Rachel hit Charlie playfully and Charlie continued laughing softly. Charlie stared at Rachel's lips, they were so pink and, glossy. Rachel watched Charlie's eyes as in glimmered in the light from the movie screen. Charlie slowly leaned in and captured Rachel's lips with hers. Rachel slowly kissed back and placed her hand on Charlie's cheek. The rebel placed her hand on Rachel's bare thigh. She slid her hand up Rachel's thigh slowly.
"Charlotte," Rachel whispered as she pulled away slightly,
Charlie slowly slid her hand to Rachel's inner thigh. Rachel laughed lightly and took Charlie's hand gently. She shook her head a little as she smiled. Charlie stared at the brunette's lips. She whispered an apology and went back to kissing her.
Charlie walked Rachel to the front door of the Berry household.
"So,"
"So," Rachel repeated.
Charlie smiled and kissed the corner of Rachel's mouth softly, "I had a good time,"
Rachel smiled and brushed her hand against Charlie's cheek, "me too, Charlotte. I'll see you tomorrow,"
Charlie just nodded and watched Rachel step into the house. She sighed, smiling to herself as she walked back to her motorcycle. She just couldn't keep Rachel Berry and her lips off her mind.
A week later and the four girls still had their minds set on getting Rachel Berry. In the past seven days, Rachel spent an equal amount of time with each one of these girls. Santana showered Rachel with gifts while Maria tried using her knowledge of books, music and movies to win Rachel over. While Quinn on the other hand had a lot in common with the short, loud brunette and Charlie was one of the sweetest girls Rachel has ever known.
Another week passed, Rachel went on that date with Santana. It was Santana's first date ever where she didn't get to second base. Rachel didn't even let the Latina get to first base. And yet Santana still couldn't shake the feeling there was something familiar in Rachel and still stuck around to try and find out what was making her stay. She kept wondering til that Saturday night. The big fight.
Charlie dropped her cigarette on the Lopez porch and put it out with her boot. Quinn rang the doorbell again, her lips in a straight line. Charlie crossed her arms and watched as the door open. Santana was surprised to see the Fabray twins on her front porch.
"Well well well, I knew this day would come," the Latina smirked. "You girls wanna have a threesome with Snix," Santana smiled and nodded, "I'm totally up for it,"
Quinn scoffed and pushed through Santana to get inside the house. Maria turned her head and stood when she saw the blonde walk towards her.
"Hi, um, Quinn," Maria saw Charlie walking through the front door after Quinn and crossed her arms, "Charlie? What are you both doing here?"
"We need to talk," Quinn spoke.
Santana closed the door and walked over to the three girls, "what about, Fabray?"
"About Rachel,"
The four of them stood in silence for a minute or two before Maria replied with, "what about Rachel?"
"Cut the crap. All of you," Quinn looked around at the three girls, "we all know that all of us know that we all like her,"
Santana frowned in confusion while Maria watched Charlie run her fingers through her pink hair. Charlie looked back at Maria and turned away when Quinn continued to talk.
"Well this needs to stop. You guys need to leave Rachel alone so she can be with me,"
The elder Lopez laughed and patted Quinn's back, "I didn't know you had a backbone, Fabray. But no," Santana's laugh faded into a serious facial expression, "it's obvious Rachel's into me the most. I mean, between you, me and little flamingo in the corner over there, there's no question. So, I think you, need to back off just a little bit, Fabray,"
"Fuck off, Santana. You lied to her about taking her home,"
Santana let out a snort, "you did too, hypocrite,"
Quinn stared at Santana.
"Yeah, if you think you're so perfect for Rachel, why did you lie to her?" Santana smiled as Quinn kept her mouth shut, "I thought so,"
"Well I was the one who took her home that night," were the first words that came out of Charlie's mouth that night, "so does this mean all of you can back off so I can have her for myself now?"
