Story 2: Sam's Dirty Supernatural First Time
Scene: Crossroads High School two days later
Sam sees Rachel standing in front of her locker in the hallway.
He sighs nervously as he watches her because he has finally decided to ask Rachel to prom. Sam has never gone to a school dance before and wasn't interested in going to any until now. Rachel had planned all through high school to go with Cole, but now that they've broken up Sam knows she won't be going with him.
Sam quickly walks up to his own locker only a few lockers down from her. Dirty Diana as Rachel smiles at him and is about to say something to Sam when another boy from Rachel's history class approaches her.
James: "Hey Rachel, what's up?"
Dirty Diana as Rachel: "I'm busy what is it?"
James: "Well everyone knows that Cole just asked Carrie to prom so you two are officially over right?"
Dirty Diana as Rachel: "Yeah, so?"
James: "So I was thinking we could go together. What do you say?"
Dirty Diana as Rachel looks past James at Sam. She can see Sam looks really shocked for a second then sad to see he's too late.
Dirty Diana smiles glad to see this.
Dirty Diana as Rachel: "Thanks, but I already have a date."
James frowns disappointed to hear that.
James: "Oh really, I didn't know. Britney said you were still single. I'm sorry."
Dirty Diana as Rachel pats James on the shoulder pretending to care about his pathetic teenage boy feelings.
Dirty Diana as Rachel: "No, its okay I haven't told anyone yet about him, but it was sweet of you to ask."
James: "Yeah, well I guess I'll see you later in fifth period then?"
Dirty Diana as Rachel nods as James sadly walks away from her.
Sam closes his locker and frowns. He overheard their conversation and assumes she has a date with another guy now that she never even mentioned to him before.
Dirty Diana as Rachel: 'Hi Sam."
Sam nods a bit, but doesn't look at her directly still too upset.
Sam: "Rachel."
Sam is about to walk away and head off to class thinking he has missed his chance to ask her out now, but she stops him from leaving.
Dirty Diana as Rachel: "Wait, so I thought maybe we could hang out today after school?"
He sighs at her and nervously shuffles his feet.
Sam: "I don't know Rachel. I mean shouldn't you be getting ready for prom or something. It is in a few days."
Dirty Diana as Rachel: "That is what I want to do with you. I thought I could help you pick out a nice tux to wear so I know that we match."
Sam stares at her totally confused.
Dirty Diana as Rachel giggles and blushes at him.
Sam: "But. Uh! I thought…."
She interrupts him.
Dirty Diana as Rachel: "But, what? You know how organized I am Sam. I just want us to be the perfect looking couple at prom that's all."
Sam: "So you don't have another date? You told James you did."
Dirty Diana as Rachel: "Yeah I do have a date with you silly. I mean I figured you were going to ask me eventually when you finally got up the nerve."
Sam laughs realizing what an idiot he's been for not just asking her right away.
Sam: "Yeah, okay sure!"
Dirty Diana as Rachel grins at him.
Dirty Diana as Rachel: "Great, you can pick me up at eight on prom night and no limousines okay they are such a waste of money. Everyone will be showing up in one so it's not that cool anymore as far as I'm concerned. I want to go in your car instead."
Sam looks at her surprised by this.
Sam: "The Impala you mean?"
Dirty Diana as Rachel: "Yeah, I saw your brother drop you off in it and it looks really cool. No one will be coming to prom in a classic car like that! So can we go in the Impala pretty please Sam?"
Sam smiles at her glad to see she's so interested in going with him.
Sam: "Yeah I guess you're right. I just have to get my brother to lend it to me; he loves that car so it'll be a challenge to get Dean to part with it for the night."
Dirty Diana as Rachel moves in close to Sam and rubs her fingers against his shirt collar pretending to straighten it.
Dirty Diana as Rachel: "I promise you Sam, if you get us that car and take me to prom in it and I'll make it worth your wild."
She flashes him the sexiest smile Sam has ever seen at this point in his life. Dirty Diana as Rachel gets on her tip toes so she can lean up as she kisses and sucks on Sam's earlobe.
