Spin The What?

Hanna's POV

Autumns leaves fell down around me as I stared into my empty coffee cup. My hands and feet are shaking not just because it's chilly out. I'm shaking because I'm nervous about…

"Here you go," Caleb said while placing another coffee cup in front of me.

I smiled shyly as I brought the cup to my lips. I'm nervous because I'm hanging out with Caleb alone for the first time ever. We`ve talked at school, but with other people around. Today at school I asked Caleb if he wanted to get a cup of coffee, so I could tell him about my plan. He seemed intrigued when I told him the plan had something to do with Spencer and Toby. He also said he really wanted to spend time with me. That comment made me blush.

He scooted up in his chair. "So what's the plan you had in mind?"

I took another sip before answering. "Like I said it has something to do with Spencer and Toby. This idea could be really fun to watch."

He folded his arms on the table and leaned forward. "Okay, I'm listening."

"Tonight you're bringing Toby and Ezra along to my birthday party right?"

"Yeah of course."

"Good, Spencer will be there and I really want to see those two lip lock."

"By lip lock you mean kiss?"

I smiled and nodded "mhm tonight we're going to play spin the bottle. Odds are Spencer and Toby, are probably going to end up kissing each other."

"Hanna that idea is mean, cruel, evil, and the will hate us." Caleb grinned and said "and it's brilliant. Count me in."

Spencer's POV

I stood and looked at myself in the mirror. My hair was wavy and hung over my shoulders. Aria stood behind me to help me zip up my little black dress. Tonight is Hanna's 18th birthday party and I'm excited to go. Besides the fact that Hanna invited Toby, everything should be fine. If I avoid eye contact and do my best to avoid Toby then I'll be fine.

Aria finished zipping up my dress and patted my shoulders. "You look great Spence."

I sighed and said "thanks."

I walked past her and sat at the end of my bed to put on my heels. Aria leaned against the bed frame and crossed her arms. "You're dressing a little extra sexy tonight, how come?"

"I'm not dressing any different. I just wanted to look nice for Hanna's party."

"Spencer It's going to be you, me, Hanna, Emily, Toby, Caleb, and Ezra. You have no reason to dress up that nicely." She smirked "unless you're trying to impress Toby."

I scuffled and said "excuse me while I vomit."

"I don't know," She shrugged. "I could see you two being a couple."

"That is never going to happen."

Aria helped me put my necklace on when she saw I was having trouble. After I had that on, I stood up and took one last look at myself in the mirror. When I was satisfied with my appearance, Aria and I grabbed our purses and went to Hanna's party.

Emily was already at Hanna's when we got thee. She got there early to help Hanna set up. Hanna opened the door and invited us inside. Emily was standing in the kitchen with another woman. I've seen this woman before, but only a couple times. I didn't know she and Emily hung out. Emily smiled and turned around to greet us.

"Hey guys," she points at the girl next to her, "this is Maya."

Maya smile politely and shook all our hands. "It's nice to meet you all."

The doorbell rang again then Toby, Caleb, and Ezra walked in. Emily also introduced Maya to the boys. They did the same thing as we did and shook Maya's hand.

"Maya these are my friends…" Emily started, but Maya cut her off.

"Oh let me see if I got this." Maya said our names while pointing at us all out. "Aria, Caleb, Ezra, and the married couple Spencer and Toby."

I glared at Emily who was laughing her head off. "You made her do that didn't you?"

Emily smiled and shrugged "maybe."

"No thanks, I rather chew off my own toes," Toby said.

"Yeah well I rather jump into a pool of nails," I said.

Toby glared at me. "I really hate you."

"That's okay, I hate you too."

Maya laughed and shook her head "you guys are cuter than my parents."

"Okay, enough hate," Hanna chimed in. "Who's ready to play spin the bottle?"

"Spin the what!?" Toby and I both exclaimed.

We all sat around in Hanna's living room in a circle with a bottle in the middle. We are about to play spin the bottle and I'm really hoping I won't have to kiss Toby. Hating Toby isn't the only reason I don't want to kiss him, but what if we lose control again? If we kiss the way we did before, everyone will know that we've done this before.

"Before we play I'm going to explain the rules," Hanna exclaimed. "The first time the bottle lands on someone that you have to kiss, you only have to kiss once, if that same person picks you a second time then you make out for sixty seconds. The third time they have to French kiss. Does everyone understand?"

We all nodded.

"Okay," Hanna said. "I'll spin the bottle first."

She took the bottle in her hand and spun it clockwise around the carpet. The bottle slowed down to a stop right in front of Caleb. Hanna bit her lip and blushed as she stood up to meet Caleb in the middle. They closed their eyes, leaned forward and pecked each other's lips lightly. Hanna's face was a dark shade of red when they pulled away. She giggled quietly to herself and took her seat next to Emily.