Maria laughed and shook her head, "you girls are pathetic,"
"No, Maria, I think what's pathetic is putting up this stupid charade of you being so God damn innocent," Charlie laughed, "did you think people would forget about those crazy nights you had with-"
"Hey, leave Maria alone, alright?" Santana stood infront of Charlie,
"What about Rachel then? Are we all gonna keep fighting for her like a bunch of barbarians?"
"Well let's let Rachel decide, alright? Does that seem fair? It's me against you and Quinn. Rachel will choose. And she's smart, so, she'll obviously choose me anyway,"
"What about Maria?" Quinn pointed,
"Maria isn't involved in this,"
"Well what if I am?" Maria blurted out, making Santana turn to face her twin,
"Maria, you don't wanna get into this, it-"
"It's what? Dangerous? Unhealthy? What bullshit are you going to give me this time, Sanny? I'm so fucking tired of this, of you treating me like a kid,"
Charlie and Quinn froze, watching the scene unravel infront of them. Charlie recognized that look in Maria's face and grabbed Quinn's hand. She turned to her twin and nodded at the door. Quinn saw the look in Charlie's eyes and nodded before pulling her hand away slowly. The Fabray twins left the Lopez house and was silent in the car as they drove home.
"And you know what else I'm tired of, Santana? I'm tired of watching you get with every girl you want and then treating them like shit when you start to get bored. And I'm not even sorry for those slushies I ordered for you and Quinn," Maria rubbed her forehead.
"What?" Santana looked at her sister with disbelief, "what the fuck, Maria?"
"Yeah," Maria laughed sarcastically, "I ordered those slushies, Santana. And also, I'm not sorry for caring about Rachel, and I want her just as much as you all do," she took one step closer to Santana, "you are only one minute older than me, Santana, I am not seven fucking years old, I'm so tired of being in your fucking shadow,"
Santana stared at her twin and shook her head a little, "I don't get it, Maria, what, why would you-"
"You already took Katherine from me," Maria glared at her twin while Santana felt a lump form in her throat.
"I fucking knew it," Santana pointed her finger against Maria's chest, "you did have feelings for her. I fucking knew it," Santana shook her head, trying to hold back her tears, "well she was mine, Maria, she was the only girl I ever cared about and you know that,"
"You're a fucking liar!" Maria yelled, her cheeks already wet with tears, "I was the one who introduced her to you, she was my best friend. You just couldn't fucking wait to shove your tongue down her throat the second she showed any interest in you. You ruined what I had with her,"
"God fucking damn it, Maria, she loved me too, Katerina loved me, I know she did!"
"So why'd you let her leave? Why did you cheat on her?"
Santana clenched her fists and banged one of them against the table, knocking a few picture frames onto the ground, "what the fuck is wrong with you, Maria? Where is all this coming from?" the tears streamed down the Latina's face.
"Why'd you let her leave, Santana?" Maria yelled.
"She killed herself, Maria!" Santana yelled back, stepping back, waving her arms in the air, "what the fuck do you want me to do? Build a fucking time machine for you? She left, because she wanted to, and not because I made her,"
"And you cheated on her anyway," Maria's tears started to blur her vision.
"I regret that everyday, Maria, there is not a day that goes by that I don't regret that night with Brittany. I miss Katherine, so much, Maria, so much, my heart aches, every single day knowing she's never going to come back to me, ever," Santana's lower lip trembled.
Maria wiped her tears away with her sleeve, "why'd you have to lie to her about me? Why'd you have to lie to Charlie about me, huh? I know it was you, San, who made up that rumor about me fucking Mia. You purposely made Kat and Charlie hate me just because I was closer to Katherine than you were,"
"I know you loved her, Maria, but she was mine,"
"Your dumb apologies can't make her come back, Santana, it was your fault and you know it. And with that said, I'm not gonna let you take Rachel away from me like you did Katerina," Maria laughed lightly, "not again,"
"I care about Rachel too, Maria, and I'm not going to give her up just because of this stupid fantasy you had about Katherine," Santana wiped her tears away with the back of her hand,
Maria and Santana stood and stared at eachother.
"Well too bad," Maria said before grabbing her keys and walking out the front door.
Sorry if this sucks. I love you guys anyway.