The response I've received from the first chapter has been great! Thank you, thank you, thank you to those of you who have faved and followed you rock!:) Also, thank you to the reviewers, I really appreciate your interest! This chapter is mostly a filler, but I hope you enjoy it just the same. I'm not sure when I'll get chapter 3 kicked off, but hopefully we'll see Bonnie meet some more of the Beacon Hills crew!

Disclaimer: All publicly recognizable characters, settings, etc. are the property of their respective owners. The original characters and plot are the property of the author. The author is in no way associated with the owners, creators, or producers of any media franchise. No copyright infringement is intended.

Previously:"Oh my gosh! I cannot believe I haven't introduced myself!" Grams was probably doing flips in her grave. She had raised her better than that. "I'm Bonnie." She stuck her hand out for him to shake.

"That's a beautiful name," Mystery boy said with a smile. "I'm Isaac."

He met her hand with his, and all of a sudden Bonnie was seeing a series of images that made her head spin. She quickly pulled her hand away, and tried to ignore the hurt look that crossed his face. She hadn't seen anything like that since Mason, and it made her a little nervous. Isaac was a werewolf, and he wasn't the only one in town.

"I'm sorry! You just gave me a bit of a shock." Bonnie let out a nervous laugh. She was feeling very uncomfortable all of a sudden.

"Oh. Sorry, I didn't mean to." Isaac was pretty sure he would've felt something too, but he decided to let it slide.

"You're fine. I mean it's fine! It is fine. I didn't need to spaz out like that." Bonnie was slowly losing control of her filter. Where was that milkshake?

Isaac silently observed the petite girl sitting across from him. She put most of the girls of Beacon Hills to shame. Her skin was a smooth caramel color which made her green eyes even more striking. She had a slightly crooked smile, and he could see that she carried herself with a certain strength. He definitely wouldn't mind getting to know her better, but apparently she wasn't there to stay.

"So-"Isaac started.

"Here you go!" Danny had arrived with his water and Bonnie's shake. "Can I get y'all anything else?" He asked with a dimpled smile.

"I'm good." Bonnie told him with a small smile.

"Same here." Isaac agreed.

"Cool! I'll come back in a bit with your check." Danny gave them another smile, and headed off to help a couple that had just entered.

As Danny walked off, Bonnie took a sip of her milkshake. Immediately her eyes bugged out, and she let out a moan that she would remember to be embarrassed about later.

"Oh my God!" She took another sip as Isaac covered his mouth to stop himself from laughing. "This is amazing! Have you had one of these?"

"Umm, no. But I definitely want to try one now." Isaac told Bonnie with a smile.

"Here try it." Bonnie shoved the glass in front of him. "It tastes like unicorn tears."

"I don't know if-"

"I promise I don't have cooties if that's what you're worried about." Bonnie interrupted. "Wait. Do you?"

"Not that I know of." Isaac said with a laugh. He grabbed the glass and prepared to drink. Before he put his mouth on the straw he picked up the scent of her cherry chapstick and something else he couldn't identify. It wasn't setting off any alarms so he ignored it. As he drank the milkshake, he realized that Bonnie's reaction was right on point.

"Oh my God!" Isaac exclaimed while staring at the magical milkshake.

"I know!" Bonnie said as she threw her hands up.

To their right they heard a throat clear. They turned to see Danny and the couple staring at them. The woman sat up straight and looked to Danny.

"I'll have what they're having."
Bonnie and Isaac's eyes met, and they began cracking up. This was the happiest that either had been in a while, and it was nice. Of course, with their track record, joy never lasted for long.

At once, their phones started ringing.

Bonnie looked at the caller id and saw that it was Caroline calling. She suddenly realized that she had completely forgotten to call someone to let them know about her car troubles.

"I'm sorry I have to take this." Bonnie told Isaac.

"It's okay! I should get this." Scott was calling for some reason, and in his gut, Isaac knew it wasn't good news.

They gave each other small smiles before answering their respective calls, and braced themselves.

"Bonnie!" Caroline's tearful voice came through.

"Isaac!" Scott's scared tone immediately chilled Isaac's bone.

"It's Matt and Jeremy."

"It's Boyd and Erica."

Bonnie and Isaac's eyes met again, but this time there was no laughter.

"They're missing."

So that's chapter 2! Honestly, i'll probably come back and rework this a little bit, but for now this is where it's at. What do you think the second scent Isaac picked up on the straw was? Let me know!