Sam can't believe how amazing her tongue feels and he is very surprised because Rachel has never kissed him like this before. He becomes too nervous and excited to even speak afterwards so he just nods at her as erection begins to form in his pants.
Dirty Diana as Rachel: "Good!"
The school bell rings so Dirty Diana as Rachel walks away from Sam headed to her first period class. He stares at Rachel as she leaves totally mesmerized by her newfound sexiness. He can't wait to see her all dressed up and pretty for prom on Saturday.
Scene: Rachel's house on prom night
Sam stands in her foyer nervously in his tuxedo suit twisting his necktie trying to remain calm. He holds a box with a pretty blue and white flower corsage inside in his other hand as he waits for Rachel to come downstairs in her Cinderella blue gown.
Paula and Richard come into the foyer with a camera so excited to take pictures of their daughter headed off to her senior prom.
Paula: "Oh wait until you see her dress Sam! I had it made especially for her and its just gorgeous."
Sam smiles at her and politely nods.
If only she knew that I spent the night here and already saw the dress. He thinks to himself as he looks up at the staircase.
Rachel: "I'm coming down now!"
Richard grins and holds up the camera ready to immediately snap her picture as she comes down the stairs.
Rachel appears at the top of the stairs and her mother gasps in horror when she sees what Rachel is wearing instead of the Cinderella blue gown.
Both Sam and Richard stare with their mouths wide open as she comes down the stairs towards them.
Dirty Diana as Rachel is wearing a low cut black halter gown with a high slit off to one side and sexy strappy black heels with bright red nail polish on her toenails and fingernails. Her beautiful curly reddish brown hair is up in a sexy wild up do with little curls hanging down around her face. She has on big gold hoop earrings and a fancy gold bracelet that her parents have never seen before. Her make-up is also quite dramatic with black smoky eye shadow and bright red lip stick.
None of them have ever seen Rachel look so sexy and grown up before. Sam is especially mesmerized by the way she looks.
Richard puts down the camera and frowns at her.
Richard: "What are you wearing!"
Dirty Diana as Rachel: "Oh do you like it? Isn't it sophisticated dad? I got it just the other day, but don't worry it was on sale."
Paula: "But, honey I thought you were going to wear the blue gown that I bought…."
Dirty Diana as Rachel cuts her off.
Dirty Diana as Rachel: "Yeah, but that dress was so old fashioned mom. It was the dress I was going to wear to go to prom with Cole so I sold it and used the money to get this one. I'm going with Sam now so I wanted something extra special and different that I knew he'd appreciate. What do you think Sam? How do I look?"
She does a quick twirl around in her dress so he can see her from all angles in it.
Sam is practically speechless he can tell her parents don't approve at all and are looking at him with daggers in their eyes like this is all his fault and probably his idea. However, despite their disapproval he honestly thinks Rachel looks very sexy and incredibly beautiful too. He doesn't want to lie or upset her.
Something about that black dress against her soft pale pink skin really turns him on immediately. He is so used to Rachel in light pastel colors and she always looks sweet and pretty, but damn right now she looks hot as hell!
Sam clears his throat loudly then finally responses to her as sincerely as he possibly can.
Sam: "You look absolutely breathtaking Rachel!"
Dirty Diana as Rachel grins excitedly and puts her arm under his happy he likes it.
Paula sighs then nods in agreement.
Paula: "Well fine then its no point in arguing about it now what's done is done I guess."
Richard still disagrees and wants to argue about it and demand Rachel take the damn dress off immediately because he thinks it makes her look like a slut. But, Paula gives him an awkward look so Richard sighs and silently agrees not to get upset over it.
Paula picks up the camera and takes two pictures of Rachel and Sam.
Dirty Diana as Rachel: "Alright, we better get going we don't want to be late. Oh and Sam put that down because I got another corsage it's in my purse."
Sam: "Oh uh okay."
She picks up her little black purse and pulls out a single dark blood red rose. It matches the new look better Sam realizes so he takes the rose and places it around Rachel's wrist.
Dirty Diana as Rachel smiles at him and he opens the door.
