A/N: Thanks for all the alerts and faves and reviews! Love 'em!

All or Nothing – Chapter 2: Whatta Man

"So Kurt tells me you're an accountant?" Blaine said, staring at me from across the kitchen table.

"Yeah… kinda boring," I said, pushing my mashed potatoes around. I couldn't bring myself to look in his eyes. I felt like I did when I first admitted that I liked Will, except that I didn't even know this guy. Kurt had never talked about him, and I didn't even know if he was truly gay. Well, strike that. I knew he was. Otherwise, Kurt never would've invited him over and pretended that he was just inviting a friend over for dinner. It was a setup, plain and simple. And this time, I didn't mind.

"I wouldn't say it's boring," Blaine responded.

"Blaine's a math teacher at the school I'm working at," Kurt smiled.

"Well, student teacher. Still a year away from certification. But I get a lot of freedom in teaching, so it's nice. Have you ever thought about teaching, Finn?"

"Nah. I'm not good at public speaking."

"That's not what Kurt said. He said you were the lead of the glee club in high school. So was I."

I glanced up from my mashed potato mountain. "Really?"

"Yeah. We were called the Warblers. It was cool. Never won any titles like you guys did though."

We made small talk about glee club throughout the rest of dinner. Kurt cleaned up while Blaine and I drank coffee in the living room.

"So, you know this was a setup right?" Blaine asked. I blushed.

"Yeah. Kurt has been trying to get me to start dating for a while now."

"Why haven't you two hooked up?"

I about spit out my coffee. "Yeah, that isn't going to happen. Kurt had a crush on me in high school, but I never returned the feelings. Then we became best friends, and then brothers. I think if we were going to get together, it would've happened by now. Kurt really isn't my type."

Blaine raised his eyebrows at me. "So what is your type?"

I blushed again. "I don't really know honestly. I've only ever had one boyfriend. Before that, it was just girls."

"One boyfriend? Wow. He must've been special."

"It was… interesting."

"Do you want to tell me about it?"

I shrugged. "Not much to tell really. He broke my heart. I can't blame him. I did something stupid. It is a long story."

"Well maybe I can hear it sometime. Right now, I have to get going. Early meeting with my supervising teacher tomorrow. I really enjoyed meeting you."

Blaine put his cup of coffee down and stood up. I stood up and followed him to the door.

"Yeah, I enjoyed meeting you too. Would love to see you again sometime." Did those words really just come out of my mouth? Mr. no I don't want to meet anyone?

"Definitely," Blaine smiled. "Bye Kurt!" He called out.

"Bye! See you tomorrow!" Kurt called from the kitchen, and Blaine gave me one last smile as he left. Kurt came out of the kitchen a short while later while I still stood at the door.

"That's what I thought," he said.

I turned and glared. "What?"

"I knew Blaine would be your type."

"I don't have a type Kurt."

"Oh but I can see the wheels turning in both of your heads."

"Why don't you want him?"

"He's not my type."

I stared at Kurt for a moment. "Hold it. Did you hit on him and he turned you down?"

Kurt turned bright red and went back into the kitchen while I followed to tease him more.