Finn walks into his room. He smiles when he sees Sam sitting on the edge of the bed waiting for him. He closes the door behind him. Sam is smiling at him. Finn wants to speak, but Sam gets up and walks over to him. He's now less than an inch from Sam's face. He can feel Sam's breath come across his lips. Sam tilts his head forward. Their noses touch first and Finn can't control himself and he grabs Sam, pulling him in for the first kiss the two have shared since the car accident.
Sam turns the tables and pushes Finn onto the bed. He rips off Finn's shirt and attacks his chest, kissing and licking his way up to Finn's neck. Finn moans in pleasure as he feels Sam's hands go for his pants. Sam removes Finn's jeans and boxers in one fell swoop. Finn pushes Sam away and takes off his lover's shirt. He pulls Sam in and traces his tongue over those perfect abs. He rips open Sam's jeans and takes the full length of Sam's cock into his mouth. He bobs his head up and down quickly.
Sam pushes him away. Finn knows Sam must've been close to do that. Finn is now flat on his back and Sam is giving the greatest blowjob of his life. He was getting close and he tried to think of the mailman, but it wasn't working. "Sam…SAM! I'M GONNNAAAAAA! UUUUUGGGGHHHHHHH!" Finn blows his load into the back of Sam's mouth.
Sam stands up and smiles at Finn and he leans over and kisses Finn. Their tongues dance in each other's' mouths both getting a good taste of Finn's cum. Sam lifts Finn to the head of the bed and is on top of him. He reaches for the lube and coats his cock. He eases his way into Finn's hole. Finn sighs with a smile on his face. He's missed being intimate with Sam. Hell, he's missed Sam all together. A few tears of happiness fall from his eyes and Sam wipes them away before kissing Finn. Sam starts out with slow thrusts. He's already hitting Finn's sweet spot. Finn holds onto Sam for dear life, never wanting the moment to end.
Finn can feel himself building up for a second explosion. His fingers dig into Sam' shoulders as he cums onto his and Sam's abs. He hadn't even touched himself. He clenches his ass muscles and Sam lets out a low moan and Finn can feel Sam unloading deep inside him. Sam rolls off of Finn.
"I love you so much. I've missed you so much, Sam." Finn says as he rolls onto his side.
Sam doesn't say anything. Instead he rolls out of bed, grabs his clothes and gets dressed. He walks over to the door and walks out of the room. Finn gets up, throws on his pants quickly and runs after Sam.
"Sam, wait! Where are you going?!" Finn calls out running after him. He grabs Sam by the arm.
Sam looks disgusted at Finn. "What the hell is wrong with you Finn? I'm not gay anymore. I'm with Mercedes. Whatever it was you and I had…it died in that car accident along with Blaine and Sebastian." Sam's tone was harsh and Finn's heart shattered.
"But, we…" Finn stammers.
"But we what? You can't make me gay again Finn. I'm not a homo like you." Sam shoves Finn to the ground and runs off.
Finn gets to his feet and runs after Sam. He doesn't care what Sam thinks, he knows Sam still loves him on some level. He opens to door to the apartment in time to see Sam driving away with Mercedes kissing his cheek.
"SAM!" Finn calls out.
Finn watches as the car turns out of the parking lot and is hit by a speeding black truck. Before he knows what's going on he's next to Sam. He's holding the blonde boy in his arms, shaking him as he tries to wake him. Sam's eyes open for a moment.
"You have to let me go Finn." Sam says before the light fades from his eyes and a final breath escapes his lips.
"Finn wake up! Wake up!" Finn sits up gasping for air and sobbing uncontrollably. He sees Kurt sitting on the edge of his bed with a look of worry. Finn grabs Kurt and holds him tightly as he cries on his brother's shoulders.
"Finn! Finn, I can't breathe!" Kurt squawks out. Finn calms himself enough to let Kurt go.
Kurt scoots closer and hugs his brother. "Hey, it's ok, Finn, you're alright."
Finn shakes his head. "He's never going to love me again." His words are barely heard, but Kurt holds Finn tighter, knowing how badly Finn is hurting.
