Elena P.O.V
From the moment that Star woke up everything changed, Damon looked at me differently and when my confession came out about what I did to Star, the look of disappointed from both of their faces killed me. When I looked at Star all I saw was hatred towards her everything had changed since she came into town. All Damon had done a totally turn around her always put her first, then there was Stefan look at her with so much love in his eyes he used to look at me in that way. That all changed once Rebekah forced me to tell him about my feeling for Damon. The look in his eyes of hurt, but then when Rebekah made him tell her what else he was hiding it came out that Star was his first love. Which left me lost for words as I never expected for that to come out of his mouth, him and Star?
A fight broke out between Star, and all I wanted to do is tear her apart I had enough of her. When we both began to fight I notice that she was pretty strong. In that moment in time I didn't care that she may hurt me, all I thought about was ripping Star heart out. I wanted her out of my life I wanted her out of the Salvatore's life too, I wanted her the hell out of Mystic Falls. Well Star went all loopy loo and Damon warn me that I messed with the wrong girl, apparently she had woken up a little different, with her not technically being human and all. I went home that night and all I felt was anger I wanted to go and hunt her down, and put a stake her through her heart. If I went out and did that Damon will hate me forever along with Stefan, and I couldn't deal with the thought of them hating me.
So to calm myself down I went up to my room and took a long hot soak in the bath hoping it would somehow take all my troubles away, and it did work for a while I just let everything slip away. I got changed into my PJ and climb into bed I laid back looked at the celling, part of wished I never did what I did back on the island, because right now I'm in a screwed up situation. I got woken up to my phone ringing, I fumbled about on my night stand, and got my phone I looked at the screen and saw it was Stefan calling, I answered the phone.
"Hello…" I moved the phone away and looked at the time it was 6am, why would Stefan be ringing me at this time?
"Elena... I'm call to say that you need to stay away from the house for a while." Stefan spoke with seriousness in his voice, I sat up straight in the bed surprised from what I heard. What did he mean by that?
"What? No Stefan, I'm not staying away because Star got a hissy fit." I practically shouted down the phone, no way Star going to win at this, I'm sick of her getting in between us.
"Elena, I'm telling you this for your safety." What the hell did he mean by that?
"If you think I'm scared of Star you—" He cut me off abruptly
"Elena you need to listen me. Last night we found Star and she mascaraed a dozen people, she completed transition, and in the processes she turned off her humanity." I didn't know what to say I literally felt speechless. "She got every emotion off right now, she's not thinking clearly. I'm worried that if she see you she might do something to you, and I wouldn't be able to live with myself." He spoke with concern in his voice, even after everything I did to him Stefan still had my back.
So I made a promise to Stefan for a few days I would lay low, and keep out of Star way I didn't even go into school, of course Caroline kept me updated with what was going on. Apparently Star had turned into a right bitch, she was miss behaving not following the rules that were set by Damon and Stefan. Even Klaus was trying to get involved, I didn't get how she had each and every one of them wrapped around her finger. Well there no point in me stressing over the psycho Star, all I need to do is keep low for a few days until they have her under some form of control. Friday night came and everyone was far too busy, Caroline was called by Stefan so she disappeared, then Bonnie be MIA for a while now, she's not been the same since we got back from the island. Jeremy and Matt were both working down at the grill, even if I wanted to go down there I couldn't because the psycho was on the loose. The only place that was safe for me right now was my own home, where Star couldn't come in. So I was stuck here for the night I put a movie and sat on the couch, after a while watching the movie I could hear a noise. I got up from the couch and began to look round, but the noise wasn't coming from inside the house, but outside. I made my way out onto the porch and I saw the swing chair rocking, I looked around there wasn't a breeze I was about to walk back into the house when I felt sharp pain in my neck and I blacked out.
I came around and my neck and head were killing me I tried to move but my arms and legs, but I couldn't move them. I opened my eyes and looked around the room I was in, it looked familiar I looked at my hands and they were chained up to some device. What the hell going on here?
"Help! Help!" I could hear footsteps coming toward the room I was in, the old wooden door opened and there stood Star with a smirk on her face.
