A/N: Thanks for all the alerts and faves and reviews! Love 'em! I know the chapters have been coming fast as of recently. I'm done with school and have two weeks where I just have work, so I have extra time to write.

Chapter title inspired by the incredible Mariah Carey.

All or Nothing – Chapter 12: Emotions

"Wow, Blaine," I said, surprised. "How did you know I was coming back now?"

"Blame Kurt. He called me after you called him on your way back. I had told him to keep me updated on when you were coming back so I could tell you that I understood why you had to go to Seattle to meet up with that guy."

"His name is Will."

"Of course. Will. Sorry."

"It's fine. But wait? Kurt told you why I left?"

"Yeah. The boy has a big mouth."

"Unfortunately not a good thing in this situation," I muttered.

"Look," Blaine said walking up to me, and placing his hands on my shoulders. I couldn't avoid looking into his eyes. "I like you Finn. A lot. I know we haven't known each other a long time, but I can tell certain things right off the bat."

"I like you too Blaine." It wasn't a lie.

"So can you tell me what happened?"

"No."

"Okay, I understand that." Why did he have to be so understanding? "Can I ask you something else?"

I swallowed. "Of course."

"Did it help?"

Loaded question. "I think it did."

"Did you get closure?"

More like it opened things up again. "In a way, yes."

"So does that mean I can do this?" Blaine leaned in, placed his lips against mine, and locked me into a kiss. Oh man it was good. I couldn't help but kiss back. Soon we were making out passionately.

I tried to pull away. "Blaine… I…"

"You what?"

"I… can't do this."

"Why not?"

"Because… Will…"

"Because you and Will hooked up?" I pulled back and looked at him. "I told you. I'm good at reading people."

"So then why are you making out with me if you know that Will and I are back together?"

"I think it is pretty obvious why I am. I want you Finn. I think the true question should be, why are you making out with me when you know that you and Will are back together?"

I sighed. "I don't know."

"I do."

I sat down on the couch, and Blaine sat down next to me.

"Okay, Mr. Know-it-all, why?"

"Because you don't think that Will and you will last."

"That's a bit bitchy."

"So be it. But I think you know that you need to leave the past in the past. No matter how good the sex was."

"It was more than just sex."

"Are you sure?"

"Blaine, I think you're going too far."

"I'm sorry. I just… really want you."

"I want you too. Trust me. I do. If it wasn't for Will…"

"If it wasn't for Will, you wouldn't have felt so alone for seven years. If it wasn't for Will, you wouldn't have closed yourself off, even to me. If it wasn't for Will, you'd still have a relationship with your mother."

He made good points.

Blaine turned my head towards his and placed a soft kiss on my lips. "I know that you may think I'm being harsh. I'm just fighting for what I want."

I locked eyes with him, and we started making out again. Soon, we were both naked on the couch, grinding into each other. This time I reveled in his hairy chest, instead of freaking out over it.

"Finn, I need you inside of me," Blaine gasped, breaking lip contact for the first time in twenty minutes.

"Do you have…?" I asked. He reached down for his pants, and pulled the condom out of his pocket. "Came prepared huh?"

"Well I hoped it would get this far," he smirked, and placed the condom on me. For two glorious hours, we went at it like rabbits. At that point, I realized the time. Kurt would be home any minute. We ran up the stairs, and shut my bedroom door, just in time to hear Kurt walk through the front door. He came upstairs, and knocked on my door.

"Finn? You in there?" he asked.

"Um, yeah…" I answered, as Blaine went down on me again. "I just am taking a nap. I'll be down in about an hour."

"Two," Blaine said though his mouth was full.

"Two," I corrected.

"Mmmm hmm, tell Blaine I said hi. I'm going out to dinner. See you in a couple hours," Kurt said. He probably was in on this. I looked down at Blaine, and he had the biggest grin on his face.

"You guys suck," I said.

"But you like it," he said. And boy did I.

A/N: I know. I just put Will and Finn back together and then I do this. Guess we'll see what happens!