"You're going to get him back, Finn. You have Santana ready to take out Mercedes…who I hate to say has become my least favorite person on this planet. But, Sam belongs with you…eve if he doesn't realize it."
"How do you know?" Finn asks wiping his eyes.
Kurt sighs, knowing he probably should've told Finn the day it happened, but he didn't want to give Finn false hope. He knows now he needs to tell him. "Finn, he's still wearing his engagement ring."
Finn's eyes go wide. "What!? I figured he would've taken it off as soon as he could."
"He's tried, even other people can't take it off of him…even when he's sleeping. He clenches his fist every time." Finn is speechless. "Finn, Sam is still in there, he' just buried under the surface."
Finn nods and Kurt starts to leave. "Kurt," Finn says quietly.
Kurt turns around "What is it?" Kurt can see how hard this has all been on Finn, and though he too is still grieving, he knew Finn had been right the other day. He didn't have to see the ghost of his dead boyfriends, but Finn did.
"Will you stay with me tonight?" Finn's eyes were worn from all the crying he'd done both sleeping and when he woke up.
"Scoot over." Kurt says as he climbs into bed with his brother. It isn't long before the two are fast asleep.
…
The next afternoon Santana is waiting in the Lima Bean. She smiles when she sees Finn arrive. He buys her a cup of coffee and they talk about the plan they've been working on.
"I don't know if I'm ok with murdering a person, Santana…Even if it is Mercedes." Finn says shutting down the idea of hiring a hitman to take out Mercedes.
"Ugh, fine, nothing physically harmful…guess that leaves emotional harm…yay!" Santana finishes her sentence with her famous raspy, quiet "yay." The last time she'd given the bitchy yay was when Rachel dressed like Britney Spears.
"So what do you have in mind?" Finn asks.
Santana holds up her finger as she takes out a new cell phone. She makes a call and waits for an answer. When she hears an older man answer she disguises her voice with a New Jersey accent.
"Hi yes, this is Gina from the Unplanned and Unwanted Clinic, and I was looking for Mercedes Jones. She's missed her last two appointments for her mandatory After the Abortion therapy. Could you please have her call us back. …Yes she has our number. ….No thank you Mr. Jones, and again we're very sorry about your unplanned event. We hope you and your girlfriend are happy it's been dealt with." She hangs up the phone. She smiles an innocent, yet evil smile and Finn shivers at the deviousness of the phone call.
"Santana, that….was…wow. I should be disappointed in you and myself for that matter….but strangely, I just don't care. I actually enjoyed that." Finn says with a look of confusion of his feeling pleased with how Santana's first move was made.
"Welcome to the dark side, Finnyboy." Santana laughs and the two begin their plans for the next phase.
….
Kurt gets off work early and heads home to take a much needed nap. As he walks through the door he finds Puck sitting on the couch. He drops his keys in the bowl and shuts the door. He can tell Puck has been crying for a while. "Puck, what are you doing here?" Kurt asks with a worried tone.
Puck looks up at Kurt. His face is becoming pale. He's holding his wrist. Kurt notices blood coming up from between his fingers. Kurt runs over to the bar and grabs a cloth napkin he had out. He runs over to Puck and forces him to move his hand as he applies pressure. He wipes away the blood and sees that it's only a small cut. He looks up at Puck with horror and anger in his face.
"I couldn't do it. I kept hearing Blaine's voice, begging me not to go through with it." Tears are falling from Puck's face as he speaks and Kurt can only be angry with him.
Kurt's hand slaps Puck hard across the face. "YOU STUPID BOY!" Kurt slaps him again but Puck doesn't flinch. "DO YOU HAVE ANY IDEA HOW SELFISH OF YOU THIS IS!? DO YOU HAVE ANY IDEA OF WHAT THIS WOULD DO TO FINN?! TO OUR FRIENDS!? TO ME?!" Puck just sits there and takes all that Kurt has to dish out. Kurt storms off, but returns with peroxide, rubbing alcohol, Neosporin, and bandages. He cleans the cut, the whole time he just rants about how angry he is at Puck for this stunt.
