"Are you freakin' kidding me Ms Berry?" Kurt screamed at me, dropping his glass of cosmo and receiving glares for the bar tender who had to come and clean it up, "Ohmygod, I'm so sorry, it's just"

"Oh, don't worry, I get it... They're denying their feelings blah blah blah... These other guys were in here the other day having the same conversation, quite a coincidence don't you think..." He chuckled, throwing the broken pieces of glass in the trash...

"Yeah... A little too coincidental don't you think... Do you happen to know their names or anything?" Kurt questioned, not at all believing it was "just a coincidence that two other people were having the exact same problem..."

"Ermm... No, sorry I don't..." He answered, a little startled by the sudden interrogation

"What did they look like?" Rachel interjected

"One of them had like dark olive skin, brown eyes, brown hair, ermm dunno... OH he had a mowak !""

" A MOWAK ? " Rachel and Kurt screamed at him

"Yeah, I remember cause I thought I recognised him, he looks like my cousin Quinn's husband but I don't think it was..."

"OhMyGod, it was! That was Noah Puckerman !" Kurt screamed suddenly feeling excited for no reason...

"Oh OK, erm, how do you know?"

"Oh yeah, sorry, we went to school with them, anyway, can you tell us what they said?"

"Oh, erm, well, Noah was having a go at this tall guy for not manning up and taking responsibility for once or something like that, I dunno, then the tall one s-"

"Finn" Rachel interrupted,

"Yeah, Finn was saying that he didn't agree with the arrangement or something, kept saying something along the lines of isn't it weird to be in love with someone you hate and have to be a parent to your own child that you haven't spoken to like ever and living with the only person you've ever loved but them like totally rejecting you and staying friends or something... I'm not really sure..."

"Oh my god..." Rachel gasped throwing her head onto the bar and allowing the tears to flow freely down her cheek

"Oh, I'm sorry, did I say something wrong?" The bar tender asked, growing concerned "I'm so sorry, I just, I never know when to stop talking I and I I just" He began to stutter

"Oh no, I'm sorry, It's just, if he didn't agree with it why didn't he say something?"

"Maybe, because he didn't want to hurt you, or himself or maybe he just didn't know what to say... I'm not sure because I don't know what the agreement or whatever it was is or something but it seemed like this guy really loves you..."

"Rachel ! " Kurt whispered "Even a stranger knows that... You two are something I've never seen before and you need to really work it out... Not just say what comes easily..."

XxxxxxX

It was a breezy evening when she text me. Well i say evening, I mean midnight, but who's counting, I was wide awake thinking about her at the time anyway... It didn't really explain much... When we were together Rachel and I were brutally honest about our feelings... Now, not so much... I guess it kinda annoys me

Rachel Berry (Mobile)

Sent at : 12.23

Tuesday 1st August

Maybe I jumped to conclusions...

I'm sorry Finn,

I know it's late

and you like your sleep but I was thinking

maybe you could come meet me?

Txt me, or call me or whatever...

Rachel...x

So I got the details of where she was and jumped in a cab down to the bar... I think me and Puck came down here the other day, not sure, i had to much of a hang over to really remember...