"You can scream all you want, no one going to hear you." She walked over to one side of the room where there was a table filled with all different types of tools. Star stood there admiring them for a moment and turned to me with a smile. "Are you comfortable?" She asked while approaching me, she clearly still had her humanity off and now she making me pay for doing this to her.
"Look, I know you hate me—" Star began to laugh evilly, she had really had lost it.
"You and I are going to have so much fun." She put a gag around my mouth, I couldn't even fight her off me if I wanted to being chained up like this. "I have a headache, so try and keep the scream to a minimum." What the hell was she on about? She pulled something out of her pocket then turned to me, she held her hand her phone. "Why don't we give Damon a little call?" She did something on her phone and placed it facing me on the table, I could see Damon face on the screen "Say hello to Damon, Elena." Star teased, I started to scream as I saw her holding a stake in her hand and twirling it around. "Come on Elena tell the boys how much you need saving." Star taunted again.
"Star, let Elena go." Damon demanded, but Star had well and truly lost it, I'm hoping Damon could get through to her, Star came in view of the camera holding a stake in her hand
"Why would I let her go Damon?" She stabbed the stake in my arm, from the pain of the impacted I let out a scream, I knew that now she had me here she will torture me after what happened on the island. "You see Damon, I thought you didn't love Elena anymore." All I could see was Damon looking torn about all of this, I didn't know if it was about me, or the fact that his psycho friend had gone off the rails.
"Star this isn't you, your better than this." Stefan pleaded to her, I looked over at Star and she seemed amused by all of this, she wanted them to witness her torturing me, possibly killing me.
"Star please. Let's just talk about this. I know that your emotions are doing this to you." I glanced over at Star and she began to chuckle, I began pull at the ropes but they kept burning me she had obviously soaked them in vervain I could feel it sneering into my skin.
"My emotion? Damon I don't have any, I don't feel a thing." She pulls the stake out of my arm. "You see I'm the way I'm, because of two people... the two bitches you both fell in love with." She stakes me in the stomach, I couldn't hold my scream in. "Aww Elena did that hurt." I felt tears pouring down my cheeks, as she had angle the stake so it was scraping against my heart.
"Star just let's talk, please. You're gonna regret doing it." I think it was pass all that, Star brought me here for one reason only and that was to punish me for what I did to her.
"You wanna talk, well I don't." She walked over to the other end of the room, I looked up and I saw her come back with a bucket. "Elena and I are having fun, and talking boring. I rather do this." She throws the water in the bucket over me, it was vervain water as soon as it touched my skin burnt every inch of my body. I felt it seeping into my skin I felt like I was literally on fire, I screamed so loud I felt like I fading out. If Star wanted to kill me, I just wanted her to get it over and done with.
"Star!" Damon screamed down the, they were not going to find me in time, Star was going to end me tonight I could see by the look in her eyes. "Star! Please! I know that you don't want to talk, but we need to. This isn't you." She turned to the camera and her face was filled with amusement.
"Sorry Damon, but I'm having too much fun here. I have torturing to do, bye." She smiled sweetly and hung up on him. I slowly raised my head to see her walking over to the table and picked something up, she turned around and held a power drill in one hand and hammer. She walked over to me with a grin on her face she moved the gag from my mouth.
"Star I'm sorry for—" She began to laugh loudly, I had to try and get through to her somehow beg plead whatever I had to do to get out of here alive. "Star this isn't you, your humanity off that why your behaving like this—" I was cut off by her punching me face my head jerked back, I felt blood trickling from my nose.
"What the hell do you know about me Elena you know nothing about me?" She raised the hammer and the power drill. "So Elena make a choice." She totally nuts? I wasn't going to choose "You know what, I think we should try all my toys out on you." I could feel my heart racing as she got the drill and tuned it on, putting it near my throat. I felt the point ripping through my flesh I couldn't even scream I watched as Star stood in front of me totally amused with the torture she was giving me.
