Puck is sitting in his apartment thinking about Blaine. The former Warbler has become his every thought. His heart races every time he sees Blaine's dazzling smile. It skips a beat whenever Blaine's fingers brush across his skin. It nearly stops when Blaine's lips press themselves to his own. He hates himself for loving Blaine too. Despite the fact that Blaine was the one who started the sneaking around he wanted to do nothing more than to tell Kurt the truth. Kurt had been through too much and deserved better than this. He was scared that if he told Kurt the truth then he might lose Blaine in the process.
A knock at his door breaks his train of thought. He slips on a wife beater and answers the door in his red boxers. Sam is unexpectedly paying him a visit. Puck had been trying to distance himself from everyone so he and Blaine wouldn't have to worry about getting caught. It hurt him to do it. He missed his friends. Sam and Finn especially were missed. He didn't want to have sex with them, he just wanted to be with his buds. He smiled at Sam as he opened the door.
"Sup Sammy boy? Where's Finn?" he asks with a smug tone.
"Not much just came to hang out for a while before I head to work. Finn's sleeping off last night. He and I are both really sore." Sam says rubbing his ass.
"You too go at it hard last night?" Puck says letting Sam in.
Puck doesn't have a lot of furniture, let alone apartment space (just a bedroom and a bathroom) so he takes a seat on the bed. "Yeah we both got double stuffed last night. It was so freaking hot dude."
Puck thinks for a minute and remembers that would mean that Finn and Sam had at least one other person with them. "Who joined you guys…unless you just used that lame dildo Finn stole from Santana back when we were sophomores."
"Mr. Schue….wait that used to be Santana's?" Sam says with wide eyes.
Puck's jaw has dropped to the floor at the news of Mr. Schue hooking up with his buds. "You're freaking kidding me! He did not bang both of you! And yeah, he swiped it after she made him a man, it was like a souvenir, though I usually take their panties, but whatever."
"Oh that's …God I hope he washed it before he used it on me that first time. Anyways, yeah he banged us, so I could pass history. Then we double stuffed his ass." Puck sits next to Sam not covering his boner.
"And dude, his cum tasted like strawberries. It was freaking awesome." Sam looked like a boy who woke on Christmas morning and had just gotten a brand new puppy.
"Wow, never thought Schuster would ever screw a student. Guess you and I are the only studs from McKinnley to bang a teacher while we were students." Puck says feeling proud of Sam for getting his hands on a T.I.L.F.
"Yeah, well I gotta stop with all the 3ways and 5ways. Finn and I have barely planned the wedding. All we have is a location in New York, a date, and Finn's two best men…three if you'd ever reply to one of his texts. Blaine, and Rory are going to by my best men, Mike is gonna be a groomsman. Arties the ring bearer and Brittany is the flower girl. Quinn and Rachel are gonna do a duet while Finn and I walk each other down the aisle. Santana is going to officiate. Mercedes told me to go to hell when I invited her. Tina is going to try and sing My Funny Valentine. I really hope she doesn't break down again. We still have a lot of work, like sending out invites, getting a caterer, and tuxes need to be picked out. Thank God for Kurt, he's been so awesome with the planning so far." Just hearing the name breaks Puck's heart.
"Sounds awesome dude, but I gotta drain the lizard. Be right back." Puck gets up and runs to the bathroom, locking the door behind him.
Puck's phone begins to buzz catching Sam's attention. He looks closer and sees that Kurt is calling, but it's a picture of Blaine and Kurt kissing. Sam decides to be nosy and answer the phone.
"Hello." Sam says trying not to be too loud.
"Sam?" Kurt's voice sounds confused on the other end.
"Yeah, Kurt its me." Sam says getting a bad feeling.
"Why do you have Blaine's phone?" Kurt asks still confused.
"Uh, I guess he left it in my car." Sam says realizing what might be going on. He doesn't want Kurt to know until he's certain.
"Oh, ok well when you see him let him know I'm looking for him. He didn't come home until late last night and I'm really nervous about asking him to marry me. What if he says no?" Kurt says sounding like he's about to have a panic attack.
"Calm down Kurt. I'm sure Blaine was just working on his auditions for NYADA and NYU just like the rest of us have been. And as for popping the question, just relax and do it in a way that's simple but totally unexpected." Sam hates himself for telling Kurt all of this, knowing that his friend's heart was probably going to get ripped out of his chest if Sam was right.
