They sat around in a circle next to the bed, an empty beer bottle lying in the middle. Kurt and Blaine lounged on the bed arms casually draped over each other watching the game get underway.
"I'll spin first since it's my house" Rachel said in her trademark bossy tone. She winked at Finn and crawled forward on her knees giving the bottle a good hard spin. It landed on Sam and she giggled pulling him up by his arm. Finn looked a little worried but soon relaxed, knowing Rachel loved him and after all, this was only a game.
She pulled Sam into the closet and pressed him up against the wall giggling drunkenly. "I alwass wants to kiss those trou lipss" she slurred pressing her mouth against his and tangling her hands in his hair. Sam put his arms around her waist and kissed her back a little before breaking apart.
"Rachel" he gasped "that was really nice but I think we should stop now" he said thinking of Mercedes and Finn. She pouted but nodded in agreement, following him out of the closet after just four minutes. Both Finn and Mercedes looked pleased and relieved.
Sam spun and got Puck but neither of them wanted to go so he passed his turn to Santana who was sat on his left. Santana licked her lips in anticipation hoping she got Berry, wanting to taste her. She spun the bottle and waited for it to stop. Finn. She smirked wondering how Rachel would react but bizarrely Rachel was grinning and winking at Finn like she was fine with it. She walked over to him, her heels sinking into Rachel's carpet and pulled him up by his shirt. "Come with me Finnocence" she whispered seductively dragging him into the closet. He cast a helpless glance over his shoulder at Rachel who just grinned back and gave him the thumbs up.
Santana pulled him inside the closet, backing herself up against the wall and pulling him in between her toned thighs. "Kiss me" she drawled pulling his face towards hers "even your girlfriend wants this Finnocence" she purred pressing her glossy red lips against his. He kissed her back, knowing it didn't mean anything and Rachel bizarrely did seem okay with it. Santana wrapped her hands around Finn's butt pulling him into her and ground her hips into his. He pushed her back blushing. "Wait." he said feeling the stirrings of a serious erection approaching.
"What's wrong Finn?" she asked sounding irritated "don't tell me you're gay now" he saw her eyes flash in the dark.
"No I'm not gay" he said sounding insensed "I'm just not all that comfortable with this going further than kissing" he explained defensively. "I love Rachel and she.."
Santana cut him off "Oh please spare me the details about you and Berry before I puke on your boner." she said scathingly. Damn, he thought, she had felt it. "Here's the deal Finn," she said poking her fingernail into his chest. "Your girlfriend out there is totally aroused by the prospect of me and I know you are too and this..." she trailed her hand down to his groin and squeezed through his jeans, "is just an inevitability" she kissed him again, pushing her tongue deep inside of his mouth and massaging his tongue with it. Finn pulled back again after a few seconds.
"What do you mean she's aroused by you?" he asked feeling dumb.
"Newsflash Frankenteen" she said bitingly "when Quinn and I were grinding it out on the dancefloor, you weren't the only one with your tongue hanging out" she smirked. "Seems your Berry is ripe to be picked by someone other than you" she grinned. Finn was shocked, he had no idea Rachel was interested in chicks, like, at all.
"Are you sure?" he asked her "How do you know?"
"Little things I noticed, the way she stares at my legs and my butt when I dance. The way her eyes have barely left my cleavage all night...much like yours" she laughed. "You can relax though, she's not a lesbian, she's curious. She still loves you, don't worry" she pulled him close again, pressing her breasts into his chest and licking his lips. "She's like you Finn, she knows I'm hot to look at, and..." she paused to rub his erection again causing him to jump "she knows I can give her pleasure, just like you sweetcheeks" she laughed at the expression on his face. and pushed him out of the closet before he could ask any more questions.
He stumbled out of the closet hoping and praying no one could see his hard on. Rachel smiled at him and licked her lips pulling him back down into the circle and kissing his lips passionately. Maybe Santana had been right, Rachel certainly seemed keen to get a taste. Santana strutted out of the closet, pulling her skirt down and wiping her lips, clearly trying to make it look like more happened than actually happened. She grinned at Rachel and the smaller girl smiled back shyly blushing up at her. Finn looked between them curiously and pulled Rachel closer to whisper to her. "Do you want to be in that closet with Santana or me?" feeling a little jealous. Rachel squeezed his knee reassuringly.
"Actually Finn..." she whispered back "I'd really like to be in there with both of you." she licked his ear seductively and Finn groaned. This fucking hard on wasn't going anywhere soon that's for sure.