CHAPTER FIVE
Emma and Liberty made their way into the driveway, "Spinner's car is still here" Emma stated, "Call Spin. let him know that Toby is the killer" Liberty suggested. "No, because Spinner will react to it" Emma stated. "So?" Liberty told the girl. "I did this study, no matter what...when you're surprised you react either it's blinking or sighing" Emma told her as she quietly pushed the door open. "Emma?" Spinner asked as he was on top of the stairs with Toby.
"I thought I told you two to stay at the apartment, I've got Toby now" Spinner said. "Spin. Toby's the killer" Emma stated. "What?" Toby asked as he looked at Spinner. "Toby can't be the killer" Spinner said as he turned back to Toby Spinner focused on the knife that had just been stabbed in his chest, "What the?" Spinner asked as Toby kicked him down the stairs. "Spin...just like Hazel" Toby said as he looked at Emma and Liberty both.
Emma's heart was beating, "Liberty go, run!" Emma stated as her and Liberty made their way down the hall of the house. "Oh girls don't make this harder than it has to be" Toby stated as he made his way down the stairs. "The attic!" Liberty stated as she pulled the string, "Go!" Emma stated as she watch Liberty make her way up the attic, and then did the same. Just then Toby grabbed Emma's hand, "Get the fuck off!" Emma stated as she kicked him in the face hard.
Emma and Liberty then closed the attic door and locked it. "Okay is there any other way out of here?" Emma asked the girl. "Yeah over here!" Liberty shouted as she made her way over to the trap door, but then it opened and revealed Toby who then punched her, knocking her out. "Liberty no!" Emma stated as she fell backwards.
"Emma, it's time for you to die...you got away from Peter once, but that won't happen again..." Toby stated as he raised the knife, "Wait why did you do this, for him anyway?" Emma asked as she noticed how fragile the platform was around Toby. "Simple really, Liberty didn't want to be with me...so I got mad...then Peter came to me one day, he said he was going to kill me, but only if I didn't agree to help him. He said what else did I have to live for, my sister was dead...Liberty didn't want me, J.T.'s gone, and all he wanted was you dead" Toby told the girl.
"Toby I'm giving you one chance to do this, please drop the knife and help me get Liberty downstairs and then go to jail" Emma told him. "Or what?" Toby asked her. "You see when this first happened, I decided to take self defense classes, I'm not that scared girl Peter once came face to face with" Emma stated as she tripped Toby who fell through the platform. Emma got up to run over to Liberty when Toby grabbed her and she almost fell completely through but Liberty grabbed her. "Liberty don't let me fall!" Emma stated as she was hanging on for dear life.
Toby then stood up and grabbed the knife, "Time to end this" Toby stated as he started walking towards Liberty.