Sam seemed to have been the only one to see Karofsky shove Kurt into the locker, but before he can go over and help Mr. Schuester ends up being the on to come to the rescue and hustles Kurt into his office. The blond can't help but think that maybe, just maybe, the teacher can finally start putting a stop to all of the bullying.
He's wrong.
Schuester's dumb idea to help solve the problem is singing mash ups sung by the opposite gender. He hates this idea, but of course he can't voice his opinion. He's still the new kid and standing out will hurt him if he does it too soon – especially while he's still trying to cement his quarterback status. This also comes with the return of Noah Puckerman. Puck, as the guy calls himself, appraises Sam quickly before shaking his hand and declaring him a 'bro'. Sam supposes it's because they'll both be on the same teams now (Glee club and Football), but he'd expected more of a fight from him considering he was now dating the mother of his child and had, in a sense, momentarily replaced him. But he doesn't and all it does is cement his feelings that Quinn is annoying and not worth his time.
He does manage to find a way to use Quinn to entertain himself however. Apparently a new tread has arisen where people were using the image of coach Beiste, the new football coach, to cool down their arousal. He finds the whole thing hilarious and when he pretends to do it with Quinn the look on her face nearly sends him into a laughing fit right there. His fun ends however when the blond girl runs off to tell the menacing cheer leading coach. He still can't understand why the girl trusts the woman who kicked her off the squad and announced to the entire school that she was pregnant, but he files it away for later as useful information.
He plays along with the stupid mash up for Beiste and sings to Quinn because it's what they expect him to do and it distracts him from having to watch Finn sing to Rachel. He would rather write off this whole experience, but seeing Rachel dressed in rocker chick clothes is definitely something he never wants to forget.
The next few weeks are a blur of the usual nonsense until one day in the locker room Mike and Artie confront Karofsky about him bulling Kurt. It gives him some momentary sense of hope that, finally, someone was going to do something. Unfortunately the attempt goes downhill pretty quick and Sam knows he has no other choice but to step in and rescue his teammates earning him a black eyes for his troubles. He's also earned himself a new enemy. The most startling part of the whole thing though is that he actually wishes the fight had gone on longer. Even if he was possibly going to get his ass kicked the thrill of the fight is the best high he's felt in weeks. It wasn't something meticulously calculated. It was spur of the moment and pure adrenaline.
The black eye also ends up being a better tool then he'd imagined. Not only had everyone started to look at him as a hero, but they took notice of what a coward their so called 'leader' Finn was. Even Rachel began to look at him with admiration. He's briefly considered giving Quinn some ridiculous promise ring he gotten her, but with the fight cementing his great guy status in her eyes he doesn't need to. He does, however, have to deal with her clinging to him the whole time. He even overhears her refer to him as her boyfriend to a few Cheerios as she snapped at them for talking about how attractive he was. He'd need to separate himself from her quickly.
Of course Kurt is grateful to him too and Sam is glad to have repaid his unspoken debt, but it's Rachel who gives him the best reward. She ends up showing up at Sam's house with a plate of thank you cookies and kissing his check before abruptly leaving. He's sure he's won her over – at least until Burt and Carol's wedding.
It eats away at him when he sees Finn and Rachel look at each other lovingly and he's glad that everyone is staring at the bride and groom and not at him. His eyes avert to Santana who coincidentally is also looking at Finn and Rachel. Except her expression tells him it's not a coincidence. It also tells him he may just have another hidden card to play.
It's easy to convince Santana to tell Rachel about sleeping with Finn. The Latina hates Finn just as much as he does and while Rachel isn't her favorite person she'll do it for Sam because he's the closest friend she has. The timing is pretty bad though, as she ends up revealing the truth just as Sam and Quinn are revealed to have the duet for Sectionals. As he's expected Finn and Rachel begin to argue, but before he can swoop in to play her knight in shining armor Quinn insists they start practicing their duet.
Practice bores him. Their soft voices blend well enough, but lack the power to carry the song and when Sam actually says something about it and tries to suggest another song Quinn just stares at him like he's stupid and Mr. Schue just tells him to trust him. He manages to stop himself from yelling out in frustration and just continues to go through the motions.
Even with his current distractions Sam knows he's still been able to drive a wedge between Finn and Rachel that won't easily be forgotten and he'll be able to win soon, but of course it's never that simple. Why? Because Puck suddenly decides to play nice with Rachel. What's worse is that he's finally identified the sick and angry feeling in his gut as jealousy. Of course this creates a dent in his plan, but that's never a problem
Plans can always change.
