Ah your reviews make me super happy! Here is another chapter (see what happens when you review) :) Hope you guys love it!
I wake up to hearing the doorbell ringing and then banging on the door. My head is pounding and I shove my head under my pillow and groan. Who the fuck is banging on the door? All of a sudden I hear Alyssa's voice coming from behind the front door and some banging. I'm so hungover that I am hearing Alyssa, that is some serious imagination. I hear the banging again. Ugh! I go to get up but there is a body half on mine. I then remember Ashley was here and told her to get off of me. I hear the body groan…and its not Ashley. I look at the face and holy shit! Riley! Oh my god I cheated on Ashley with my bestfriend!
I fly off the bed and look at it. I'm shocked to see not only a naked Riley but also a naked Ashley. I soon remembered everything, all the events from lastnight. We had a threesome, and we had sex for hours. Then I remembered what Ashley told me. Shit my dad and Alyssa is here at my front door. Oh my god I had sex with my bestfriend…which is my sister's girlfriend. Oh my god.
"Get up now!" I said to both of them. "Alyssa and my dad are at the door! Get some clothes on now!" I said. I ran to get some clothes on and stopped right infront of the mirror to see three deep cuts on my back, I then look at Riley's back and see the samething. Oh my god, I want to die!
"Wait what? What's going on? Oh my god is it the fire alarm!" Riley said falling off the bed and starting to run out of the bedroom.
"No idiot! They are here. Get some clothes on now!" I hissed at her. She looked at me and then Ashley.
"Oh my god…oh my god. Oh my god." She said panicking.
"Yes I know, just please put some clothes on." I said to her.
Ashley got dressed and went right back on the bed. Was fast asleep again. I left her and ran to the front door.
"Dad, Alyssa! You woke me up." I said with a fake smile and a pounding headache. "What time is it?"
"Spence! I missed you, where is my girlfriend?" Alyssa said kissing my cheek and walking right passed me and looking for Riley. Guilt came right to me.
"Hi hunny, its 10:23." My dad said kissing my forehead. "Lets go to a diner I'm sure you want some coffee."
I put my hand on my forehead and pray for this scary dream to be over. I walk to my room and see Alyssa sitting on my bed poking Ashley.
"Is she dead?" Alyssa said looking at me in wonder.
"Probably." Said Riley walking in my room. She gave me a look.
"Riley! I missed you so much!" Said Alyssa jumping into her arms and kissing her softly.
"I-I missed you too Lyss." Riley stuttered. I knew she was so guilty, as was I…for Ashley, well she was dead on my bed.
"Spence, you have more underwear on the floor than I own." Alyssa said looking at three thongs and three bras on the floor near the bed. A set owned my Riley that I ripped off of her last night.
"Ha yeah I just tend to throw them on the floor and pass out…too tired to put them away these past few days because of finals and stuff." I said nervously.
My dad walked into my room. "Is Ashley dead?"
"Oh I guess I should check." I answered walking up to her now. I started to touch her when she jumped up, startled or something.
"Holy shit we did not do that last night!" She said out loud. I stood there stunned, shocked at what she just blurted out…and it needed to be covered up quick!
"What did you do last night?" Alyssa said in confusion. Ashley looked at her with wide eyes and then looked at me. I guess Ashley wasn't sleeping and all of a sudden remembered what happened and freaked.
"Ah….I don't know?" I said lamely.
"Oh Ash are you talking about how Spence and I took your clothes off and made you dance the chicken dance?" Riley said. She looked at me and gave me the "that was the stupidest thing I've ever came up with" look. I totally agree but played along.
"Oh yeah Ash, I totally forgot! That was hilarious, you were a little drunk." I said playing along in this twisted game.
"She was actually plastered…it didn't take much for her to get her clothes off…tells you something." Said Riley with a grin. She was liking this game now, and I think it was taking her mind off of things.
"Okay we get it Ri!" Ashley said getting up. "I need coffee."
We all agreed and decided to walk to a diner two blocks away. These three days were going to suck.
After the diner we went back to the apartment and just relaxed. I think my dad and sister understood…to a certain extent…that we had a long night and couldn't do much today so we sat down on the couches and had a major Netflix movie day. It was relaxing but at the same time gave me time to think about last night. I'm not going to deny and say it wasn't hot, because it was very fucking hot, but it was wrong too. It was super wrong because I had a threesome with my sister's girlfriend. I wouldn't be so flipped out if my bestfriend wasn't dating my sister, I mean yeah it would be kinda weird knowing she is so close to me but having sex with your bestfriend isn't wrong, it's the cheating part that sucks. I'm not jealous that her and Ashley had sex, I mean you can't be to have this happen. I obviously wouldn't want Ashley to go off and have sex with other people, I love her. This all goes down to my sister and how all three of us betrayed her. Her sister, girlfriend, and close friend betrayed her, and if she found out this would crush her. I had to talk to Ashley and Ri, this could not get out…especially to Alyssa.
After watching a few movies and chilling out in the living room we decided it was time to get a good nights rest. Riley and I did have classes tomorrow morning. Riley was in the bathroom brushing her teeth with Ashley and I took this opportunity to talk to them. I walked in and shut the door.
"Guys we need to talk." They looked at me and nodded their heads. "We can't tell Alyssa…we can't tell anyone, because if it gets around it will eventually find it's way to Alyssa. You remember what we said lastnight at the party, what happens at the party and after, stays with us forever! I can't have my little sister crushed." I said to both of them in a whisper.
"Spence, I love her! We have to tell her at some point. I can't live forever with the biggest secret that I cheated on her with you AND Ashley…at the sametime." Riley said guilt written all over her face.
Ashley was on my side. "You know that would kill her Ri. You two would break up and she wouldn't speak to any of us. Look I'd like to say it was a mistake but it obviously wasn't. We knew exactly what we were doing, we just had the alcohol give us that last push to make it happen." Ashley said and she was right.
Riley sat on the toilet and put her head to her knees. "Guys I regret it, but then I don't…Oh my god your dad basically made me family and I totally shitted on his daughter! Because I fucked his other daughter!"
"Riley lower your voice!" I said. "We are all wrong here okay? You can't just blame yourself and start thinking things like that. We are human, and humans do things that suck! So we just have to suck it up and not mention this at all ever. Riley I love you and I can't see you hurt okay? Ashley and I will make sure everything is okay."
"Yeah Ri, we both love you and wouldn't do something to hurt you." Ashley chimed in.
Riley thought about it for awhile and finally answered.
"Biggest secret ever…has to be the hottest thing ever. You guys ready to live with that secret and not let it happen again?" She said waiting for our answers.
"Never again." Said Ashley. She actually seemed unsure about that, like she wanted it to happen again even thought she knew it was so wrong. Honestly, it was so hot its hard to not think about it.
I took a deep breath and looked in Riley's eyes. "Never again."
And for a moment, I thought I saw that glimpse of lust come back to Riley's eyes. I had a bad feeling about all of this.
Tell me what you think! I will give you guys a heads up…major drama will be coming! I'm not sure how I'm going to play this out yet, I want it to be insane. It seems like the girls want more of this sex action…but like I said don't know what I'm going to do! I will figure it out lol Probably lose some sleep but then be like "GOT IT!" lol Reviews :)