Misunderstandings: A Klaine Break Up story
Setting: Set back when Sebastian was actively perusing Blaine (before midseason 3 finale) and Blaine didn't realize he was evil (before Michael)!
Summary: Sebastian throws himself at Blaine and Kurt misunderstands the situation. Sad and Angsty. Angry!Kurt. HAPPY ENDING!Songfic (or just gleetastic!). Klaine. Not Cannon.(I recommend scrolling down to the bottom for a link to the music in the fic and playing it when the song occurs in my story)
Spoilers: Not much, I guess parts of the first half of season three.
Kurt singing
Puck Singing
Chapter Two:
Puck's POV:
I walked into Glee practice today knowing that some crazy shit was about to go down. Late Saturday night I'd been woken up by a frantic phone call from Kurt asking if he could come raid my itunes for some "Angry" music. Then he crashed at my house for nearly all of Sunday while he searched for the "Perfect song to show Him how I feel". When he'd finally chosen one, a Fall Out Boy song I'd downloaded illegally back in 2007 when they were popular, he then somehow convinced me to help him practice it for Glee. Once I heard the song he picked, I knew something had happened and my suspicions were confirmed when it became painfully obvious he and one Mr. Blaine Anderson were avoiding each other. I had to admit, I was a little excited to see the looks on both Blaine and the rest of New Directions faces when they heard the lyrics and the style of the song. So it was no surprise that I couldn't restrain my shit-eating grin as I took my seat and noticed Blaine shifting uncomfortably in the back row.
Mr. Shu was about to start a pep-talk when Kurt sashayed through the door looking slightly different than his usually fabulous self. I mean he still looked fashionable, but he was dressed in all black and had a definite punk vibe. I was kind of digging it. He certainly dressed the part.
"Fashionably late today, Kurt?" Asked Rachel uncertainly.
"Sorry," He responded, not sounding sorry at all, walking up to stand next to Mr. Shu, who looked confused, "I was preparing a song. If you don't mind, Mr. Shu, it is kinda important." Wow, bad ass points for Hummel. Mr. Shu seemed like he was about to tell him to wait but then his gaze shifted slightly to Blaine and he backed off. So, Mr. Shu knew something was up too. Interesting.
"Alright, Kurt. Go ahead." Kurt gave me a head jerk and I stood up to grab my Guitar and a mic for singing back up. Kurt pulled a stand over for himself as well. Once we were set up, Kurt looked up at Blaine for the first time since entering to room. Blaine was giving his best puppy eyes but they seemed to be sliding right off of Kurt's Bitch glare. Man, Blaine was in the dog house this time.
"This song is about getting ….caught." He glared down Blaine and the rest of the group followed his gaze. They were figuring out what I had assumed when I heard the song. Kurt had caught Blaine cheating. I kinda wanted to punch him for it, but he was little and fast and knew how to box so he could probably just dodge it. Kurt's punishment might be a little more effective.
Kurt started singing without accompaniment for the first word and I joined him with strong hits of my guitar on the second. It had a powerful effect. I saw everyone's eyes widen a little bit. Then against it might have been how low Kurt was singing and, well in the style of the song, he was practically screaming.
"This has been said so many times that I'm not sure if it matters
But we never stood a chance
And I'm not sure if it matters
If you are the shores, I am the waves begging for big moons
I'm mailing letters to addresses in a ghost town"
"Your secret's out" We sang together. I hit the lower notes and he the, still low, but higher part.
"I know this hurts, it was meant to, it was meant to
Your secret's out and the best part is it isn't even a good one
And it's mind over you don't, don't matter"
The rest of the Glee club was turning and glancing at Blaine every few seconds now. Blaine, meanwhile, was staring at Kurt looking like he wanted to cry. Kurt was rocking out. He'd taken the mic out of the stand and was actually sort of making the song sexual. It was a smart move. It is what I would have done. Remind him what he is missing out on now that he screwed up.
"This has been said so many times that I'm not sure if it matters
But it must be said again that all us boys are just screaming
Into microphones for attention
Because we're just so bored
We never knew that you would pick it apart, oh
I'm falling apart to songs about hips and hearts"
Here Kurt added a hip thrust for good measure.
"Your secret's out
I know this hurts, it was meant to, it was meant to
Your secret's out and the best part is it isn't even a good one
And it's mind over you don't, don't matter"
"I used to obsess over living,
Now I only obsess over you
Tell me you'd like boys like me better
In the dark lying on top of you"
Blaine seemed to visibly flinch at this line and shake his head frantically. Was he seriously try to proclaim his innocence? I mean judging from the lyrics, Kurt had walked in on him and whoever.
