A/N: Thanks everyone for the reviews. They mean so much to me, seriously.
For those of you who feel bad for Jesse, I think you're kinda supposed to. I mean, in reality, he didn't do anything wrong. He just wasn't the right fit for Rachel. As I said before infidelity isn't for the weak of heart. hahaha.
Don't forget to review, y'all. Tell me what you like and hate so I can be sure to make you happy with each passing chapter. I will listen to most ideas as long as it doesn't hurt the integrity of the story and planned plot line. :)
Chapter Ten
Finn woke up before Rachel and noticed she had squirmed her way into him arms. He grinned down at the small girl and hugged her tight, she stirred for a minute in his arms before finally looking up in his eyes. "Hey." She covered her mouth with the blanket and looked up into his eyes.
He teased her by covering his own mouth with his hand, "Hey." He grinned back at her.
Rachel jumped up quickly and made her way to the bathroom, "Where are you going? I want more morning cuddle." Finn pouted.
Rachel grinned and grabbed her toothbrush, showing it to him, "I want more than that." Rachel told him before beginning to brush her teeth and Finn laughed and made his way to the bathroom to follow her lead. They made weird faces at each other, teasing each other a little as they brushed their teeth. Rachel finished after a minute or two and quickly rinsed her mouth out before returning to bed. As she made her way back she slipped off her tee shirt and jumped on top of the cover to lay there in her matching red bra and thong, this was supposed to be Finn's treat for the night before, but now would do.
Finn made his way into the room seconds later and crawled up on top of Rachel, the excitement in seeing her in the lacy red thong was getting the best of him, "Wow, you look-"
Rachel silenced him with her lips on his, he didn't mind. Rachel and Finn both knew they had a lot to talk about but neither seemed to care in that moment, they just wanted each other. Rachel tugged at Finn's shirt and he got the hint, pulling it off quickly and returning his lips to hers. He dipped his tongue into her mouth and allowed their tongues to dance, he wrapped his hands around her waist and rolled them over in one swift motion, Rachel now straddling him like she had last night.
He propped himself up on the headboard and began to unhook Rachel's bra, when it was unhooked she released the kiss to let the bra slide down her body and Finn moaned at the sight of her and she grinned with a knowing look. Finn didn't cease to make her feel sexy. She constantly felt like he wanted her, and that was a huge confidence boost. And wanting her over Quinn? That didn't hurt matters at all.
Finn moved his head to her chest, running his tongue along her, stopping to tickle her nipples as she moaned loudly, "Take your boxers off." She commanded and he obliged quickly as she lifted herself off him to let him do so.
"What about that lacy thong of yours?" Finn growled returning his lips to hers.
"You'll have to work around it." Rachel grinned seductively in his direction and Finn came unhinged, that had been enough foreplay for now, he wanted to be inside her.
Finn shoved the underwear aside and pushed himself inside her, where he now fit perfectly. He groaned out as Rachel slide herself up and down on top of him. Her hands rested on his chest to keep herself steady. She reached on of her hands up to stroke his very scruffy face and Finn pushed himself up into her deeper, surprising her. She let out a squeak and Finn growled in excitement as a response, "That was new." Finn uttered breathlessly and grinned at Rachel showing that he approved.
Rachel lifted and eyebrow and spinned slowly herself around on Finn, with him still inside her showing him her ass as she continued the motion. He groaned with pleasure as she did so and let his arm slide down her soft back down the to the rim of her thong that he pulled up and let it snap on her skin. Rachel arched her back in pleasure and brought her hand down to touch under his shaft. He let out what could only be called a squeal and Rachel suppressed her laughter.
He hadn't been expecting her to do that but it felt amazing, too good though. He felt himself getting ready to explode, "Rach." He said simply and she knew what he meant.
"It's okay, go baby." She said moving up and down quickly and letting her hand play with him. She felt him come inside of her and continued to ride out the feeling with him.
Rachel jumped off of him, grabbing his shirt and wiping him off before laying down, "I'm still dirty, baby." She pouted.
Finn was of course clueless, "You want the shirt?"
Rachel shook her head, "No, but if you wouldn't cleaning it off for me, that would be sweet." Rachel voice seductively and it only took Finn a minute to get what she was hinting at.
