Don't tell Rachel part 3:
Rachel sat in the Ballet room. Her arms were crossed in anger but her face was hurt. Finn came in quietly. When she noticed him, Rachel turned away quickly. Finn sighed then sat next to his girlfriend.
"Rachel, don't be upset. Theirs an important reason why we are keeping a secret from you." He explained. Finn was about to put his hand on her shoulder but Rachel turned around and said furiously
"I would love to know since I've had to act like a psycho chick for the past couple of days!"
"Come to my house tomorrow at four and I will explained everything." Finn said and with that, kissed his girlfriend on the cheek then departed living Rachel more curious then ever.
The next day:
Rachel nervously walked to Finns house. She knocked on the door. A few moments later she could hear heavy footsteps, Finn greeted her.
"Glad you could make it" he said with his boy next-door smile.
"This had better be good Finn I'm tired off-" Rachel stopped talking in shock. As she walked into the house, the living room was decorated for a party. Everyone from New Directions was present.
"What's this?" Rachel asked confused.
"Its an appreciation party in your honor." Quinn smiled.
"The reason we were all being secretive was because we were planning this thing." Explained Tina.
"We truly realized how much you do for us, love us and how we can be mean to you so we wanted to show you how much we love you." Puck added.
Rachel had tiers in her eyes.
"Uh God what's with the water works?" Santanna asked annoyed.
"You guys are so sweet, I love it, and feeling utterly hurt and betrayed was worth it." Rachel said.
"We are all your friends girl." Mercedes said proudly.
"Even you Santanna?" Rachel asked. Santanna wouldn't look the shorter girl in the eye.
"Yes" she muttered. She then quickly and awkwardly hugged Rachel then quickly got off.
"Lets go eat cake." Artie said. Everyone went into the dining room except Rachel and Finn.
"I love this Finn." Rachel said as she kissed her boyfriend.
"I'm going to have to give you something in return." She added.
"Would you ware that black dress again?" he asked feeling a little heated.
"Possibly" Rachel said seductively; as she went to join the others. Finn was flushed. The only thing he could think of was
"Mail man, mail man, mailman, mail man."