"This has been said so many times that I'm not sure if it matters
This has been said so many times that I'm not sure if it matters!
This has been said so many times that I'm not sure if it matters
This has been said so many times that I'm not sure if it matters"
I held out the last note and jammed out on my guitar while Kurt slide back into the chorus.
"I know this hurts, it was meant to, it was meant to
Your secret's out and the best part is it isn't even a good one
And it's mind over you don't, don't, don't, don't matter!"
We finished off strong. There was a speaking part that came after this and made the song more poem-y and lame. Kurt and I both agreed it did nothing for the song and that neither of us could really pull it off correctly anyway.
There was a pause and then a few awkward claps.
"Thank you for your time." Kurt said stiffly and turned to walk out.
"Kurt! Wait! Please! Let me explain!" Blaine jumped up from his chair and rush over to Kurt. He successfully snagged a grip on his sleeve and tried to turn him back to look at him. Kurt, however, reacted violently.
"Don't!" He shouted, pushing Blaine away from him. "Touch me!" He finished. It was then that I realized Kurt was crying. He yanked out of Blaine's gasp, paused to wipe away an angry tear, and stormed out. The door slammed behind him with a crash.
"Sorry, Mr. Shu," Came Rachel's voice, "But I think Glee isn't going to happen today. I have to go check on Kurt!" Before Mr. Shu could answer she ran right past Blaine and out the door after Kurt. I watched as the rest of New Directions followed. First Mercedes and Brittany scurried out not even sparing a glance at Blaine. Then Santana stalked up to him and had to be dragged out by Tina and Quinn before she tried to "go Lima Heights" on him. Sugar and Rory shuffled out next, followed by Mike and Sam who both gave Blaine disapproving head shakes. Artie wheeled past him giving him a thumbs down. Last was Finn and I. I walked to the door all bad-ass and leaned against it waiting while Finn approached Blaine.
"Are you gunna punch me?" Blaine asked not looking up from the floor. "I would."
"No." Responded Finn. "Did you really cheat on him?" Finn asked not looking at Blaine, but instead standing slightly in front of him and looking at me. His jaw was set. He was gritting his teeth and scrunching his eyes. He was mad. Probably the maddest I'd ever seen him.
"No. I honestly didn't. It was a case of bad timing and putting too much trust in someone who I shouldn't have." Blaine looked up at the back of Finn. He was still crying.
"I'm not ready to believe you, not if Kurt doesn't."
"That's fair."
"So what are you gunna do about it?"
"I don't know." Finn nodded then sighed. He gave me a quick look before turning to face Blaine. I shrugged and walked out leaving them alone as Mr. Shu awkwardly walked past them and out the door.
Finn's POV:
I sighed as I turned to Blaine. The little guy was wracked with silent tears. Part of me wanted to believe him. He looked so torn up, but that could be because he was feeling guilty.
"You have two choices." I told him bluntly. "You can keep fighting for this. You can try to convince Kurt that it wasn't what he thought. You can try to win him back, but if he doesn't come back to you and forgive you, you run the risk of him hating you. I know Kurt, and seeing your face every day in school and knowing that he wasn't good enough to hold your attention, that you only want him back now that he caught you cheating, would kill him."
"That- I mean I don't – I'd never!" Blaine started desperately.
"Hey," I waved him away, "I'm not the one you need to convince. I told you. I'll believe you when he does." I paused while he nodded looking dejected. Dejected? How do I even know that word? "As far as I can tell, your other option is to get out of his life. If you loved him you wouldn't want him haunted by the memories of walking through that door. I'm talking quitting Glee at least until we graduate. Up to you, but, if I find you do neither, I might get puck to hold you down, if you know what I mean." I patted his shoulder and turned to walk out the door.
"You're a good friend Finn, and an even better Brother." I smiled and shut the door on him.
-TBC-
Author's Note:
Thanks for reading. Sorry this took so long. I WAS IN CANADA! Haha
Here is a link to the song: www. youtube watch?v=0kiYevm-DX4
REMEMBER TO TAKE OUT THE SPACES! :D
I already started the next chapter so hopefully it will be out soon. If you have an POV requests let me know ok? :D
Reviews are love.
-Scifigeek-