He smirked and tried not to show that he was internally terrified, he'd never tasted his own… stuff. He hoped that Rachel's taste would mask it.
He positioned himself between her legs and cautiously let his tongue make its' way to her opening. He just had one lap and could already tell something was different. It was the taste of Rachel Berry, but there was something else, something that tasted salty, almost greasy. Like the fries he'd had for dinner or something. Wait, was that him? He tasted like fries? Or did he taste like what he'd eaten?
He made a mental note to eat more fruit and let his tongue find its' way to her again. He licked her opening, the area with the most mess while Rachel writhed in passion. Eventually Finn made his way to her clit to finish the job. He sucked and licked her, letting himself taste all of her. Rachel began to shudder and her lips spit swear words intermixed with his name and he smiled internally. He was loving that he could make her come so hard she didn't even know what she was saying.
After she was finished she let herself go limp and wiped his face quickly before returning to Rachel. Finn brought his lips to Rachel and she could taste herself and Finn all over his lips and she loved it. Rachel Berry was not this girl, Rachel Berry was a prude. No, Rachel Berry St. James was a prude. Rachel Berry with Finn, she was a completely different person entirely.
Finn snuggled up to Rachel, laying his head on her bare chest and breathing out. "Wow."
"Yeah," Rachel agreed, running her hands through his sweaty hair.
They lie like that for a while, just breathing and being with each other in the silence. It's Sunday, Rachel's favorite day of the week and she wants to ask Finn to take her to brunch in the next town, but doesn't want to cause another fight.
"Finn," She whispered sweetly, "Are you hungry?"
Finn grips his stomach, "Starving."
"I know this great buffet that has tons of vegan options, but it's not exactly in Lima." Rachel tells him softly, hoping she'll believe her that it's about the food, not that she doesn't want to be seen with him. It is true, it's her favorite place, but not many people are willing to take the trip.
"Is it far?" Finn moved his head to lay on the pillow next to Rachel's head, making Rachel shiver for the lack of warmth and she grabbed a blanket and made her way into the crook of Finn's neck. She nuzzled her nose into him.
"Only 30 minutes." Rachel told him as she kissed his neck lightly.
Finn nodded, "I don't see a problem with that, but let's go now 'cause I seriously could eat a cow."
Rachel sat up and looked at him in disgust, "Please don't eat an entire cow." She pleaded, "I don't think I could continue to be with you."
Finn rolled his eyes and chuckled, "I'm not planning on it, Rach." He promised and they quickly got dressed. Rachel put her hair in a messy bun and applied some quick mascara before putting on jeans, a tank and a Finn's sweatshirt.
"You make that look good." Finn remarked as he added a sweater of the top of his v-neck, "I think I'll let you keep it."
"You better."
When they got to the restaurant Finn and Rachel walked inside, hand in hand and were seated. To Rachel's surprise she noticed Brittany and Santana just tables away. Santana waved and they asked if they could be seated together.
"So, you won't come here with me, but if Brit is involved you'll do it in a heartbeat?" Rachel winked at Santana who just brushed it off.
"Brittany, Finn, Finn, Brittany." Santana quickly introduced the two and they shook hands. "Are you going to be working next weekend, Rach? I want updates on how it is having Quinn at school."
"Quinn went back to school?" Brittany asked stupidly, "And I thought I was dumb." Rachel almost choked on her coffee.
"No, she is working there. She's the new coach of the cheerios." Rachel tells Brittany quickly, "I'll tell you all about it next Saturday, San." She explains.
"Man, that chick gets on my nerves." Santana growls and Brittany kisses her hand softly. Finn wonders what is going on between the two women but chooses to keep his mouth shut.
Brittany however can't keep hers closed, "So Finn… who are you?"
Rachel looks at Finn wondering how to explain him, but he takes the lead, "I'm Rachel's boyfriend."
Santana whispers to Rachel, "well that was quick."
Rachel bit her lip and tried to ignore her comment, "Well let's eat." She stated awkwardly before getting up and pulling Finn with her.
Finn loaded his plate with anything he could find while Rachel stuck to fruit and some vegan muffins that she adored there. When they got back to the table they enjoyed casual conversation and Rachel avoided all of the sticky topics, but promised to dish to Santana at a later time.