Damon POV
I had witness the most disturbing thing ever, not the fact that I watched someone getting tortured, but that fact it was Elena, and the one doing the touching was Star. Star wasn't the type to do something like that she didn't have a bad bone in her body, but with her switching it all off she had turned into the one thing I never expected from her, a totally heartless person, actually a monster. I mean I'm no angel I've done some questionable things in my past, but I had my reason, Star was pure of heart she not one to murder, or to hurt anyone. With her turning into a vampire had changed her. She switched it all off because of the massacre she did, I still remember the look upon her face when she looked around at what she did. I watched my best friend turn off her humanity I saw in her eyes the life taken out her. I watched the one girl who I considered as family even a sister turn into something which I never wanted for her, no matter how selfish I can be at times I could never wish this life of vampirism on her that not what she is about.
The girl we all cared and love was gone, and somehow between Stefan and I need to bring her back, and in the processes save Elena before Star will do something she will truly regret. Now she may not care about anything, but she's not thinking rationally. Once that switch is flipped back on, it going to destroy her so somehow we need to find her and stop her.
"Damon." Stefan snapped me out of my thoughts. "What the hell are we going to do?" That was a great question, and I didn't have the answer to that.
"I don't know Stefan, I don't even have a clue where to start. Do you?" Stefan looked as frustrated as I did, I mean we both were concerned about both girls, the way Star is at the moment I think she actually capable to kill Elena.
"I we need to think of where Star would have taken Elena, how many locations could she of taken her?" Well that could be anywhere right now, and we really didn't have time on our hands I don't know how long Star planning on playing with Elena, but I think we didn't have a lot of time "We can do a location spell, all we need is some of Jeremy blood, and we find where she holding Elena." Yeah that sounded like a pretty good idea, but the only witch we were on good terms with is MIA.
"Great idea Bro, but we have no witch to hand right now, we don't have a clue where Bonnie is." I was frustrated the more time we wasted the more we were going to lose the two girls we cared about.
"Ok but we know one person who willing to help, and probably has a witch up his sleeve." I turned to Stefan who the hell was he talking about? "Klaus wants to save Star as much as we do." Stefan had a point I mean Klaus was full on in love with Star.
"Ok then you go and get blood donation from baby Gilbert, while I got and explain to Klaus how Star totally gone off the edge." Before I could say anything else Stefan was gone, it looked like I had to deal with Klaus. I walked over to my car and got in I looked back at the house it was still filled with teens I was in two mind about clearing out the house, but this was far more important. I started up the car and drove to Klaus mansion I got out of my car, and walked to the front door any normal person would knock but I've got no time for formality. I walked in and made my way to the parlour and I saw Klaus sitting by the fire with a bottle of scotch in his hand.
"What do I own the pleasure?" He kind of slurred his words, was Klaus drunk? I've never actually seen him drunk, as I approached him he had six empty bottle of bourbon by his feet.
"Great the one time I need your help, and you're drunk. Wonderful!" I grabbed the bottle from his hand and took a swig from it, I needed this after everything that just happened.
"Well I'm not in the mood to help right now. The woman I love has turn off her humanity, the one thing that kept her together." He spoke slurring once again, I never thought of Klaus being one to give up I mean his always vengeful and always been persistent in getting what he wants.
"Well Hydick, I need you to help me with Star." The moment he heard Star's name he got up abruptly, and gained his composure. He really did look a mess.
"Where is she? Has something happened to her? Don't just stand there TELL ME!" I took a step back for the first time ever seen Klaus behave like this.
"Look she's out of control, she got Elena chained up and torturing the crap out of her." Klaus began to laugh as he walked over to his collection of scotch. "What so funny?" He looked up still looking amused.
"She torturing the girl who fed her vampire blood, and let her becoming the one thing she never wanted to be." He drained his drink. He had a point, but that wasn't the case here, the reason behind all this is what it's actually going to do to Star once it's all back on.
"Yeah the girl you want to cure to make your hybrids remember." He glared at me I think I definitely touched a nerve there, he began to approach me with a dangerous look in his eyes.
