AN: Hey guys!! I am definitely blown away by the number of reviews I got for my first chapter!! Thank you so much, I love you guys. Now, because you all were so amazing, I present you with the second chapter….

Disclaimer: Unfortunately, I do not own Nathan, or any other thing associated with One Tree Hill. I only own the story idea.

CHAPTER 2 – Truth or Dare?

"Do you guys want to play Truth or Dare now?" Brooke asked hopefully.

"I don't know Tigger," Haley cried.

"Please Tutor Girl," Brooke begged. "What about you guys? Don't you want to play Truth or Dare?"

"Sure, we'll play Brooke," Nathan said kindly. "Please play with us Haley,"

"Fine, what the hell, I'll play," Haley said, unexcited, but pleased that Nathan had personally asked her to play. "But can we clean up the kitchen first, the mess is distracting me."

They had all finished eating macaroni and cheese for dinner, made by Brooke, after Lucas finished getting her finger all bandaged up.

"How about we let the boys tidy up the kitchen, while you come help me fix my band-aid Haley?" Brooke asked while discreetly winking at Haley.

"Sure, we would love to Brooke," Lucas said smiling.

"Thanks boys. Haley let's go." Brooke said while grabbing Haley's arm and pulling her out into the bathroom.

"Please, please let go Brooke. You're going to leave a bruise on my arm."

"Sorry Tutor Girl, but I am so excited."

"For what Brooke?"

"Truth or Dare, duh." Brooke said as if it was obvious.

"What's so exciting?"

"Goodness Haley for a tutor, you are really slow sometimes."

"Hey! Don't make fun of me."

"Listen up. You clearly like Nathan, so I was thinking I could…"

"Wait. Why do you think I like Nathan?"

"Hmm…maybe because you were practically gawking over him all through dinner."

"Oh my gosh, no I wasn't! Fine, fine, maybe I looked at him once."

"Once? Hales you stared at him the whole meal!!"

"Whatever Brooke get on to what you were saying."

"Thank you. I was thinking of daring Nathan to kiss you."

"What? No. I don't think so."

"Why not?"

"One, I just met him, and two, how do you know he wants to kiss me."

"Please Hales, you two were like flirting with your eyes the second he walked in."

"So you really think he likes me?"

"Yes Tutor Girl I really think he likes you."

"Fine, I guess you could dare him to kiss me."

"Oh goody!"

"What about you and Lucas? He seemed to be holding your hand pretty tightly when I walked in."

"Nothing is really going on between us. I mean he is definitely cute, and I guess I like him, but he would never go for me."

"And why is that?"

"He's seems like the smart type. He would never go for the cheer slut."

"First of all, you're not a slut Brooke. Second of all, you have an amazing heart, he would be stupid not to give you a chance."

"Thanks Tutor Girl, you always make me feel better."

"What are best friends for?"

"Okay now that we are done, let's go back to the boys. They're probably getting suspicious since we've been gone so long."

"Do you know where the dishes go?" Nathan asked, rather confused.

"No way, I just said we would clean the kitchen, since Brooke made dinner, and I made her cut her finger."

"Don't forget the fact that you like her."

"What are you talking about?"

"Please Luke. Don't deny that you like her. You were flirting with her since we got here. Holding her hand, helping her finish grating the cheese, and smiling at her every chance you get. It's like your in love."

"Fine so maybe I like her. What about you and Haley?"

"What about us?"

"Don't act like you don't know what I'm talking about. You smirking at her, and sitting next to her at dinner, making her blush. I can tell when you like someone Nate, I've known you forever."

"Okay so I like her. You never know what can happen. Now let's put up these dishes so it looks like we actually did something."

The boys finished cleaning the kitchen just as Brooke and Haley walked out of the bathroom.

"Why don't we play in the living room boys? It will be more comfortable." Brooke asked.

"Sure," Nathan responded. "Fine by me."

They all settled next to each other on the couch. Nathan next to Haley, and Brooke next to Lucas.

"Okay, who would like to start?"

"I will Brooke," Lucas said.

"Hmm…Haley, truth or dare?"

"Truth."

"Do you have a boyfriend?"

"No."

"Do you like anyone?"

"Sorry Lucas, but you only get one question. Brooke it's your turn. Truth or Dare?"

"Dare."

"I dare you to show everyone your tattoo."

"Fine." Brooke pulled up her shirt revealing a Chinese symbol tattooed on her lower back. "It means long life. I got it two years ago with my ex-boyfriend. Okay, Nathan you're next. It's time to spice this game up. Truth or dare?"

"Dare."

"I dare you to kiss Haley, anywhere you want."

"I accept." Nathan kissed Haley's neck softly and whispered in her ear, "I will be happy to continue this later."

Once again, Haley just blushed and smiled at Nathan. God that boy had soft lips. Was he trying to kill me? He is just so tempting. I'm not used to having these feeling about a guy before.

"Lucas," Nathan continued. "I dare you to throw Brooke into the pool."

"We have a pool?" Haley asked.

"Lucas, you don't have to do this. Don't listen to Nathan," Brooke cried.

"It's okay Brooke, I don't mind." With that, Lucas quickly picked Brooke up and carried her to the pool.

"No Lucas, please don't!" Brooke screamed.

"Sorry Pretty Girl, a dare's a dare." Lucas said, while throwing himself and Brooke into the cold pool. Nathan and Haley were now running up to the pool side, hysterically laughing at Brooke's reaction.

"LUCAS SCOTT!! I CANNOT BELIEVE YOU JUST DID THAT!!" Brooke yelled.

"Oh my gosh, that was so funny," Haley said to Nathan, still chuckling.

"You know what would be funnier?" Nathan asked, smirking.

"What?" Haley asked suddenly intrigued.

"This." Nathan stated before picking Haley up and tossing them both in the pool as well.

"NATHAN SCOTT!! YOU ARE SUCH A JERK!" Haley screamed, wiping water out of her eyes.

"It's okay Hales," Nathan joked. "You look good wet."

"I am so going to hurt you." Haley exclaimed, while dunking Nathan under water.

The four ended up spending the whole rest of the night in the pool, having a huge water battle and playing "Chicken Fight". When they finally got out of the water, their fingers were all shriveled up.

"Goodness, that was so much fun," Brooke stated, climbing out of the pool.

"I know, I haven't laughed that much in a long time." Lucas said.

"Well I'm going to bed. Night boys, night Tigger." Haley said.

"Night Tutor Girl, night Luke, Nathan. See you guys tomorrow." Brooke said while she followed Haley up the stairs.

"Night girls." Nathan and Lucas replied.

As they all drifted off to sleep, they couldn't stop thinking about how much fun they just had, and about how much fun they were going to have over the summer to come.

AN: Thanks for reading you guys!! I love hearing your input, whether positive or negative. Please REVIEW!! REIVEW!! REVIEW!!