When Santana and Brittany left Finn looked to Rachel, "You two are an odd pair."
"Me and Santana?" Rachel asks surprised.
Finn chuckled a little, "Yeah, she's um…"
"A skank?" Rachel asked bluntly.
"I was going to say blunt and judgmental, but I suppose she's rubbing off on you a little." Finn teased.
"Me and Santana never really knew each other in high school, but once we started to work together… we just became friends." Rachel explains, "Opposites attract, I guess."
"Kinda like me and you?" Finn asked softly and Rachel bit her lip before nodding.
"Exactly like me and you." Rachel leaned up to kiss Finn softly and Finn grinned, accepting the sweet kiss.
"Rachel?" Finn heard a man's voice from behind them and turned to see a tall black man.
"Uhhhh" Finn stared awkwardly at the man.
"Daddy?" Rachel asked with terror in her voice.
"This is your Dad?" Finn asked in pure confusion. Rachel is not black and this man was very black. Finn reminded himself quickly that Rachel had two Dads and only one was her biological father. He breathed a little easier.
"Rachel, what are you doing?" The man asked Rachel, glaring at Finn.
Finn gulped and Rachel answered in a shaky voice, "Ha-Having brunch?" She stated it as a question instead of a statement.
"I'm Finn." Finn quickly added, sticking his hand out to shake Rachel's fathers' hand.
"Oh yes." Rachel was reminded, "How rude of me." She stood quickly and Finn followed her lead, "Finn, this is my father, Leroy."
"Hiram." Leroy called not taking his eyes off of Finn, and not taking his hand. "Come over here."
Hiram followed his husbands voice to find the trio, "Oh, well look who it is. Wait." He stopped himself noticing Finn, "Who is this?"
Finn moved his extended hand from Leroy to Hiram, "I'm Finn, and you must be Hiram." Finn grinned awkwardly and Hiram took it slowly, obviously confused.
"What is going on guys? What brings you out here?" Hiram asks nicely, he was normally the less friendly of the two Dads, but he hadn't just seen Rachel kissing Finn in a public place just two weeks after separating from her current husband.
"Brunch." Finn said simply, "Rachel said she knew a place so we ventured out."
Hiram nodded politely. "Join us?"
Rachel and Leroy's eyes were now locked, "We just finished actually. We should be going."
"Hiram, sweetie," Leroy said to his husband sweetly, "Were you aware that our daughter had taken a new lover?"
Finn's mouth dropped open in unison with Rachel's and Hiram's face went from confusion to what almost looked like terror, "Excuse me?" Hiram said loudly.
"These two," Leroy pointed at Finn and Rachel, "I saw them kissing."
"Kissing is a far leap to 'taking a lover', Daddy." Rachel argued. Finn could see where her dramatic side came from.
Hiram could only see red, "Rachel, what is going on here? You're already seeing someone else?" He shouted.
Leroy shook his head, "Maybe this is why the sudden break. You were seeing him before weren't you?"
Finn's mouth was still open from all that had just happened, "Mr. Berrys'" Finn cringed at the way that came out of his mouth, that wasn't how it was supposed to be said, and it felt weird. "I mean, Mr. and Mr. Berry, Rachel just wasn't happy anymore."
"Did you ever see them together?" Leroy asked, "Jesse was perfect for her. They liked all the same things; they took all the same classes in school…"
"Daddy, please." Rachel almost cried, "Can we talk about this later, this is not how I wanted you to find out I was seeing someone."
"Where have you really been the last couple nights?" Hiram spits suddenly, "You're not still staying at Kurt's father's house, are you?"
"I've already asked nicely that we drop this, and you won't let it go." Rachel says back in a low to the point tone, "Since you won't respect that or me… We're leaving." Rachel stated quickly before grabbing Finn's arm. Why was she always rushing out of places these days?
Finn let the small girl drag her out and looked back and the two men, "Sorry sirs, hope I see you soon." Finn stated awkwardly as the door shut behind him, "Rachel?" he uttered as she opened the passenger door quickly, walking past it to get in the driver's seat. Finn got in slowly and Rachel peeled out quickly and they headed on their way, "Rachel, talk to me." He whispered and noticed her beginning to tear up.