When Kurt finishes, he raises his hand like he's going to slap the poor boy one last time, but he stares into the sad eyes of his friend. He grabs Puck by his shirt collar and pulls him in and kisses him hard and fast. His tongue invades Puck's mouth and Puck deepens the kiss and grabs on to Kurt. Kurt forces himself to stop kissing Puck. Puck tries to kiss him again, but he stops him. Puck pushes Kurt aside and runs out of the apartment crying.
Kurt sits there crying. He feels like he just cheated on Sebastian and Blaine at the same time. He cleaned up the remnants of the bandages he'd used and throws them in the trash. He goes into his room and lies down. He rolls onto his side and staring at him is a picture of him and Sebastian at the park, laughing and holding each other as they smile for the camera. "I'm so sorry." Kurt sobs before he cries himself to sleep.
….
"SANTANA!" Mercedes yells across the parking lot at the high school.
Santana walks over to her and smiles. "What's up Fatty McBeefcheeks?"
"What the hell is your problem?! Why would you call my dad and tell him I had an abortion!?" Mercedes face is practically growling and Santana notices a couple of dark hairs on Mercedes' upper lip.
"You know you might want to wax your mustache before you start to look like Burt Reynolds. Although, that may be the look you're going for since Sam is actually gay, and you're just taking advantage of his amnesia!" Santana cocks her head, but then dodges Mercedes' fist. "Careful Lady Lardass, wouldn't want me to go all Lima Heights on yours ass now woulds you?"
"You just wait Santana, you're gonna get it when you least expect it. Sam is mine, he ain't no fag." The word alone is enough to make Santana want to kill her former friend.
"Lookie here Fat Wheezy, if I were yous I'd starts mys car with the autostart button on the remotes." With that Santana walks into the school to say hello to Coach Sylvester and Mr. Schuester.
Mercedes remote starts her car as she walks towards it. The second the engine turns over the car explodes in a giant ball of fire. Santana looks over and see that she's messed up and accidently blown up not just Mercedes car, but she's also set Mr. Schue's care on fire.
Oh well, Mr. Schue needed a new car anyways. Besides it's not like I used anything traceable to blow up that fat bitch's car. I paid four ex-cons to do it for me. They just wanted to see my boobs so no money changed hands and it was merely a suggestion not a request if the cops come knocking on my door.
Mercedes calls her dad and gets a ride from him after the cops say that the explosion must've been caused by a faulty fuel line. They told her she was lucky to have remote started her car before getting in it.
…
Kurt sits up and bed and sitting next to him is Sebastian. "Hi Kurt, I missed you baby." Kurt is speechless.
"I've missed you too." Kurt turns and sees Blaine on his other side.
Tears are falling down his cheeks as he's overcome with happiness. "I've missed you both so much."
Sebastian grabs Kurt's chin and kisses him softly. He pulls away for a moment. "No more talking, we don't have much time." Kurt then feels Blaine's lips attacking his neck as Sebastian attacks his mouth
He opens his eyes and all three are now naked. Blaine and Sebastian are licking their way down his chest, his stomach, and then they both kiss his cock. Sebastian takes the head into his mouth while Blaine takes to tonguing Kurt's tight pink hole.
"Oh God, I never thought I'd be doing this with the two of you! Oh God don't stop!" He feels Blaine push two fingers inside him and he thrust his cock deep into Sebastian's throat. Sebastian pulls off and Kurt whines in disapproval. He lays down next to Kurt and grabs the lube from the nightstand. He begins to lube up his own hole.
"I want you inside of me Kurt. I want us to experience this before we run out of time." Kurt was in heaven and didn't notice the last part of Sebastian's sentence. He positions himself on top of Sebastian and slowly enters his boyfriend. Blaine gets behind Kurt and kisses the back of his neck, lubing up his cock before entering Kurt.
"You're so warm Kurt. I'm so sorry I hurt you before." Blaine whispers into Kurt's ear.
"I forgave you a long time ago Blaine." Kurt turns his attention to Sebastian. "I love you so much."
Sebastian raises himself enough to kiss Kurt passionately. Kurt and Blaine begin their thrust and Sebastian and Kurt moan into each other's mouths. Blaine quickens his pace, which quickens Kurt's. Sebastian is yelling for more and Kurt is all too happy to give it to him as he thrusts in and out like a rabbit.
