Sam walks through his apartment door around three in the afternoon. Finn is chopping up some vegetables in the kitchen and hasn't noticed Sam walking in. He jumps out of fear, but relaxes when he feels Sam kiss the side of his neck.
"What are you doing home?" Finn asks putting the knife down.
"Got sent home early, they said I looked too angry and then when I stopped looking angry they said I looked sick so they sent me home early." Sam says placing Blaine's phone on the counter.
Finn turns around to face Sam. He feels his fiancé's forehead. Its normal in terms of temperature, but Sam does look like he doesn't feel well. "Well you don't feel warm or anything. Are you worried about something, cause you do kinda look like you want to puke."
Sam looks around the apartment. "Is Kurt home? I know Blaine's still at work, I saw him on my way out and didn't have a chance to talk to him. But I can't say anything if Kurt is home."
Finn can hear a slight panic in Sam's voice. "Kurt is meeting Mr. Schue to discuss the set list he made for Regionals. He won't be back for about another thirty minutes. What's going on Sam? You're making me nervous."
Sam picks up Blaine's phone and opens up the pictures. He hands it to Finn. "Blaine's having an affair with Puck."
Finn couldn't believe the pics he was looking at. Each one made him angrier and angrier. "I can't believe this! We have to tell Kurt, and then I have to kill Blaine!"
Sam knows Finn doesn't mean what he says, but he needs to calm Finn down so he doesn't do anything stupid. He takes the phone away from Finn. He closes out of the pics and sets the phone back on the counter. Sam pulls Finn into his arms.
"Finn, we can't tell Kurt. Not yet anyways. I owe Blaine enough to let him tell Kurt the truth." Sam says running his hands over Finn's back.
Finn slows his breathing down and he quells his anger. "Sam, Kurt deserves the truth. I know Blaine helped you after you were raped, but still, he's cheating on my brother. I can't just stand here and let him hurt Kurt like this. I mean Kurt's planning on proposing tomorrow night. He's taking Blaine to Dalton and he's gonna perform a Katie Perry number with the Warblers, like Blaine did when he and Kurt first met." Sam sees the hurt in Finn's eyes.
"Just give me a chance to talk to Blaine first so that way he can be the one to tell Kurt the truth." Sam says with pleading eyes.
"Ok, I'll give him until tonight to tell Kurt the truth, or else I'm gonna tell Kurt, and you'll be there when I do." Finn says sounding upset.
Sam nods and he starts to walk off to his and Finn's room, but Finn grabs him by the wrist. "Sam, I just want you to know that I could never cheat on you. I love you too much to ever hurt you that way."
"I know babe, that's why I love you. I couldn't do that to you either, it would kill me. Although I did give Mr. Schue a blowy on the way home yesterday."
Finn smiles, "You were just getting my present warmed up for me, how could I be mad about that?"
Sam kisses Finn softly and smiles as he pulls away.
"You know I love you, right?" Finn says smiling at his fiancé.
"I love you more." Sam says before kissing Finn one more time.
…..
Puck has spent the past few hours freaking out in his apartment. He's cried over the fact that Kurt will likely never forgive him for the things that he's done and that he could likely lose Blaine if Sam tells anyone the truth. He decides that Blaine should be given a heads up so he drives over to the mall and finds Blaine just as he's getting through with his shift.
"Blaine!" Puck yells as Blaine walks out of the store.
Blaine turns and is surprised to see his dirty mistress is paying him a visit at work. He walks over to Puck trying to act like he's just greeting a friend. "Hey Puckerman, how's it hangin'?" Blaine says casually.
"We have a problem." Puck says as his body shakes with fear.
"What do you mean we have a problem?" Blaine says angrily.
Puck flinches at Blaine's tone. "Sam came by…thi..this morning and you ….had l…left your phone on my nightstand and Kurt called while I was in the bathroom. And I uh….I guess Sam answered and then he went through the phone. But, he said he wouldn't t….tell anyone."
Blaine's mind is racing a mile a minute. Puck is shaking uncontrollably. He's worried Blaine is going to hate him forever and no longer want to be him. Blaine takes Puck by the arm and leads him out of the mall quickly. When they get outside Blaine lets go of Puck.
"What were you thinking leaving my phone lying around!" Blaine demanded an answer and Puck looked like he was about to cry.
"I'm sorry baby. I screwed up." Puck says with a sob.
"Don't give me that 'I'm sorry' crap! You've wanted me to end it with Kurt since we started this affair! I bet you did this on purpose!" Blaine snaps at Puck.
Puck flinches and Blaine shoves him hard. Puck falls on his side and cuts his forehead on the license plate of a car. He winces in pain as blood begins to trickle down his face.
"Now look what you did!" Blaine barks at Puck.
"You're pathetic Puck. You were nothing more than a good time to me. I've never even liked you." Blaine kicks some loose gravel at the older boy.
"Blaine, please don't. I love you." Puck says with tears streaming down his cheeks.
Blaine laughs a slight maniacal laugh. "Please, you wouldn't know love if it came up and sucked your dick and then married you. Guys like you are only good for sex and keeping it a secret. Looks like you suck at that too."
Blaine turns and walks off. He hopes he can repair what damage is likely to happen between him and Kurt. Puck was dead to him now. There was no forgiving him for allowing Sam to find out about their affair. Blaine gets in his car and speeds away.
Puck sits up and leans against the car that had cut him. He cries for a few more minutes knowing the only person that he'd ever truly loved had just torn his heart into shreds and left it out for the vultures. He wiped the blood from his forehead with the sleeve of his denim jacket. He winces when he touches the wound. He pulls out his phone and calls the only person he knows will listen to him.
"Sam, I need your help." Puck says sobbing into the phone.
….
Finn watches as Sam leaves quickly after getting a call from Puck. He barely had a chance to say goodbye. A few minutes later Blaine walks into the apartment. He nearly loses his head as he barely dodges the flying cellphone that Finn has just thrown.
"You left that at Puck's you bastard." Finn says sounding angrier than he ever has.
"Finn, you have to let me explain. I never meant for anything to happen with Puck, it just did. I don't love him or anything. I only want Kurt." Blaine says hoping Finn will be stupid enough to believe him.
"Really, cause based on some of those texts you were either leading Puck on so you could screw him into loving you, or you actually did have feelings for Puck. And I gotta say either way, you'd better tell Kurt by the end of the night, or I will and then I'm gonna beat your ass for hurting my brother!" Finn's eyes are filled with rage and Blaine sees that he's not going to win this one just yet.
"Finn, I promise I will tell him when he gets home if you'll just calm down. Cause you're scaring me." Blaine says pretending to be afraid.
Finn knew something bad was headed for their family and Blaine was the cause. He knew Kurt was about to get his heartbroken. He wants to be angry with Puck, but after reading all of the ones he sent Blaine, he knows that Puck was being genuine and honest. He even wrote that he wanted Blaine to end his relationship with Kurt several times. Finn could tell that Blaine had become that guy who takes advantage of the person he's having an affair with and tells them that he loves them an only them. He just hoped that Kurt would kick Blaine to the curb and find a quick way to get over the son of a bitch.
Sorry this one was a little shorter than I'd hoped. But that's it for this chapter. Next up will most likely be Kurt learning the truth and something unexpected will happen.