"No, Finn. I need a minute." Rachel explained wiping the forming tears.
Finn sat in silence and turned on the radio as they drove, Rachel stopped at a market in Lima and said she'd be right back, "Get me a coke, will you?" Finn asked handing her a $20 and she nodded.
Rachel came out with a couple cans of coke and a bag. When Finn opened the bag he saw candy and ice cream. "Vegan ice cream, huh? I didn't know such a thing existed." Finn grinned at her and she smiled lightly back.
"Thank god it does, I don't think I could get through anything without it." Rachel noted, "I'm totally one of those girls."
"What girls?"
"You know, the one that cries and eats ice cream while watching a sappy love movie." Rachel chuckled and Finn nodded.
When they got to the hotel Rachel crawled up on the bed with her ice cream and threw a gallon at Finn, "Cookie dough?" She asked.
"That's my favorite." Finn told her with a grin.
"It's Kurt's favorite too." Rachel said softly, "I really miss Kurt." She said giving a spoon to Finn and taking one for herself before digging in.
Finn sat next to her and started to eat his as well, "I know you do, Rach. I'm sorry he's not here."
Rachel nodded, "Me too. He would always bring me ice cream when I was fighting with my Dads, or with Jesse. Or he'd take me to a movie, or we'd just talk. He was my true other half." Rachel told Finn, "Jesse was just runner up."
Finn didn't ask the question that loomed in his heart. He wondered if Finn could be her other half now or if Kurt still held that place. "I was thinking," Rachel broke him from his thoughts, "Maybe I should come home with you. I need to just… run away."
Finn shook his head, "Rachel… you know I want you there, but not if it's just to run away. I want you there because you want to be there."
"Well it's both. I want to be there and I need to get out of here." Rachel's eyes pleaded with Finn's, "We can figure it all out over the next couple of days, please Finn. I just can't deal with this anymore."
Finn nodded, taking another bit of his surprisingly delicious vegan ice cream, "Under one condition." He started to feed a bite to Rachel, she opened her mouth for the bite and nodded after taking it, "We see your Dads before we leave."
"Not fair." Rachel said with a full mouth, covering her mouth as she said it, "You're not playing fair."
Finn put his hand under her chin and made her look at him, "If you run away from your family, of all people, you'll regret it. Trust me, baby. I've been there. There isn't a day I don't regret not discussing everything with my mom." Finn told her and she nodded sadly. "Now give me a bite. What is that? Rocky Road?"
Rachel nodded and spoon fed him a bite, and then another, yet again another. "You're taking it all." Rachel protested.
"We don't have a freezer, we have no choice but to finish it." Finn told her sweetly, opening his mouth for another bite.
Rachel lifted another bite in his mouth, "Two gallons? Have you seen me? I'm pretty tiny."
"Lucky for you, I'm not." Finn said and Rachel caught the double meaning pretty quickly. "Why did you buy magazines?"
"I love reading gossip magazines when I'm sad." She pulled one out with Taylor Swift on the cover.
"Ohhhh, don't read that one." Finn grabbed it, flipping it face down.
Rachel smirked, "Oh, I read about this, you two dated, huh?" She pointed her finger at Finn in accusation.
Finn shook his head, "No, I didn't date her… we went to a movie, or two. Maybe three."
"You slept with her." Rachel's mouth was wide open, "Three times, huh?"
"I didn't sleep with her… three times." Finn shook his head awkwardly, "Only once."
Rachel was now laughing, "You're a dirty skank who sleeps with blonde singers."
Finn nodded down closely to Rachel's ear, "I prefer brunettes." He uttered in a sexy voice and Rachel could feel a chill run up her spine and she knew it wasn't from the ¼ gallon of ice cream she just consumed.
Rachel smiled at the giant brunette next to him, "I would hope so, I guess I should be calling you my boyfriend now, huh?"
"I guess so." Finn grinned. "I don't want to be anyone else's boyfriend. You win."
"Not even Taylor Swift?" Rachel teased him.
Finn laughed loudly, "Nope, not even her."
Finn took another bite of him ice cream before setting it aside, "Come here, you." He requested lifting up his arms, "Let's take advantage of your day off."