Luz and Amity awoke by the sound of the portal case opening, they sat up to see what was going on, they saw Eda and Hunter Standing there.

" Where did you go?" Luz said groggily

" I went to check out Caleb's room, and had some interesting memories, to say the least. "

" Wanna talk about it?" Luz said yawning.

" Not right, now I will tomorrow with everyone."

" Okay." She said before laying back down on Amity's shoulder and falling back to sleep. She smiled at Luz. she looked over at Hunter. He was very easy to read though the tried to act like he wasn't. She knew something was up.

" Hunter? If you need to talk, and don't want to tell Luz something, I'm here to listen."

" I appreciate it, Amity, but it's alright. "

" Okay as long as you're sure."

" I'm going to head back up to my room, good night guys."

" Night Hunter." She watched as he walked back up the stairs. She looked over at Eda, Eda smiled at her

" He will be alright don't worry, now come on let's get this tired human to bed."

" Sounds good." Amity said doing her best to move Luz without waking her up.

Meanwhile back up in his room Hunter laid in bed, tossing, turning,and thinking, he rolled over and saw Philips Journal sitting on his desk with the deer Palisman he found. He knew he should probably sleep, but something yet again was nagging him. He sighed getting up and walking over to his desk, and opening Philips Journal. Waffles had a feeling this was a bad idea, and she kept pecking his hand and chirping at him to go to bed and rest.

" It's okay Waffles I'm just gonna read an entry or two then I will go to bed, I promise." He said, petting her head. The little bird glared at her witch before hopping on his head and settling in. "Thank you Waffles." The bird just gave a single chirp. He flipped through the entries skimming them for any mention of Caleb in association with the memory he had earlier, finally he found one near the end of the journal.

" Today is October 23rd. Well, my worst fears have come true, I do believe I have lost my brother to the witch. Earlier this evening he took me to the Waterfall we played in when we were kids.. when it was a much simpler time. He placed these pieces of paper on the grass and as he stepped on it they turned into flowers and produced glowing orbs of different colors. He looked so happy , I haven't seen him that happy in a long time, the fact that Witchcraft is what is making him happy is wrong. He thought I would find it beautiful. He even tried to have me touch one. He really has strayed away from God's path. He even had the nerve to carve me one of those Palisman things, he assumed I would like such a demonic and archaic thing.

What hurts the most out of everything he has done. He has made the decision to move to the demon realm. He wanted me to come with him. But I cannot in my good conscience and soul do such a thing. He is really going to abandon me here, to live a life of sin, to live a life amongst demons and monsters. I know what I must do. It is the only thing that will save him. God forgive me, and I do pray he will forgive me too. "

Hunter didn't like the way that entry was worded. Waffles sensed his uneasiness, and chirped at him softly.

" I'm okay, I just don't know what to make of it. I will share it with the others tomorrow. Maybe they have some ideas." Hunter yawned and rubbed his eyes, closing the Journal. Waffles noticed and angrily chirped at him to go to bed. " Alright, I'm going. I promised you I would." He said chuckling at her and smiled. She did a little flip and let out a Happy chirp for her victory of making her witch go to bed. Hunter turned off his desk light and laid in bed. He really was exhausted, within a few moments of laying down he fell asleep and right into a memory.

He opened his eyes to see he was sitting in the living room by the fire. He looked down and noticed Evelyn was resting her head on his chest. "Alright so I'm in another memory, this should be a good moment…why do I have the feeling it's not.

" So he didn't take it well I assume?"

" No, we ended up in a huge shouting match, and I ended up admitting I am planning on leaving."

" The glyph magic didn't work to change his mind?"

" Nope, neither did the Palisman I carved him… I don't think he's ever going to change it. I know he will choose to not come with me. Which saddens me greatly. " Evelyn sat up and he felt her put her hand on his face.

" He will be okay, it is his choice to make, you can't force him. Despite his strange obsession with witch hunting, he is a really smart guy. He's a very detailed observer and artist. He can go places I -" her thought was interrupted by a knock on the door. He felt himself turn his head looking at it, as another loud knock happened.

" Are you expecting anyone?"

" No, stay out of sight. I will be right back." He said feeling himself get up,

" Why does he feel so nervous here…what's going on?"

He felt himself take a deep breath as he opened the door and He saw a mob of people outside, he noticed they had torches and pitchforks in their hands. He knew exactly what was going on.

" I have felt a similar type of fear before…But this is somehow even more terrifying. "

" Caleb Wittebane, You have been accused of fraternizing with a witch and have been seen performing acts of witchcraft." He felt himself not knowing what to say. he just stood there as he heard people murmuring in the crowd. his mind was blank.

" I always knew something was up with him."

"It's not surprising, I have even seen him talking to a bird before, like it could understand him."

