Author's Note: Thanks for all the reviews. I apologize in advance for any errors, enjoy, nonetheless. I also apologize for the Finchel that's going to pop up shortly.
The day before her party, Rachel Berry decided it was time for her and Finn to 'make love.' She felt bad for cheating on him, even if he had cheated on her.
She made her way to Finn's house, and knocked on the door a couple of times before he answered. "Hey, Rachel," he greeted as he opened the door.
"Can we go to your room?"
"Yeah, sure, of course, Rach," Finn replied before he led her upstairs. "Look, I'm sorry for what Seph-"
"Shh," Rachel murmured before kissing him, cutting him off. He roughly kissed her back, and Rachel notes how different her one night stand and her actual boyfriend are. From what she can remember, his lips were soft and smooth, while Finn's were rough and chapped.
Rachel urgently brought the both of them to his uncleaned bed, and when her hand traveled lower and lower, Finn stopped her immediately. "What are you doing, Rach?"
"Didn't you want us to have sex awhile ago?" Rachel questioned, hoping Finn would say that he didn't want to anymore.
"Yeah, but right now?"
"...If you want." Please say no, please say no.
"Okay, let's do it," he said instead. Fudge.
Rachel locked their lips together again, and soon, they are both stripped naked.
"Finn, stop, do you have a condom?"
"Ah shit, no, I don't."
Rachel groans, "Okay, just don't come in me."
He nods and then he's in her forcefully within seconds, and he's being so rough. Rachel finds no pleasure in this and is mildly uncomfortable. She just laid there, biting her bottom lip from the pain, and tried to think of the other night. She feels Finn thrust a few times before she feels something fuzzy and warm within her. She immediately sits up.
"Finn!"
"I'm so sorry, you know I have early arrival problems!"
The next night, the first to arrive to her party were Kurt Hummel, Finn Hudson, Sam Evans, and Mercedes Jones. Rachel's still aggravated at Finn and said nothing to him when he entered her house. She greeted the other three with a welcoming hug. As she sat back down on the couch, waiting for the others, Kurt sat down next to her.
"Do you want to talk about it? Finn told me what happened."
"No, I really don't want to," Rachel mumbled back.
Kurt placed a comforting hand on her shoulder. "Okay, you can talk to me when you feel like you need to." He then left her and went back to gossip with his best friend, Mercedes, and her boyfriend, Sam.
The next to arrive were Puck and Lauren Zizes. Puck had brought several boxes of beer, and the duo carried two each at first, before rushing back to Puck's vehicle and bringing in more.
Rachel immediately opened a can of beer and chugged down its contents. She should've learned a lesson last time when she had drunken sex, but she doubted any of the New Direction members would take advantage of her. Finn wouldn't dare touch her after their incident. Puck had a girlfriend, Lauren, who would slaughter him if he cheated on her. Kurt was a flaming homosexual. Artie can't possibly rape her. Mike was dating Tina, as was Sam, who was dating Mercedes.
She finished the beer in seconds, and wiped her lips with a napkin. She decided to not drink another can until everyone's here.
It was the day of Rachel Berry's party. Santana Lopez and Brittany Pierce had practically forced Quinn Fabray to go, despite all her protests.
"I can't go, I have to, uh, do stuff," Quinn lied.
"Bullshit, get dressed, we're leaving right now," Santana ordered.
Quinn frowned, but obeyed anyway. She knew there's no way she can get out of this. Santana can tell if she's lying or not, and it seems like Santana's the only one. Well, other than Brittany, but Brittany could see through everyone in a way.
Quinn ran towards her room and quickly tugged on a random purple tee and a pair of light cerulean jeans from the closet. She grabbed her cellphone, then rushed downstairs, only to find Brittany straddling Santana on her couch.
"I'm gone for five seconds, and you two are already practically having sex on my couch," Quinn murmured as she searched for her keys.
"Chill, we still have our clothes on," Santana replied as Brittany slid off her.