He and Santana invite themselves over to Rachel's house to check on her right when Puck is visiting. They stumble upon her crying to him over Finn and through her distraught state she thankfully forgets to ask how they got inside. Santana actually apologizes and he's surprised to hear how genuine it sounds. This is a good thing because in order for his new and improved plans to work Santana and Rachel need to get along. Rachel is understandably wary of the Latina's apology though and the other takes the hint and coerces Puck out the door with her leaving just he and Rachel. The small girl sobbed a bit more and soon she was laying next to him with her face buried into his chest.
"What if I got rid of them all? Finn, Quinn, Karofsky...just everybody..." He asks her. She looks up at him, teary eyed and confused, before answering. "You would do that for me?" She asks him. "Do you want me to?" He questions her in return. Just by the look in their eyes they both know that this isn't just some kind of kind of emotional, spur of the moment, meaningless talk. It's deadly serious.
So they perform at sectionals without incident. They're ok, but it's a huge surprise to Sam when they actually tie. He doesn't quite know how it happened since there are three judges and only three teams competing, but if it make Rachel happy he'll deal with it. His week brightens even more when Rachel dumps Finn and runs straight back to him after. He's won. It's over.
Except it's not. Because now he needs to get back to work.
Dave Karofsky is walking to his car late one desolate evening when he and Santana corner him. It's Santana's first time killing something – someone – and all she can talk about is how alive she feels. Hearing her chatter makes the clean-up less daunting so he lets her repeat the details while the story plays back in his head.
The two of them offer to have hims spend a bit of 'fun' with them. Santana had spotted Dave checking him out in the hallway. Sam knew his teammate would never agree to an encounter with Sam alone for fear of being outed as gay. But he knew Dave would agree if Santana was their because with a girl there is somehow made it less gay. As usual he's right and they head back to Santana's empty house to get the party started.
It starts out innocently enough. They push Dave down so he's sitting on the bed and Santana quickly climbs into his his lap and kisses him. The boy responds quickly but Sam knows he needs to up the ante to fully distract the tall jock. He leans in close and trails kisses up the boys neck and is quickly to find his pulse point. He runs his hands under the other boys shirts and traces his abdomen as the Latina slips away unnoticed.
He only need to open his eyes for a moment to see she's in position. He grips the other boys hair tightly enough to hold his head in place as Santana slips in from behind. Tugging the lager boys head back by his hair and the girl quickly and efficiently cut open his throat. The blood sprays rapidly as the boy cokes, but Sam remained unaffected. To him it's just like water, only red. He pushes the other boy on his back and sits on his chest to prevent him from getting up. As predicted the guy fights, but he loses blood too rapidly to save himself and he dies choking on his own blood sprawled out on Santana's comforter.
They immediately get to work cleaning up – from throwing the comforter, sheets, and their clothes in the wash, to showering, to bleaching the floors and walls when they are finally face with removing the body. Sam managed get his hands on a plastic sheet from the school's art department and they have just enough to wrap up the body with. The only problem they have from there is lifting the body. They manage to get it into the back of Sam's pickup from the safety of Santana's house connected garage and pull away from the house with the headlights off to avoid any suspicion. They dump the body in a barren part of the woods that's known for housing wolves and they unwrap the plastic so the animals can enjoy a nice dinner.
There is a shared sense of satisfaction between them and they congratulate each other before parting ways to go be with their separate lovers.
Rachel is quiet when he climbs through her window later that night to see her. She's sitting on her bed waiting for him barely reacts when he tells her the deed is done. She does respond however, when he leans in and kisses her softly. The kisses soon become hungry and they lay back on her bed. He strips off his clothes for a second time and soon their position is very reminiscent of their last encounter. He's down to boxers and she's in another flimsy nightgown. But she doesn't stop him this time. She knows who he is – what he is now and he takes full advantage of the power he now has over her.
He reaches up her thighs and pulls her panties down her legs before kicking off his own boxers and hovering over her. He thrusts into her gently and she lets out a cry of pain and shock. He continues to pull his cock in and out of her as she cries meld into pleasure. While some lovers murmur sweet nothings he's not most lovers. Instead he whispers to her exactly what happened and they both reach their climaxes right after the part where Santana had slit Karofsky's throat.
The news that Dave Karofsky is missing spreads like wildfire. Rumors circulate that a diary had been found and that the jock was secretly gay help at validity to the theory that he'd just run away. Lima Police Department says nothing about the diary or the boys sexuality at their press conference. All they do is plead for Dave to contact them and to come home. It's clear that they think he's run away too. And with that the case goes cold.
I'm think of making the next chapter in either Rachel or Santana's P.O.V. Should I? Or do you guys just want to keep following Sam?