" I bet he killed their parents, his poor brother was raised by such a heathen. thank the Lord he has not been led astray."

" There is always one bad egg in every family." the words of the villagers stung, but he finally found the words to speak, glaring at the head witch hunter.

" What are you talking about? I have done no such thing! Who would tell you such-" He yelled before noticing a figure emerging from the crowd.

" Tell them the truth Caleb. Please, they promised they wouldn't do anything to you, if you turn her over." He looked over and saw Philip standing there.

" Philip, betrayed you....by the Titan, this feeling hurts, I feel like my soul is being crushed, Is this what real betrayal feels like?"

" Philip?" He felt himself just stare at Philip unable to process the fact that his dear brother that he loved more than anything, would do such a thing to him.

" This is for your own good brother. You will soon be free of the demon that has ensnared your soul and who has corrupted your beliefs. "

He felt someone grab his hand and saw it was Evelyn. She threw some paper on the ground and a giant yellow glyph appeared. He watched everyone back up as it started to glow, except for Philip. "Caleb!" He heard Philip yell. In mere seconds they were right outside the cemetery. He felt himself help Evelyn up and looked over to see Philip teleported with them.

" Philip!" He heard himself scream as he felt , the anger and rage burning within him, as he stared at his brother.

" Caleb, look I know you're mad, but I- I did it for us, she-she was corrupting you. Please Caleb, say something" before he could open his mouth he heard something smash against the archway, in mere seconds a portal was open. Evelyn was looking at him.

" Caleb! We need to go now! This portal can only stay open for a short while!" He saw Evelyn yell as she was holding out her hand.

" CALEB!! " He felt himself look over back at Philip and shook his head,with tears in his eyes he felt completely disgusted. "SAY SOMETHING!!!" He heard his brother scream as loud as he could. He turned around and grabbed Evelyn's hand, running through the portal.

As the memory faded Hunter woke up screaming, he noticed he was having trouble breathing, as tears streamed down his face, he let out another anguished cry " As he held his hands up to his head, and tucked his knees to his chest.

" Hunter!" Luz, Eda, King and Amity, burst into his room. They saw Hunter sitting in bed in the middle of a severe panic attack, they haven't seen Hunter in this state in a long time. They saw him just sitting there sobbing and screaming. " Eda what's going on?" Amity said Eda took a deep breath.

" Luz I need you, King and Amity to go down stairs."

" But I want to-" Eda cut her off.

" This is something I need to handle."

" Luz, Edas' right, she has to handle this."

" Eda he's going to be okay right?" King said, concerned.

" He will, I think he just experienced a really scary memory of Calebs " Luz nodded sadly and took King with her as Amity shut the door behind them. Eda walked over to Hunter, and took a seat on his bed.

" Hunter, can I touch you? " She said quietly and calmly. She watched for his answer, he nodded his head. She started by putting her hand on his shoulder. Hunter managed to look over at her and she noticed the pain in his puffy and teared eyes. She hated seeing one of her kids, looking like that, especially with Hunter. She remembered the nightmares he used to have, and how utterly terrified he would be. Her motherly instincts kicked in immediately.

"Was it a bad memory of Calebs?" she watched him nod his head, and he grabbed her Sobbing hysterically. Eda just sat there, and let him do what he needed to do to let it all out. " Shhhh, it's okay Hunter, when you're ready we can talk." she quietly said running her fingers through his hair once more trying her best to aid in calming him. twenty minutes passed before the sobs started to fade, and his breathing started leveling out. When he was ready Hunter let go and looked at her.

" Eda?"

" Hunter,What did you see?" Hunter took a deep breath as best as he could and spoke.

" Eda… I know-I know why Caleb left the human realm, and didn't return…" he squeaked out trying not to start crying once more.

" Why? " She said, nervous to hear what Hunter was going to say next.

" Philip he… he" he felt the tears start flowing again burning his eyes. " He reported Caleb…. HE REPORTED CALEB TO THE WITCH HUNTERS ABOUT EVELYN AND THAT HE WAS PRACTICING WITCHCRAFT! PHILIP BETRAYED HIS OWN BROTHER!" He yelled as loud as he could before he went back to hugging Eda, sobbing some more. Hearing those words broke her heart. Now knowing that Caleb was a part of her family, hearing about how his brother, that deranged monster did something so vile to a member of her family stung deeply.

" Oh Hunter." She said hugging him back trying to hold back tears of her own. unbeknownst to them the same presence as earlier was in his room watching them. He felt beyond guilty. He had no idea that memory would hurt Hunter that deeply. He promised himself when he started showing Hunter his Memories he would never harm Hunter with them after witnessing everything his brother put him through, but he just did that.

"I'm sorry Hunter..." he said to himself, as he was unable to do anything but watch.