"But, Santana, we have sex all the time with our clothes-" Brittany started.
"Too much info, Britt," Quinn cut her off, tossing her cellphone and keys into her pockets. "Do I really have to go?"
"Yes, you have to," Santana hooked her pinky with Brittany's and galloped out of the house with her in tow. "Let's go, we should've been there awhile ago."
Quinn groaned, and stalked out of her house, locking the door before she got into the back of Santana's vehicle.
Before she could even get of the car, Santana and Brittany were already on Rachel Berry's doorsteps. Quinn rushes towards them, just as Rachel opens the door with a smile. Quinn notices that Rachel's cheeks were tinted pink, which must have meant she had been drinking. She scowls at this.
She throws out her arms, waiting to hug Santana, who wrinkles her nose and merely ducks under her arms and enters the house by herself.
"Don't touch me, Berry," is all she says as she leaves the other three.
Rachel frowns, but her arms are still out, waiting for Brittany, who does hug her and is lifting the brunette off her feet.
"Santana's just mad because Quinn interrupted our sexy times, but it's okay, I'm not mad," Brittany says, before dropping the brunette to her feet.
"Oh," Rachel starts, "I see, well, welcome to my party."
Brittany grins. "Thank you," she replies before passing Rachel to enter the house.
Quinn's heart is beating in her chest, and hopes to god that Rachel doesn't recognize her touch. She feels her appendage harden just a bit when the events flashes through her eyes.
"Hey, Quinn," Rachel greets, interrupting as she holds her arms out, waiting for a hug.
Quinn awkwardly steps into the arms, and embraces the brunette. "Hi." It's a quick hug, due to Quinn pulling away two seconds later. She made sure that her hips did not meet Rachel's, so nothing accidentally pokes her, as she goes through the doorway.
As soon as she sets foot into the house, a can of beer is thrown at her, and she barely catches it.
"Nice catch," Puck compliments, smirking at her from the table, where there's layers and layers of beer.
She rolls her eyes, and plops down on a couch, right next to Santana.
"Who are we missing?" Rachel asks as she clasps her hands together.
"Mike, Tina, and Artie," Kurt Hummel states. As soon as he finishes, there's a knock on the door, and Rachel rushes to greet them.
Artie Abrams enters first in his wheelchair, and a beer is immediately thrown at him.
Tina Cohen-Change comes next, and another beer is thrown at her, too.
Then Mike Chang enters, and he easily catches the beer.
"Now that everyone's here, let's play a game," Puck says, plopping randomly on the floor. "Never have I ever!" There are a few sounds of approval, as everyone descends into a large circle.
Quinn groans inaudibly, she doesn't want to drink and get drunk. She's pretty sure if she does, she'll do something stupid again. She looks at Rachel from the corner of her eye, and the brunette's beaming at the mohawked male and is already gulping down sips.
"Rachel, you start," Puck says, smirking at the brunette.
Rachel sits down right next to Quinn's leg, and Quinn winces slightly as she tries to subtly move her leg. Rachel thinks for a moment before saying.
"Alright, never have I ever... forgotten lyrics to a song I was singing!" Rachel slurs.
Every single person there takes a sip as they stare at Rachel with an odd expression. Quinn only pretends to take a sip, and she catches Santana watching her, knowing what Quinn was doing. Quinn gives her a forced smile.
"My turn," Puck shouts, "Never have I ever had sex with a male."
Santana, Brittany, Rachel, Quinn, and Lauren take a sip. Quinn grimaces at the taste and also of the thought of her and Puck's incident, back when she didn't have her condition. She stares at Rachel, who's still taking a drink, and feels hurt that she is pretty much a male.
"Never have I ever had sex with a stranger," Finn mumbles. Only Puck takes a sip as he smirks. Quinn notices how Rachel almost takes a drink, but stops herself because Finn's staring right at her.
"Never have I ever kissed a person of the same sex," Mercedes says next. Quinn, Brittany, Santana, Lauren, and Kurt all drink. Rachel stares questionably at Quinn.
