{ Bonnie }
As she made her way out to the car, Jenny offered to drive. Once they got in the car, Bonnie clicked the tape recorder on silently. Neither of them spoke for a while. She knew Gold and the others were listening back home, and she needed evidence. She decided she would attempt to strike up a conversation.
"So, Jenny," she started, turning towards her. The blonde did not reply for a while.
"Where are we going to eat?" she finally asked, snapping Bonnie out of her thoughts.
"Oh, uh... anywhere you want."
They drove in silence for a while. Bonnie was starting to get anxious.
Damn it, She's not insulting me...
The sun was slowly setting and Bonnie watched it, mesmorized by the golden glow. Soon the sun retreated behind the trees for the night. They were going some way that Bonnie wasn't familar with.
"Uh... Jenny? Where are we going?" Bonnie asked. She did not reply, but a small smile made itself present on her face.
"You'll find out."
Bonnie felt her pulse racing. She checked her pocket and made sure the tape recorder was on. It was.
The car slowed to a stop. Bonnie, who had been studying her nails, looked up. They were in a clearing, trees on all sides, besides a rocky path that they had come on. In front of them sat an abandoned church.
"An abandoned church?" Bonnie asked, trying to tell her friends where Jenny was taking her.
Jenny grinned. "Yeah! Trust me, come on!" She said in a cheery and excited voice. With that, she got out of the car.
Bonnie reluctantly got out of the car. Jenny walked towards the church, her hips swaying, twirling the car keys on one finger. Bonnie looked around. She had no idea where they were. This was not going to end well, she felt it all the way to her bones. The oncoming night just made things worse.
"Coming?" Jenny asked. She did not go into the church, but instead leaned against the wall.
Bonnie stopped a few feet away from her, not saying anything.
"Why have you taken me here?" She asked in a steady voice, forcing all her fear down to give her the same noncholant demeanor she always had.
Jenny scoffed. "I'm surprised you don't recognize me," she spat, her voice full of venom. She had ignored Bonnie's question and only made her more confused.
Bonnie arched one eyebrow. "Am I supposed to?" she asked warily.
A harsh laugh erupted from Jenny's mouth. "And I thought you were the smart one. You don't remember when Gabe attacked Sarah? I was the friend with her."
Bonnie's eyes widened. "No. Y-you can't be-" Everything came together in her head, all the separate puzzle pieces forming to create the entire picture. And what an ugly picture it was.
Jenny grinned, her face covered in creepy shadows. "You bet, Bon. It's me. The girl with so many pimples blind people read her face. Jennifer."
"How did I not realize..." Bonnie asked herself, slapping her forehead. "Same hair color, eye color, same name but just a shorter version - GAH! I'm such an idiot!"
"That's right, sweetie," Jenny growled, a twisted smile on he face. "You caused me so much pain in middle school."
"You caused me more in elementary!" Bonnie hissed, scrunching up her face in anger. This was her arch nemesis since second grade. Jennifer "Pizza Face" Fitzgerald. How had she not realized it was the same person? The only explanation was her lack of sleep and stress.
Jenny snarled like a wild animal. "You made my life a living hell. You and that Finn guy that's obsessed with pirates," she was nearly screaming now. Bonnie's heart was racing. "And now, I'm making your life a living hell. You broke up with your boyfriend. I kissed him and made you think he was cheating on you! Your best friend hates you. I sent those messages. You're all alone!" She laughed like a madwoman.
Bonnie knew it. Jenny had been sabotaging her life for the past few days. But she knew she wasn't alone. "That's what you think," she laughed, sticking her hand in her pocket. Realization hit her like a giant fist slammed itself into her stomach. Her phone was gone.
"Looking for your phone?" Jenny smiled, her eyes wide as saucers. She looked like a female, blonde Jeff the Killer.
Thinking about killers in the dark woods by an abandoned church with a psychopath nemisis on a rampage. Good going, Bon.
"You left it in the car," she finished, then pressed a button on her car keys. The door locked with a sharp beep that echoed through the clearing. Bonnie was trying to keep herself from panicking. This was definitely not going to end well.
Where was a pair of scissors when you needed them?
Jenny put the key in her pocket and cracked her knuckles. "Well, Bonnie," she said, her voice so overly sweet it made Bonnie shudder. "I don't think I've caused you enough pain yet. I think to be satisfied, I need to see you bloody and beaten at my feet, begging for mercy!" she broke out in mad laughter.
Before Bonnie could do anything, Jenny flew at her. The dark clearing exploded with light as Jenny punched her in the nose and tackled her to the ground. Warm blood gushed down her chin and into her mouth. Gagging, Bonnie brought her knees up to gain purchase, and kicked Jenny in the stomach, sending her flying off.
Bonnie jumped up, wiping her nose. She took self-defense classes years ago, but she doubted it would be much help. Her sharp bobby pin was also gone, so she had nothing to defend herself. Jenny picked herself up off the floor, panting. At least she didn't have a knife or anything sharp. "Oh," Jenny growled. "So you want to play the hard way?"
She grabbed Bonnie by the collar and shoved her into the wall of the church. Her head hit the wall and more light exploded on her vision.
Bonnie smacked Jenny across the face with her palm. The blonde cried out in pain and stumbled a bit. Bonnie kicked her in the side and she fell over.
Jenny hit the ground and rolled, standing right back up. Her cheek was an angry red and her green eyes flared with anger.
Bonnie ran at her and tackled her, showing her to the ground. She tried to hit the pressure point that would make her pass out, but Jenny rolled her over and ended up on top, screeching in fury. Jenny yanked at Bonnie's hair and Bonnie landed a few good punches to her face as they rolled around in the grass.
Jenny ended up with red claw marks on her face when Bonnie used her fingernails to tear open her soft cheek flesh, and Bonnie with two swollen and throbbing black eyes and a bleeding nose.
Eventually they broke apart and both stood. Bonnie wiped her nose and snarled. "You won't get away with this, Jenny."
A wide, maniacal smile broke out on her face. She stepped closer to Bonnie and caressed her fingers on her chin. "Dear Bonnie... I already have."
Jenny kicked her in the chest and shoved her to the ground. Bonnie felt the breath knocked out of her as she fell over, fighting to get her breath back. She landed on her side and gasped to fill her lungs with air. But it didn't end there. Laughing madly, Jenny started kicking Bonnie in the stomach. A crack was heard, but it was not a rib.
The tape recorder broke.
Coughing up blood, Bonnie curled into a ball as Jenny continued to kick her. Eventually she got tired and stopped. By then, Bonnie couldn't even lift one finger, let alone do anything to fight back. Her nose was swollen and her stomach, sides, all of the rest of her body was huring like hell. She let out a moan.
Jenny cackled. She wiped some of the blood from her face. Her right eye was slowly turning black from one of Bonnie's punches.
"By the time they find you, you'll be dead," she said as she swung the keys around on her finger. She sighed, shaking her head. "I'll miss my Mikey. He was so sweet. He put up with everything I did and said. I still have feelings for him. But after this, I don't think he'll want to be with me anymore."
With that, she started towards the car, laughing like she had just exchanged a pleasant joke with an old friend. "By the way, I knew about the tape recorder the whole time. That's why I decided to make my move. I mean I would have left tomorrow anyway so I had to do it at some point. I'll just leave early. And they'll never find me. I hope you don't mind, I'm stealing this car of yours. I'll be out of the country by morning."
Bonnie watched as Jenny got in the car. She revved the engine then turned and thundered down the road, her headlights fading out of sight.