"You think I give a dam about Elena Gilbert!" He screamed. "I'm happy to hear that Star torturing her, she deserve every ounce of pain that Star inflict on her. I'm sure that Katherine next on her hit list." Klaus actually sounded kind of proud of Star and no way in hell I'm going to let Star turn into a heartless murder.
"You listen here dick. If you care about Star as much as you say you do, you will help us stop her doing something she'll later regret when she dose finally turn that switch back on." He stood there and looked at me clenching his jaw displeased with me putting him in his place. "Now we need a witch, do you think you can summon one up?" I didn't want to turn to Klaus, but right now he our only hope, we need to find Star and somehow reason with her. I don't want to go to the extreme of locking her up but right now she really not giving me any choice.
Klaus P.O.V
From the very moment when Star walked in on Hayley and I after our rendezvous the look upon her face still haunt me, how could I of down that to her Star meant more to me than anything in this world. I slept with another woman not even after 24 of knowing that she had died, just so I could forget the pain of losing her, the whole purpose of having Hayley here was to get closer to Katherine and kill her with my bear hands. I have really messed everything up, she'll never forgive me for that. Not long after I received the phone call from the brothers informing me that Star had vampire blood in her system, now she planning not to complete transition we went to find her. We found Star in the middle of the cemetery with dozen dead bodies around her, she looked horrified each of us tried talking to her, but it didn't work. Star did the one thing that I never expected from her and that was that she turned off her humanity.
From that very moment girl I knew was gone she had turned into something in my worst nightmare, looking the face of angle but spoke with venom like a snake each word that came out of her mouth cut me like a knife. How much she hated the fact that she was in love with me for 520 year that she wasted her whole existence pining over me. I couldn't be around her anymore, no matter how much I wanted to help bring her back I couldn't, in reality she was right I didn't deserve her. I was no good for her whatsoever, so I chose to stay away from her and the brothers. I'm not a man that can be broken easily nothing or none has ever broken me. This one woman had broken me she had tear at each and every layer that I have put up in the last thousand. This feeling I had of vulnerability to feel hurt to feel emotional pain I've never had this for centuries, and I dealt with it all the only way I knew how to and that was with my good old friend scotch.
I spent most of the day consuming the finest scotch I had in the house to numb the pain I was feeling, I didn't want to think about what was actually happening in the outside world. That my wife had turned into a malicious heartless 'monster' that wasn't the woman who I loved. Well my day got spoil by the arrogant Salvatore coming over to tell me that Star had taken Elena and torturing her, for a moment I was impressed. I didn't think Star would have it in her to do something like that. Elena and Katherine are the reason why she in this situation, even though selfishly I'm happy she not dead but doppelgängers are going to paying for this. Well that what I thought until Damon reminded me that when Star dose eventually switch on her emotion she will be flooded with every wrong thing she had done, that not a fate that I want her to go through. I wouldn't be able to bear seeing my Star in that amount of pain.
Damon wanted me to get hold of a witch so we could perform a location spell to find Elena that would mean we would find Star, did he think I could pull a witch out of my pocket. I asked why the Bennett weren't available, Damon gave me some cock and bull story about not knowing where she was so I called Angelic. She been a trusty witch for many decades, and I knew she would be here extremely quick. Well the other brother turned up with a vial of blood donation from little Gilbert no long after Angelic arrived, she was more than happy to help. Angelic had longing lust after me for a long time, and of course she would do anything to please me. She laid out the map of Mystic Falls and Stefan handed her the vial of blood, she began to perform the spell while we watched.
"So is your witchy friend going to find her, what the plan with Star?" Damon questioned well that was a good one, Star was strong it will take two of us to take her down.
"I suggest that Stefan play the part of the hero saving Elena, and between you and I, we bring Star down." Damon looked at me arching his brow, I knew that Star had incredible strength but between both of us we could take her down, I turned to Angelic "How is the search going sweetheart?" I approached her from behind, and I watched the blood droplets form into one and moving across the map then it stopped.
"Well boys your girl in Mystic Falls." Angelic announce, good job Star didn't take the doppelgänger too far then, I looked down at the map and I couldn't help but chuckle.