"Your turn Emily," Hanna said while handing the bottle to her.

Emily took the bottle and spun it. The bottle slowed to a stop and landed on Maya. Emily blushed and stood up to meet Maya. They got to the middle and leaned in for the kiss. Maya's lips touched Emily's and lingered there for a few extra seconds. They pulled away and smiled at each other. Then Emily took her seat between me and Hanna.

Emily gave me the bottle. "Your turn Spencer."

I took the bottle and spun it around in a circle. The bottle slowed to the stop. My face whitened and my stomach twirled when I saw who it landed on. It landed on Toby. Toby's eyes widen as he gazed up at me. I swallowed hard and tried to think to every possible way I could get out of this.

"I want to skip my turn," I said.

"Nope it's too late now you have to kiss," Hanna said.

Caleb planted his hand on Toby's shoulder and said "come on man it's just a game, now go up there and plant one on her."

Toby and I eye each other before finally standing up and meeting in the middle. Toby's blue eyes gazed right into mine. I watched him gulp before leaning in. I squeezed my eyes shit waiting for it to be over. Then I felt his lips press against mine. The kiss was so quick I didn't even have time to respond. When I opened my eyes Toby, was already walking back to his spot. I turned around and took my seat between Emily and Aria.

I wanted to touch where Toby kissed me. Even though it was over I could still feel the light touch of his lips. I watched Toby from the corner of my eye and noticed him trying not to look at me. Before I knew what was happening, I heard everyone laughing. When I finally zoned back in and looked down, I noticed the bottle was pointing at me. I looked up at Toby and his face was whiter than a ghost.

That's when it hit me. Toby spun the bottle and it landed on me. Wait this would be our second time. Does that mean we have to make out?

Hanna laughed and said "alright you two over in the corner. I want to see some serious lip locking."

"Wait this is my first time landing on Spencer," Toby said.

"Yes, but Spencer already landed on you. This counts as your guys second kiss. Now get up and kiss."

Toby's POV

I glanced at Spencer as we rose to our feet. For a moment we just stood in there until Caleb urged us over to the corner. We met each other in the corner then turned to face each other. My breath got caught in my throat when her brown eyes gazed into mine. Those are the brown eyes I haven't been able to get out of my head for several days.

Spencer swallowed as I reached up with one hand to cup her face. My other hand went behind her head to pull her closer to me. Our eyelids fluttered closed as we leaned in closer and closer until our lips touched. Spencer held back for a second, but eventually I felt her lips starting to move against mine. Her arms came up to lock around my neck as we depend the kiss.

There was that feeling again. That feeling that I didn't want to stop. Just like the first time we kissed, her lips fit perfectly with mine and it feels right. Despite all of the hatred we have for each other, it feels right.

I wanted to slip my tongue into her mouth, but I had to remember that our friends are watching. Damn Caleb and Ezra probably already noticed that I'm enjoying this. I wasn't sure how Spencer felt about the kiss. I'm guessing she is enjoying it too since her fingers are getting tangled up in my hair. Finally Hanna told us that our sixty seconds is up. Spencer and I pulled away quickly to try and make it seem like we were happy to be apart, but in the inside I wanted to kiss her again.

We took our seats back on the carpet and watched as the others had their turn. Aria spun the bottle and it landed on Ezra. This would be their third time landing on each other, so they had to stand in the corner and French kiss. They seemed to be enjoying it since their both moaning and didn't want to pull away.

"Ew gross!" Hanna exclaimed. "Get a room!"

Aria pulled away from Ezra and smiled. "Which one?"

We all laughed as they walked back over to take their seats. It was Spencer's turn again and of course the bottle landed on me.

Caleb smirked and said "alright we get to see some more lip action between these two."

"By the way they were kissing before, just imagine how hot they'll be using tongue," Hanna added.

"I should get a picture," Aria said.

"Don't you dare!" Spencer yelled. "Guys can we please do something else. I am not kissing him again. I almost threw up in his mouth the last time."

My face turned red with anger. "I still need to disinfect my mouth."

Hanna rolled her eyes. "Okay fine, we'll watch a movie."

We all picked a spot on the couch or a chair and watched a movie that Hanna picked out. That's how we spent the remainder of the night. After the movie ended Ezra, Caleb, and I left, so Hanna could have some girl time with her friends. Ezra and I stood by the front door for a few minutes while Caleb gave Hanna a long kiss goodbye. Then we thanked Hanna for inviting us, and then left.

That's the end of this chapter. Spencer and Toby kissed more. Thanks for reading don't forget to review!