Richard: "Sam!"
Sam looks at him nervously.
Sam: "Uh yes sir?"
Richard: "Just make sure to have Rachel back here by one o'clock like we discussed not a minute later you got that boy."
Sam: "Yes, I will sir."
Richard reminds Sam of his own father and how strict John can be on them so he knows to be as respectful as possible even though Sam thinks they are both way too harsh on their kids.
Dirty Diana as Rachel sees the Impala sitting out in front of her house.
Dirty Diana as Rachel: "Yes, you got it! How did you get your brother to give it up?"
Sam: "I had to promise I give him one of my kidneys if anything happen to the car or if he ever needs one later in life."
Dirty Diana as Rachel laughs and slaps Sam on the shoulder.
Sam knows his brother likely will need one of his kidneys someday the way Dean drinks nowadays, but he doesn't mention this thought to Rachel. He figures the trade is a fair deal now that he sees how amazing Rachel looks and how excited she is over it.
The two of them head out to the car while her parents stand in the doorway watching them leave both worried about their daughter's new behavior.
Scene: Hilton Hotel at prom.
Sam and Rachel enter the prom together and lots of heads turn towards them when they see what Rachel is wearing.
Most of her club friends immediately start whispering to themselves about her outfit while her teachers just stare completely confused by it. Most of the guys in the room are practically drooling at how hot she looks and their dates look very jealous about it.
Sam doesn't even notice them staring because he still can't take his eyes of Rachel either and though he doesn't consider himself much of a dancer he is excited about getting the chance to dance with her.
Dirty Diana as Rachel leads Sam to the photographer's booth so they can take their prom picture together. Dirty Diana even sticks Rachel's leg out a bit as she squeezes Sam's body tightly so their picture will look sexier.
Then they head over to the food table to get some snacks before they start dancing. Dirty Diana pulls a classic prank and pours some alcohol from a small bottle in her purse into the large punch bowls on the table. Sam tries to stop her, but he is too late. She just laughs about it.
Miss Capri, the Crossroads High secretary comes up on stage to announce the winners of Prom King and Queen.
Miss Capri: "Welcome students to the Crossroads High Prom of 2000. Now to kick things off we will start by announcing all your junior prom princes and princesses this year then we will announce the senior class prom king and queen."
Everyone gathers around the stage excited to hear all the winners called. Miss Capri announces the six junior winners first and gives them all blue and white ribbons to put on. Then everyone claps for them.
Miss Capri: "And now for the seniors. The winner of this year's senior prom king is Mr. Cole Turner!"
Cole Turner grins then does a congratulatory special handshake with his best friend Chris while his new girlfriend, prom junior princess Carrie shrieks with delight and loudly claps for him.
The video of him having sex over winter break did nothing, but increase his popularity at Crossroads especially with the guys so he won by a landslide with their votes.
Cole jumps up on stage grabs his crown and does a fist pump.
Diana as Rachel rolls her eyes at the whole display completely unimpressed by the whole ordeal.
Diana as Rachel: "Come on Sam let's get out of here. I'm bored with this."
Sam frowns at her.
Sam: "But we just got here and they are just about to announce…"
Miss Capri begins the announcement before Sam can even finish his statement.
Miss Capri: "And finally what you've all been waiting for the winner of senior Prom Queen 2000 is none other than."
Miss Capri opens the envelope in her hand.
Diana as Rachel yawns like she couldn't care less about winning and assumes that she won't after what happened to Rachel.
Miss Capri: "Miss Rachel Nave!"
Sam grins and immediately turns towards Rachel as whole room slowly begins to applaud for her.
Sam: "You won Rachel. You won!"
Many students and old friends clap with delight for her while others in their senior class are surprised Rachel won assuming that she would lose and some else was going to win for sure since she'd stopped campaigning for it way back in February after Cole's video aired.
Sam however knew Rachel secretly still wanted to win this and he felt she deserved it after all she done for the school so he convinced Dean to help him sneak into the school office Friday night and slip Rachel's name into the Prom Queen envelope. He figures it is payback to all those jerks at school for laughing at Rachel and not voting for her just because of that stupid sex tape.