"So….Close.! UHHHHSSSGGHUUU!" Blaine cries out before unloading inside of Kurt. This sends both Kurt and Sebastian over the edge as they both climax together. Sebastian reaches down and scoops up some of his cum with his fingers and feeds it to both Kurt and Blaine. Blaine pulls out of Kurt and kisses him on the cheek.
"I'll always love you Kurt." Blaine says getting dressed. He finishes by putting his shirt back on. He kisses Kurt one last time on the lips. "Take care of Puck for me. He's lonely and what he did was selfish, so I hope you'll look after him for me."
Kurt nods with tears in his eyes. "I will, I promise." With that Blaine fades away.
Kurt and Sebastian get dressed and Sebastian rolls Kurt on top of him again as they kiss for a few more minutes. Kurt lifts his head to come up for air. He's smiling as he looks down at his boyfriend.
Sebastian's smile is perfect, but Kurt can tell there's something on his lover's mind. "Kurt, I can't stay. I just wanted us to have a proper goodbye."
Kurt starts to cry, but he tries his best to stay strong. "I don't want you to go. Please, just stay here with me. I love you."
Sebastian's smile widens as he runs his fingers down Kurt's cheek. "I love you too, but I'm dead and you're alive." Kurt's eyes go to the floor, but Sebastian makes him look him in the eyes again. "And you're going to keep on living. You're going to get married, adopt, or get a surrogate and have kids. You're going to be happy, because no matter what I'm going to be with you." A tear falls from Kurt's cheek and lands on his boyfriend's cheek.
Sebastian wipes Kurt's eyes and kisses him. "Now, close your eyes and just kiss me."
Kurt does as Sebastian says and their lips meet. Kurt pulls away. "I love you." Sebastian whispers. "I need you to do one more thing. You need to help remind Sam why he and Finn are forever."
Kurt opens his eyes. He's under the covers and everything he'd just experienced was nothing more than a dream. Tears stained his face. "I love you too." Kurt says talking to Sebastian. "I love you both, and I'll keep my promise."
Kurt gets out of bed and goes into the living room. He turns on Finn's laptop. A picture of Finn and Sam holding each other is the background. Kurt clicks on the videos link and finds one that he knows will force something in Sam to awaken.
…
Sam is walking down the hallway headed for the last Glee rehearsal before they head to Nationals in San Francisco. He heard someone calling out his name. He turns and sees Finn running towards him. "Finn, what's up?"
Finn stops just a foot away from Sam. They haven't seen each other in over a week and he hates that he has to force himself to not kiss his boyfriend. "Uh, Kurt…He told me you were having some issues with your ring. I thought maybe I could help."
He takes Sam's hand. Sam feels confused and his heart starts with race inside his chest. Just the touch of Finn's hand on his has Sam's skin tingling. "OK, but I …I don't know how you'll be able to help me get it off."
Finn smiles, "I know because I have a feeling I'm the only one who can take it off." He flashes his ring at Sam. "I'm having the same problem as you."
"Oh, I …didn't know" Sam says as he feels Finn's finger's wrap around the ring.
"Just relax, close your eyes and take a deep breath." Finn slides the ring off of Sam's finger slowly. Sam opens his eyes and can't believe the sight of his naked hand.
"How were you…" Sam is interrupted by Finn.
"We promised each other the only person that would ever be able to take off our rings would be each other." Finn smiles and Sam can't describe the feeling overtaking him. "You're free now." Finn gives him one last smile.
Finn starts to walk away. "Wait." Sam says to Finn. Finn turns around. "Don't you want me to take off your ring for you?"
Finn shakes his head no. "No thanks, I'm not ready to give up hope just yet. I just don't want you to feel pressured to love someone you barely remember." Finn turns and walks off while Sam heads for the choir room.
Finn gets inside his car. He slams his fists into the outer ring of the steering wheel. He cries and slams his head into the headrest. "Please come back to me Sam. I need you more than you know."
Sam is a few feet from the choir room when his phone buzzes. He checks it. A new video text from Kurt arrives. He opens it.