms, connecting their lips sweetly before she took off to the kitchen leaving Troian and Lucy in the living room smiling happily.
"Looks like it's just Trucy left behind. Should we see what they're up to or scour through Netflix instant for a good show to watch once the pizza is ready?" Troian asked with a smile.
"I think the three of them can handle the pizza, they know what we like." Lucy added with a smile as they both fell onto Shay's couch as Troian grabbed the remote and started turning onto the Netflix account.
Thanks so much for reading/reviewing! Do you all have any ideas for where/what you want to see happen in this story? Or any one-shots? Thanks!