A/N: Thank you for all the amazing reviews after the last chapter. I'm so glad that the cliffhanger was so well received. The way I have it planned out, I see three chapters left, maybe four. So here we go!

Warning: This will probably be considered a short chapter by most. Sorry, but I need to put this part separate.

Chapter title inspired by Jennifer Lopez (cue Cartman talking with his hand)

All or Nothing – Chapter 15: Ain't It Funny

"Are you guys coming over tonight?" Brit asked.

"Nah. It's our one year anniversary of officially being a couple. I think we're going to like go to dinner or something," I said.

"I move here all the way from Ohio, and I barely see you!"

"I know I know. Look, next weekend, we'll go up to Mount Hood together, okay?"

"Fine," Britt sighed teasingly. "You better enjoy your night."

"Oh I will." We said our goodbyes, and hung up the phone. I finished up my work for the day and started my walk home.

I couldn't believe it had been a year since all the drama between Will, Blaine, and myself. I made my decision that night after talking with Tina. Since that time, I found myself living, literally, with my choice. He had moved in with Kurt and I, and we created our own little family. Kurt had even begun dating. He had "fallen in love" with this guy named Cody. What he constituted as falling in love was Cody spending thousands of dollars on him, and Kurt giving him sex. Yes, Kurt had found his sugar daddy. We barely saw him anymore, but it was nice the nights we could spend on the couch together watching some horrible movie as a family.

Brit had moved to Portland about six months after that night, and she was right. I barely had seen her. We threw her a housewarming party, and I had seen her about once a month. But I really wanted to see her more. It was just that my relationship was taking up most of my time.

Tina and I had barely spoken after that night. She… didn't like my decision. Or, I guess rather, she didn't like the way I handled the decision. We were still friends, and we would always be friends, it was just that she had an opinion and I had an opinion and they didn't match. She still came around for the holidays, and was there when Brit moved, but it wasn't the same.

I couldn't blame her though. She saw what the decision did to the one I let down. He had disappeared and no one had heard from him. I felt horrible, as I wanted to stay friends, but there wasn't much I could do. I had to follow my heart.

Truth be told, there were times where I questioned my decision. Especially when it affected my relationship with Tina. And truth be told, he could sometimes be a bit possessive with my time, which is the real reason I hadn't seen Brit as much as I had wanted. It was different with Kurt, since we all lived together. But now I was even starting to see him less. I loved my boyfriend, but there were times I still questioned it.

As I walked up the steps to the townhouse, I checked the mail. Bills, bills, bills. Then a letter. No return address, but addressed to me. I opened up the front door, shut it, and ripped open the letter. I had recognized the handwriting, and I was right.

Please meet me at this address, on this day, at this time. I need to see you, even it is for just one last time. I just need to tell you something.

Why couldn't he just tell me in the letter? I had made my decision. But seeing his handwriting did make my heart jump a little. He didn't even sign his name, because he knew I would know. I sighed, and started heading into the living room. I looked up, and dropped the letter at the sight before me.

"Will you marry me Finn?" Blaine asked, kneeling on one knee. I guess this was my anniversary surprise.