Rachel was so happy everything was perfect again. Of course, Rachel didn't know Puck hated how he hadn't gotten any since the accident that one night. He had needs, and it got the best of him. That combined with the fact that he was still super pissed at Rachel. During third period, him and Santana went to the girls' bathroom and did it. Of course, Rachel happened to need to go to the bathroom at that time, and heard them.

She stormed out there, huffing loudly to ensure he heard. Then she stomped off to Glee. Him and Santana arrived shortly. She walked over to him, "Noah, I just wanted to let you know I am breaking up with you. Any plans we may have had won't be done."

Santana laughed, "Oh no! He doesn't have to spend time with Man Hands! Sounds horrible!"

"Thank you for your input Santana, but I simply didn't say anything directed towards you."

Puck stood up confused, grabbed Rachel's hand, and walked over to the other side of the room with her, "What is this all about Red?"

Rachel crossed her arms over her chest and scoffed, "You pretend you don't know. As if you don't remember where you were five minutes ago. I know right now, that's all you're thinking about. One, about how much you loved it," she said with fake enthusiasm, "and two, that I'm breaking up with you because of that. Well, you are correct, I am breaking up with you because of your unfaithfulness. I'm sorry."

He frowned, "The fuck Berry? You're breaking up with me? Coz I had to get some? Seems hardly fair."

"How? If I had slept with Finn five minutes ago, you would kill him, and never talk to me again."

Puck thought about it for a second, as though he had an argument ready, but sighed in defeat, "Yeah, that's true, but it's not the same."

Rachel put her hand on her hip, "You are so sexist! We're done. The end. No discussion. Bye." Rachel waved as she walked away.

Puck sighed and looked down. "Fuck," he mumbled.

Rachel sat down, trying not to cry. She had to get ahead of him. Finn was single right? Maybe they could get back together. She'd have to do that later, right now she would listen to everything Mr. Schue had to say.

The bell rang and Rachel caught up with Finn, "Hey, Finn."

"Oh, hey Rachel. What's up?"

"Wanna go out to dinner tonight?"

"Uh, sure, I guess."

"Great, pick me up at seven."

Rachel spent all day thinking of how she could make Puck jealous, you know, besides dating Finn. After she went out on her date tonight, she'd go to the mall and get some amazing outfits. And she'd be sexy. She felt strong. She went home and got dressed, did her hair, and make up. Her and Finn would just happen to go to the same place she happened to know Puck would be at. She strut in shorts from Hollister and a red and white striped tank top from Macy's. Her hair was curled and she did her make up perfectly.

Finn rang her doorbell. She opened the door, "Hi Finn."

"Whoa, Rachel, you, uh, you look, wow."

Rachel blushed, "Thanks."

Finn took her to his car, "Where are we going?"

Rachel thought about it for a second, as if she had to think about it, "That coffee shop on the corner of 21st and Orchard."

Finn smiled that goofy smile, "Sure, let's go." They got there in about ten minutes, after all, Lima is pretty small. Finn opened the door to the coffee shop and let Rachel go in. She smiled when he wrapped his arm around her waist. They got in line, and Finn noticed Puck and some chick at a table nearby. "Hey look, it's Puck. Did you know he was here?"

Rachel frowned innocently, "No. I had no idea. Weird."

"Should we say hi?"

"Nah. Let's just order." Finn shrugged and waited for their turn. She remembered faguely why she liked him. He was tall and cute, and sweet. He cared about her a lot. She felt a tap on her shoulder. Puck, "Oh, hi Noah."

"Hey Rachel, Finn. What are you guys doing here?"

Finn smiled, "I was taking her out to coffee. What about you?"

Puck nodded back to the girl, "Cheerio." Finn nodded knowingly.

Rachel smiled evilly at Puck, "Anyway nice seeing you, Noah. Bye."

Puck stared at her longingly. He made such a mistake, he could see it in her legs. He put on a fake smile, "Same to you. See ya." He walked back to his date and kissed her face. Rachel felt her heart ache. Why was she doing this?

Her and Finn and a great date. He kissed her and dropped her off at her house. She went upstairs, her parents both asleep, and put her PJs on. Looking at her calendar she noticed she was late. Weird. She laid in bed, checking Facebook on her iPhone. Mercedes commented on her status change apologizing. Yeah, whatever, she thought. Her phone buzzed, a new text. It was from Puck. She read it and replied.

Noah: Trying to make me jealous

Rachel: No

Noah: You knew I was going there, I posted it on Facebook

Rachel: So? I didn't see it? Were you trying to make me jealous?

Noah: How?

Rachel: Uh, one, you kissed your "girlfriend" right after you talked to me and Finn, and maybe you wanted me to come there.

Noah: I can't believe you think that way of me

Rachel: Why shouldn't I Mr. Santana is totally bangable?"

Noah: Wow, you're ridiculous

Rachel: I'm ridiculous?

Noah: Yeah, you're ridiculous. You just throw that in my face, is that how you're always gonna be? Manipulative?

Rachel: I hate you.

Rachel was crying. She hated him so much for making it impossible to not love him. Puck got the message and frowned. She hated him? Really? He hurt her that bad?

Noah: What?

Rachel: Yeah, that's right. I hate you.

Noah: You hate me? Don't you think that's a bit dramatic.

Rachel: I gotta go to bed.

Rachel put her phone down and went to sleep.