"Thanks Sam. I'll see you tonight for dinner. I've got a couple new recipes I want to try so don't eat anything between work and home ok?" Kurt says happily.
Sam laughs into the phone. "Ok Kurt, I'll see you then. Bye."
"Bye Sam." Kurt says before Sam ends the call.
Sam checks behind him and the door to the bathroom is still shut. He decides to go through the phone. He finds dozens of calls and texts between Blaine and Puck that are dirty and definitely cheating. He finds photos of the two of them kissing and other compromising positions. Sam's face fills with rage. He wants nothing more than to hurt Puck for coming between Blaine and Kurt. He was angry with Blaine too, but Blaine had helped him after he was raped and he killed Ryan trying to protect Kurt, so Puck had to have taken advantage of him being emotionally damaged.
Puck walks back into the room. "Woo, I feel like I just peed a whole pool out of my dick."
Sam turns around and holds up the phone with a pic of Blaine and Puck kissing. "What are you doing with Blaine?" Sam asks giving Puck one chance to explain himself.
Puck loses his breath and begins to hyperventilate. Sam sits him down on the bed and calms him down, trying not to strangle him. "I never meant for it to happen. I never meant to fall in l…love with him. I beg him all the time to tell Kurt, but he won't. I don't like being this guy anymore. But, I can't help it. He makes me want to be better than I am. He tells me that I'm smart and I'm talented. I've never had that before, Sam. Please don't tell anyone. I can't lose him."
Sam lets Puck cry on his shoulder. "What about Kurt, Puck. You're going to break his heart. He deserves someone that's not going to cheat on him. Why don't you tell him and then you can have Blaine to yourself?" Sam says choking on his words.
"NO I CAN'T! I'll lose Blaine!" Puck says freaking out.
"Puck this will get out eventually, and honestly, if Blaine really wanted to be with you instead of Kurt, wouldn't he just end their relationship to be with you?" Puck knows Sam is right, but he can't accept it. He loves Blaine too much.
"Look Puck, I'll keep your secret for now, but you and Blaine had better tell Kurt soon, because he's about to ask Blaine to marry him." Sam says firmly. He grabs Blaine's phone and leaves the apartment with Puck sitting there in shambles.
Finn and Kurt are sitting at the breakfast table. Kurt takes out a few photos of men in tuxedos and shows them to Finn. "I think you could wear this one, it would go well with your skinny, lanky frame. This one would look stunning on Sam, the silver trim in the lapels would go well with his eyes."
Finn smiles at Kurt, thankful to have his brother's help with the wedding that was just months away, though he felt guilty for taking Kurt away from planning his set list for regionals. "Kurt, I just want to say thanks for all that you've done for me and Sam. You're an awesome brother you know that? I promise I'll help you plan the set list for regionals later since, you're helping me."
"No problem, I planned the list last night. They open with Payphone, by Maroon 5, the trouble tones will sing Stars by Grace Potter and the Nocturnals, and then they'll finish it up with The Vision of Love by Kris Allen." Kurt says looking over a few other tux ideas.
"Wow that's a pretty good list, Kurt. I'm impressed." Finn says looking at a tux that Kurt had vetoed for both Sam and Finn.
"Thanks." Kurt says looking up for a moment.
"What about this one?" Finn says sliding the picture over to Kurt.
Kurt sighs, "Finn we've been over this one, its meant for a shorter skinny man. It wouldn't work on either of you."
"I was actually thinking it would look good on you for your wedding." Finn says looking at Kurt with a simple smile.
Kurt looks up with the biggest grin. "You're right its perfect for me! You rock Finn!" Kurt runs over and hugs Finn tightly.
"I'm glad I could actually help you find something. Now all you have to do is propose." Finn says hugging Kurt back.
Kurt backs off. "I know exactly how I'm going to do it to!" Kurt reaches into his pocket and pulls out a white leather box. He opens it and in it lies a white gold ring, with the word COURAGE engraved on the inside. Kurt smiles at the ring knowing he had some work to do before he proposed.
OK so I'm hoping everyone is enjoying the story. In the next couple of chapters I'm going to bring in a character from last season who will have a major impact on how the story will go and they will forever change things for Kurt, Blaine, and Puck.