Just then, Rachel stormed out of the room. Will ran after her.
"Rachel, what is it?"
But she wouldn't even turn around to face Will. Will gave up. It wasn't like this was new for Rachel. Will walked back to the choir room. Finn didn't look very happy either.
"What's wrong, Finn?"
"It's that Rachel girl. She was coming on to me, but…I had to say no! I have a girlfriend and a kid!"
"But, don't you like Rachel?"
"Yeah, I guess, I mean, she's nice and pretty and smart and stuff, but what can I do?"
"Well, you could break up with Quinn."
"Break up with Quinn? I can't do that! What about Drizzle?"
"But she's not even your k-"
Will stopped himself.
Silence.
"What?"
"Nothing."
"What did you say? She's not my…she's not my kid? Whose kid is she?"
Will said nothing.
"WHO?"
"noahpuckerman"
"What?"
"Noah Puckerman!"
"Puck? No way, he wouldn't…"
And suddenly Finn realized. It all made sense. You can't get pregnant in a hot tub. Quinn got pregnant by having sex. With Puck.
"Oh my god. He…he did."
"Finn, I'm so sorry."
"Why did you have to tell me? Everything was just fine until you showed up! First you introduce me to this Rachel girl and now you tell me that my daughter isn't my daughter? You've ruined my life!"
Finn ran out.
"Finn, I'm sorry! I'm sorry."
But Finn was gone. Will just wanted to make him and Rachel happy, but he had completely ruined everything. He felt terrible.