"Who have you kissed?" Rachel asks Quinn, who blushes when she realizes that Rachel's talking to her.
Instead of saying Rachel, Quinn whispers to her about the other times, "Santana kissed me from a dare a couple of years back. And then Brittany just randomly did once."
"Ah, I see."
"Never have I ever been in a threesome," Kurt mumbles.
Puck, Santana, and Brittany all drink. Brittany starts laughing, and everyone stares at her.
"It's funny, because it was the three of us," she explains as she continues to giggle.
"Too much info," Santana whispers to the blonde.
Puck shouts, "Oh yeah! I remember that time. I was thinking about another time."
Sam thinks for a moment before saying, "Never have I ever had sex in an elevator."
Everyone stares at everyone, and no one drinks. The game continues on.
"Never have I ever killed someone," Artie states.
"Really, Artie?" Santana snaps after no one takes a sip. Brittany places a calming hand on Santana's back, rubbing softly, as Artie sends the duo an apologetic look.
"Well damn, this is boring," Puck comments. "New game."
"What do you suggest?" Rachel questions the group.
"Spin the bottle!" Puck pipes up as he stands, grabbing an empty plastic bottle from the table. "I'll go first!" He says, spinning the bottle nearly right away.
After it a few turns, it lands on Rachel, who sends the mohawked boy a shy smile.
"Woot!" he hoots, as they both merely face each other, since they're sitting right next to each other. Finn's frowning and looks almost as if he was going to cry. Quinn wonders if Rachel told him that she had cheated on him or if she had kept it to herself.
Rachel and Puck kiss, and Rachel notes how his lips were almost like Finn's, just less chapped and less rough. After a few seconds, though, she pulls back, and finds her way back to Quinn's leg.
Puck pouts as he slides back into his seat. It's Rachel's turn, who spins it and it lands on Brittany, who claps to herself. They meet each other halfway, and Quinn can see a bit of tongue, and crosses her legs to cover a growing bulge. She doesn't seem to be the only one doing so as she scans the crowd of people. Santana suddenly pokes at Brittany, who finally pulls away from the brunette, who can't seem to stop smiling. They both return to their seat as Puck's yelling inappropriate phrases.
Brittany then spins it. The bottle lands right on Quinn, who can feel Santana glaring at her.
"Ooh, Quinn!" Brittany applauded to herself as she crawls over her girlfriend to Quinn. Quinn turns to face the blonde Cheerio, and their lips meet right away. Brittany's hand is on her knee, and the other is on her neck, pulling her closer. Quinn has no idea where to place her hands, she's afraid Santana would kill her in her sleep no matter where her hands are. It's only when she feels Brittany's tongue poking at her bottom lip, Santana decides to tear away her girlfriend from her friend.
"That was hot," Puck comments immediately afterwards.
"Quinn's hot, I'm hot, it's suppose to be hot," Brittany states as she shrugs nonchalantly.
Santana still seems pretty pissed, and Quinn almost moves closer to Rachel and away from Santana, but then she decides not to, since her hormones are beginning to rage again after that kiss. And being closer to Rachel certainly will not help.
Quinn spins the bottle this time, and groans inaudibly in her head when it lands on the brunette to the left of her. It seems like someone's out to get her or something, because when the hands of a flushed Rachel creeps up to Quinn's pale neck, she knows she's going to hell. The blonde keeps her hands on her knees, before Rachel connects their lips in a languid, slow kiss. Her own hands are squeezing her knees hard, because she knows they want to move upper and upper.
Rachel's tongue is tracing her bottom lip, and she grants entry immediately. And then it's exploring her entire mouth. She can feel her appendage harden greatly, and that's when she pulls away abruptly. She's already up and running towards the restroom as she hears chatter in the living room about her kiss with the brunette.
Author's Note: Any other games? As you can tell, the Finchel 'sex' scene is extremely short, because I can't write Finchel at all, since they're my least favorite ship. :D Please review.