Woohoo! Chapter 4! This is so much fun! Thank you to K.C. Ellison, RR, and randompandattack for reviewing! I really appreciate it! If anyone wants to review, then please do! I accept helpful hints and tips, but please don't flame!

I don't own Fairly Odd Parents.

Chapter 4

"What! That's crazy!" Timmy shouted, trying hard to laugh and not scream in horror. "Fairies don't exist."

"Timmy, you can say that all you want, but I know the truth." Jenny argued. "I've seen you whispering to them. And the whole 'pigs flying' thing proved my point. Unless somebody wishes for pigs to fly, they can't do it. And you made a wish."

Timmy sighed. He knew Jenny was right. But he didn't want to admit that she was right. If he did, he would lose his godparents forever! And then how would he survive? "Guys, what do I do?" he asked, his voice barely a whisper.

"Timmy, whatever you do, don't tell her about us." Wanda whispered. "She can't prove we're fairies, so we won't have to go away."

"See! There you go again. Talking to them." Jenny declared. "Face it Timmy. I know you have godparents. There's nothing you can do to make me believe that your goldfish are plain old, regular goldfish."

Timmy looked from Jenny to Wanda. Oh why oh why did the person who found out have to be his secret crush? He didn't want to lie to her, but he didn't want to lose his godparents. They had been with him through everything and taught him some important lessons. Finally he made his decision.

"Jenny, I'm sorry, but I'm going to have to ask you to leave." stuttered Timmy, pointing towards the door. "Oh. I see what's going on." Jenny sneered. "You think that if I leave, I'll just forget everything that happened. Well guess what Turner? That ain't gonna happen, because I'm not leaving until you say that you have fairy godparents!"

"Jen, please! Listen to me!" Timmy begged. "Everything would be better if you left. You're going crazy! Probably from playing too many video games. Go home and calm down. After a while you'll realize how ridiculous you sound, forget this whole incident, and then we can hang out again like normal! How does that sound?"

Jenny glared furiously at Timmy. " First of all, don't you dare call me Jen again. That's worse than Jennifer. Second of all, I am NOT going crazy from playing video games, that's just stupid. And third of all, you can't tell me what to do, so I'm not leaving!"

"Fine! I guess I'll just have to use force!" Timmy grabbed her choker and yanked hard, stretching it until it looked like it was about to snap. Jenny's eyes widened. "Don't do that!" she cried out in fear. Yanking Timmy's hands off of her neck, she backed away as though she thought Timmy was about to hurt her.

Angrily, Timmy advanced, and she continued to walk quickly backwards, her hands covering her rainbow choker protectively. Her eyes practically screamed terror. Finally, when he had Jenny trapped in the corner of his room, he went back to the goldfish bowl.

"Guys, what's going on?" Timmy asked Cosmo and Wanda. "One minute she's screaming angrily at me, the next she's scared of me!"

"She doesn't like it when you touch her choker." observed Wanda. "Then I know exactly how to get her out of here." Timmy grinned wickedly. He walked back up to Jenny and began speaking.

"Okay Jenny, here's the deal. I'm not going to stop doing THIS until you leave." He grabbed her choker and started stretching it again. She gasped, but then glared angrily at him as though she had finally realized that she didn't need to be scared of him. "Well, I'm not going to leave until YOU admit that you have fairies!" she argued back, grabbing his hands and wrestling hard trying to get them off her neck.

"Well I'm not going to admit that I have fairies until-" Timmy let go of Jenny and clasped his hands over his mouth in horror. "Oh no." He couldn't believe that he had just did that. His happy life was now officially over. Wanda sighed in defeat. "Come on Cosmo, let's go start packing our stuff." she murmured, leading her baffled husband and son into their castle for what would most certainly be the last time.

"I KNEW IT!" Jenny cried out triumphantly. "I knew that you had fairies." She continued to cheer and dance around braggingly until she realized that Timmy looked horrible. "Timmy? Are you okay?" she asked in concern.

Timmy let out a deep sigh. "Well Jenny, you found out my secret. I hope that makes you happy. Now, because you found out, my fairies are going to go away forever. I will never see them again."