"What so funny Klaus?" Damon seemed unamused I looked at him.
"She has dear sweet Elena appears to be at the old Forbes Jail." Stefan was about to leave and I stopped him. "You think going in there without a plan a good idea Stefan, the Star we all knew not there, this version of her is cunning and she will stop at nothing to taken each, and every one of us down. We need to device a sufficient plan." We couldn't walk in there blind and I will not allow them to hurt Star, not that I think the brothers would actually hurt her. We needed to think of a way to weaken her, between the three of us I think we can come up with something.
Stefan P.O.V
Damon received a disturbing video call from Star she used the whole party as diversion to get to Elena, that what Star agenda all along to get to the one people who made her like this. I couldn't watch but I could hear everything the way Star was enjoying every moment of torture that she was giving Elena, while Elena screamed. I thought I had seen and heard many things in my life but this I never expected from her. Damon look tortured as he watched the girl we care about more than anything, torturing Elena the girl we both have loving feeling for. Damon came up with the idea that we needed to track them down, and the only way we could do that is by a tracking spell, as we had no clue where Bonnie was. Damon was going to ask for Klaus assistance while I went to ask Jeremy for donation. I arrived at the Gilbert house and knocked on the door the lights were on, I heard footsteps then door opened.
"Stefan." Jeremy looked at me a little stunned to see me, I don't know how to explain all of this to him but there weren't any easy way.
"Jeremy, its Elena I'm going to be needing some of your blood to find her." Jeremy stood trying processes what I told him. "Jeremy please." I walked in he turned to me.
"W-what and who got Elena?" The dreaded question I wanted to protect Star, but Jeremy had a right to know what going on.
"Star took her, and right as we speak she torturing her. Just please give me some blood so we can find her." Jeremy walked past me into the kitchen he rumbled around in the cupboard, I walked into the kitchen he place a jar on the counter. He cut his hand and let the blood pour into the glass jar.
"Here." He passed me the jar. "Stefan you better stop Star from doing anything stupid. I know what my sister did to her, but she don't deserve to die for it." Jeremy was right Elena did do wrong but to be killed over it weren't right.
"I will bring her home. I promise." Before Jeremy could say anything else I left and made my way to Klaus home. When I arrived Damon had spoken to Klaus and a witch was on the way she arrived shortly after me I had to admit she was impressive she found Elena pretty quick. I was ready to go but Klaus stopped me. He thought we need to think of a strategy that we couldn't just walk in there and attack and he was right neither of us wanted to attack Star. We need to make sure that Elena weren't hurt or even worse killed.
Third Person P.O.V
All three men left then mansion and made their way to the old Forbes jail, each of them took and entrance into the jail, prepare with a syringe filled with vervain to take Star down. As they walked through the empty hall ways they had a fear of possibly hurting the girl that they cared about, but they all knew that she had become out of control and this was the only way to save her.
Star had been torturing Elena for hours with all the different types of instrument that she could use to cause Elena pain, she felt some kind of revelation do this to Elena. The old version of her the one with a humanity would never dream of doing anything like this. Star began to embrace this new version of herself watching the girl who had a hand in turning into what she is today, screaming in pain. "Elena is it all getting too much for you?" She held the blow torch on Elena torso, the smell of burning flesh filling the room, she moved it away and watch Elena gasping for air.
Elena had never been through this kind of torment in her life, Star had been using every tool imaginable to hurt her, tear her skin away from her bones, burn her flesh Star favourite was the power drill she had use that to drill into Elena heart. Right now all Elena wanted was all of this to be over with. That Star would stake her or rip her heart out, so she wouldn't deal with all this pain. "Ju-just ki-kill me" Elena slurred while blood was pouring from her mouth; she wanted it all to end.
Star looked at Elena amused watching her pleading for her life to be over with. "Sweetie you think I'm going to make it that easy for you." She began to wag her finger in front of Elena. "Tut...Tut..." Star heard a noise from the distance, smirk appeared on her face she knew the boys would come and try and rescue poor sweet Elena. "Looks like you knights in shining armour are here." She picked up the wooden stake and pushed it into Elena chest, she let out a blood curling scream "If I was you... I'll say a pray." Star vanished out of the room before the brothers came.