Diana as Rachel: "Oh really she won I mean I won, uh cool I guess."
Diana puts on a fake smile though she really finds this whole cliché high school tradition totally moronic and pathetic. Why would anyone care about this crap she wonders.
Sam: "Well go ahead get up there!"
Diana smirks and waves at the crowd like a cheesy beauty pageant queen does as she heads up onto the stage.
Cole looks her up in down angrily as she walks up on stage. When she gets close to him he leans in to whisper to her.
Cole: "Nice dress where did you get it Whores-R-US?"
Diana as Rachel: "Oh is that what you call your mom's closet? How appropriate. Why don't you go fuck her you dick weasel?"
Cole frowns in shock at her quick and crude comeback. He has never heard Rachel speak like that to him or to anyone else before.
Diana as Rachel just smiles out at the crowd totally ignoring him as Miss Capri hands her flowers and puts the Queen's crown on top of her head.
Sam looks up at her on stage and claps happily.
Miss Capri: "Now its time for the traditional Crossroads High Senior Prom King and Queen dance. As part of the tradition whenever the King and Queen are not a couple they are allowed to dance with their dates for the evening so Cole, Rachel go on and get down on the dance floor."
Miss Capri looks back at the audience of students.
Miss Capri: "Everyone clear the floor please and enjoy the rest of your evening."
Diana heads off stage first and when Cole tries to rush past her down the stairs she puts her foot out and trips him up.
Cole loses his balance, but quickly grabs the side rail before he falls completely flat on his face.
Diana as Rachel: "Cole, when did you get so clumsy? Try not to trip while dancing with your new skanky girlfriend okay you'll ruin the yearbook pictures."
Cole angrily glares at her and is about to say something mean back when Sam takes Rachel's hand and leads her to the middle of the dance floor.
Cole quickly recovers from almost falling as Carrie comes to take his hand so they can take their places as well.
Once both couples are ready Miss Capri signals the DJ to start the traditional Crossroads High Senior Dance Song.
The school DJ begins to play These Arms of Mine by Otis Redding for them to dance to.
"These arms of mine
They are lonely, lonely and feeling blue
These arms of mine
They are yearning, yearning from wanting you
And if you would let them hold you
Oh, how grateful I will be
These arms of mine
They are burning, burning from wanting you
These arms of mine
They are wanting, wanting to hold you
And if you would let them hold you
Oh, how grateful I will be
Come on, come on baby
Just be my little woman, just be my lover, oh
I need me somebody, somebody to treat me right, oh
I need your woman's loving arms to hold me tight
And I...I...I need...I need your...I need your tender lips"
Diana as Rachel wraps her arms around Sam's shoulders and presses her body tightly up against his as they dance together.
Diana slowly begins to nibble and kiss Sam's ear then she blows on it.
Carrie and Cole both look at them disgusted by their P.D.A. Carrie pulls Cole closer to her trying to show them off as a sexy couple too so everyone won't just be looking at Sam and Rachel during the dance.
Diana as Rachel grinds Rachel's hips against Sam's pelvis as she turns around facing the other way and puts her arms up over her head back around his head. She wiggles her ass against the front of his body until she feels him getting a hard on from it.
Sam finally notices everyone in the room is staring at them and obviously whispering about them. They all look shocked and confused by Rachel's provocative dancing.
Sam: "Rachel, um what are you doing?"
Diana as Rachel: "Enjoying the moment. Aren't you?'
Sam: "Yes I am, but uh its just people are staring."
Diana as Rachel: "Let them stare, they're just jealous of us Sam. They want what we have is all."
Sam frowns a bit at that and begins to feel more uncomfortable and confused.
Sam: "And what is it that we have?"
She turns around to face him again placing her arms behind him so she can grip his ass through his trousers.
Diana as Rachel: "We're hot, we're young and we have each other."
Sam: "Well maybe uh we should go somewhere more private for this. I don't want to make other people uncomfortable and the teachers look really pissed at us."
