The single word stopped Sam cold, "No, its not possible. No," Sam stopped and breathed, "We killed her over a year ago."
Caithrine suddenly goty some of her cokcy confidence back and sat upright, "I didn't say she'd given it to my recently."
"But she did," Dean interjected, "You're a good liar. Of course I'm sure you knew that. It wasn't a year ago that you saw Anna. It was just a couple of months ago, wasn't it? She was looking for me too. Well, looking for Sam, but she knew I'd be where he was."
Caithrine bit her lip hard, "Ok maybe, but she didn't tell me she was going to try to kill me. When I found out, when ruby told me, I flipped. I was about ready to kill her myself!"
"Why?" Sam asked.
"Maybe my means aren't so honest, but my motive is true. I just wanted to find Dean. I just wanted to be with my dad."