Damon walked down the hall way and made his way towards the stairs which lead to the cells, he heard a noise and turned around and saw his brother. "Stefan" Damon growled at him, before they both continued to go down the stairs carefully, they heard Elena screams. The pair of them rush to where they the screams they both burst through the door, and saw Elena hanging looking broken her cloths covered in blood.
Stefan looked at Elena his heart sunk as he saw her all cut and bruised all over, she wasn't even healing quick enough due to the about of blood that had been drained from her. "Elena!" He spoke with fear as he approached, he raised her head and she could hardly keep her eyes open, between Damon and Stefan they got Elena down. "You're going to be ok." Stefan assured her while Elena cried into his chest.
Damon looked at the broken Elena she looked awful his friend Star had well and truly done a number on her, he looked around the room and it was filled with all different torture devices. He couldn't imagine what kind of pain Elena had been going through, and by the look of she didn't take it too well. "Bring Elena back to her house." He got up from the ground, all Damon wanted to do now is bring Star down he couldn't let her continue like this.
Star began to walk through the dark passage ways she knew she had to get out of here before the brother caught her, she also knew that they wouldn't come here without a plan of taking her down. She finally saw the door leading outside, she began to approach it when she was stopped by the man that she once loved Niklaus. "Oh you've come to spoil my fun." She teased while looked at him, she notice that his face was filled will all kind of emotions, she tried to get passed him but he grabbed hold of her arm.
Klaus stood there looking at the woman he loves looking back at him with no sign of any emotion not even hatred. "Star you need to come—" He felt a pain in his chest as he looked down he had a stake sticking out of my chest, but the time Klaus looked up Star was gone. In a Thousand years he had never come across anyone so ruthless, he knew that the Star he once knew maybe gone forever.
Star P.O.V
I made my way out of the Forbes jail I have to admit I haven't had that much fun in a long time, torturing Elena gave me a sense of being alive, that I had control of her miserable life in my hand. Her pleading for her life amused me, like I would actually stop, because she asked. How stupid and naïve she truly was. As expected the brothers came to her rescue, and I needed to get out of there as I knew the brother would have something to take me down, as they want me to turn my humanity back on. The brother are in for a very long wait. The one person I didn't expect to turn up was Niklaus, he had clearly proven that one night when I caught him and that wolf together that I meant nothing to him. So when I drove that stake into his heart I felt great sense of satisfaction. I knew with him being an original it wouldn't actually kill him, but it still gave me a kick to give him a few moments of pain.
Well after such a trying even of torture and getting away from the people who cared about me I needed a well-deserved drink, so I made my way to the local dive the grill. Of course it was closed but I made my own way in, walked over to the bar, I grabbed a bottle of bourbon and took a swig out of it. Then I walked over to the jukebox and put some music on. I grabbed hold of the bottle and began to dance, I heard the door open and I felt a present I slowly turned around.
"Aren't you a brave little thing?" Bonnie walked further into the gill not looking a little odd. "You're either dumb, or very stupid to come here," I warned her before taking a sip from the bottle.
"I'm here, because you're going to help me." I looked at her arching my brow, yeah like I was going to help her.
"Oh didn't you get the memo sweetie...I don't do help." I went to rush at her and suddenly I was pinned to the walk, I tried to move but I couldn't. "Ok, what with the witchy voodoo?" I demanded Bonnie began to approach me with a smile on her face.
"I need your help to complete the next part of the expression triangle." I couldn't help but laugh she thought I was going to help her, this witch was clearly out of her goddamn mind.
"You're out of your mind." I shouted to her she came closer to me.
"Unfortunately, you don't have a choice." I felt like a thousand needle were jabbing into my brain, I began to scream in pain the more I screamed the worse the pain got. I felt my eyes roll back I tried to keep my eyes open but I couldn't I fell into obelisk of darkness.