" Well that's alright, isn't it?" Jenny asked, not quite grasping the seriousness of the situation. "Well Jenny, it would be alright if my life wasn't miserable. But everyday, I have to deal with neglectful parents, a torturous babysitter, a teacher that hates me, and bullies, among many other things, like struggling to fit in. That's why I had Cosmo, Wanda, and Poof. They fixed my problems. All I had to do was make wishes. Of course, sometimes my wishing got us into trouble. Actually, most of the time. But my fairies were always right beside me, willing to help me make things right again. I considered them my second family, and they called me their son. And now they're going to leave me and get reassigned to another sad little kid who needs them."

"Oh Timmy." Jenny whispered breathlessly. Now that she knew the consequences of her actions, she felt sick to her stomach. She hadn't meant to do anything like this.

"And you know what the worst part is?" Timmy said. Without waiting for an answer, he continued. " When the head fairy Jorgen comes to pick them up, he's going to make sure that I forget all about them. I will never remember the fairies that made my life perfect."

Jenny was speechless for a few minutes. Finally she desperately cried, "What can I do?"

"You've done enough." was Timmy's barely muttered answer.

With a loud POOF, the 3 fairies popped out of Timmy's fishbowl. Normally this would have amazed Jenny. But now seeing them made her feel little and weak. She didn't even know what to say to them. Finally she looked into their sad eyes and murmured, "I'm so sorry."

The fairies didn't answer her. Instead they floated over to Timmy and gave him a loving hug. Jenny noticed that every single fairy had silent tears flowing. Timmy meanwhile, was sobbing into the female fairy's shoulder. Jenny guessed that she was Wanda.

Suddenly Jenny had an idea. She walked over to Timmy and his fairies, and grabbed his hand firmly. He looked up and winced at her touch. "What do you want?" he growled, wiping his tear-stained face on his other arm.

"If your memory is going to be erased, then I want mine erased too." she said determinedly. "I deserve it."

The fairies smiled sadly at her. "That's very kind of you Jenny." Wanda's high voice said. Jenny could tell she was trying not to cry again.

"Hey Wanda, Jorgen's late!" Cosmo yelled out loudly. "What are you talking about?" Wanda asked in annoyance. "Normally Jorgen comes almost immediately after someone discovers us. Why's he taking so long?"

"Maybe he doesn't know that I found out." suggested Jenny. "That's impossible." Wanda shook her head in confusion. "Jorgen always knows."

"Timmy Turner has fairies." Jenny whispered. Still there was nothing. So she yelled. "Timmy has fairies!" But no matter how many times she said the words, nothing happened. "I don't understand." Timmy said, puzzled. "Let me see Da Rules."

So Wanda poofed up the big purple book of rules. Timmy opened up the book to the very first page. "Rule One. Do not tell anyone about your fairies. If another human finds out, your fairies will be taken away and re-assigned."

"Oh." Jenny gasped. "Well Timmy, it's getting late. I've gotta go. Right now!" she leaped up off of the bed that she and Timmy had been sitting on and started running towards his door. "Bye!"

"Hold it!" Wanda poofed her way in front of the open door to stop Jenny. "You know something! Why are you hiding it?"

"Hiding? I'm not hiding, who's hiding?" Jenny quickly lied, trying to get past Wanda. But the stubborn fairy was in her way. "Tell us Jenny!"

"Yeah Jenny." Timmy and his other fairies came over and together all 4 surrounded Jenny. "Spill the beans."

Cosmo gasped, "No, don't spill the beans! That'll make a mess! And then I'll cry! Spilled milk doesn't make me cry, but a can of spilled beans make my eyes flow like Niagara Falls!"

Everyone ignored Cosmo's stupid ramblings. They were all focussed on Jenny, who looked like a trapped rat. Finally she cracked. "Alright I'll tell you. The reason your fairy godparents aren't being taken away is because I'm not human."

"Not human? What are you? An alien? A vampire? Another fairy?" guessed Timmy. His wide blue eyes were filled with confusion.

"No." Jenny shook her head. "I'm a Bornagain."