She grins at him then pulls his head in close to hers for a kiss just as the school photographer takes their picture for the yearbook.
Diana as Rachel: "Finally Sam! I thought you'd never ask! Yes, let's get out of here. I want it to just be us anyway."
Sam nods and stops dancing with her just as the song ends.
Carrie whispers to Cole.
Carrie: "What is wrong with Rachel tonight? She is really taken this rebound thing too far. I mean she is acting like a total tart."
Cole nods in agreement as he stares at Rachel.
Cole: "And with that guy too. I mean she never behaved that way with me. What does he got that I don't?"
Carrie thinks to herself as she watches Sam walking away with Rachel that Sam's ass does look a lot perkier than Cole's but she of course chooses not to mention this particular revelation in front of Cole at the moment.
Carrie just shakes her head at Sam and Rachel in annoyance as they prepare to leave the hotel.
Sam: "So where do you want to go now?"
Rachel: "Take me back to your hotel Sam."
Sam looks at her surprised that Rachel wants to go to his hotel instead of out to a dinner or a movie, but he decides not to question her on it and do as Dean told him for a change.
"Live in the moment" he always says, hell its prom night so why not Sam thinks to himself.
Rachel: "Just give me a moment to freshen up first."
Sam: "Okay, I'll go get the car and I'll pull it up front for you."
Diana as Rachel smirks and watches as Sam walks out to the parking lot. Then she heads into the bathroom to fix her make-up before heading outside to meet him.
Scene: Inside Hotel Bathroom
Diana looks at Rachel's sexy curvaceous body and sweet looking face in the mirror as she fixes one of her black spaghetti straps.
Diana speaks to an unconscious Rachel who is still trapped inside her own body unaware of what Diana has been doing with her body all this time.
Diana: "You're such a juicy cherry baby girl if only you could see how hot we look. Sammy is going to really enjoy getting it on with us tonight. I'm going to rock his world."
Rachel stirs in her sleep, but doesn't wake up. Diana smiles as her demonic eyes flash in the mirror for a quick second.
Carrie comes into the bathroom frowning at her.
Carrie: "Rachel, you're not really just leaving here with that guy are you?"
Diana takes out some of her red lipstick and applies it while looking at herself in the mirror. She smacks her lips together.
Diana as Rachel: "What business is it of yours that I am?"
Carrie folds her arms in front of her body about ready to chew Rachel out for being so rude.
Carrie: "It sure is my business Miss Queeny since we're co-captains of the prom committee. You're supposed to be the one to stay and help with the clean up remember? That's what we agreed on Rachel."
Diana as Rachel: "Well the plans have changed sweet cheeks so I'm out of here."
She turns to leave the bathroom nonchalantly swinging her purse, but Carrie reaches out and grabs on to her shoulder hard to make Rachel stop and turn back towards her.
Carrie: "Look I'm getting really sick of your attitude. You can't just quit! This is important. Not everything is about you."
Diana looks at Carrie's hand on Rachel's shoulder likes she is just about ready to rip it off if she doesn't move it.
Diana as Rachel: "Take your hand of me now before…"
Carrie angrily interrupts her
Carrie: "Before what? What are you going to do about it?"
Diana as Rachel pretends to smiles innocently and Carrie smugly glares back.
Carrie: "Yeah that is what I thought!"
Diana suddenly rolls her dark devilish red eyes forward as she smirks at Carrie. She then grabs Carrie's arm and Carrie gasps!
Minutes later, Diana as Rachel leaves the bathroom humming These Arms of Mine as she walks outside to meet Sammy swinging her hips and her purse as she goes out the doors.
A few minutes after Sam and Rachel leave several people outside in the lobby of the Hilton hotel hear a blood curdling scream and they all turn to look as a terrified young junior runs out of the girls bathroom.
Young junior girl: "She's dead! Oh my God! Someone call the police! Carrie Black is dead!"
The young junior begins to cry as three hotel staffers' race into the bathroom and find Carrie's mutilated body on the floor her neck and both arms are broken and there is blood dripping out of her wide-eyed open eye sockets.