I do not own Glee or anything to do with it. This belongs to Ryan Murphy and Fox. However I do own Emily, Sophia, Josh and the songs used, as well as them belonging to their own respective companies. I also do not own any of the words used in the episode 'Bad Reputation'.
Onto episode four and a little bit more of the mystery will be revealed. Thanks for everyone who has read and reviewed as well it means a lot. Anyway on with the story!
The New Girl in Town
Chapter Four: A Bad Reputation is Never Easy to Escape
(Emily wandered into the choir room where most of the Glee Clubbers were sat around a laptop. She sat down next to Mercedes and Kurt, pulled out a book and started to read as Jessie and Rachel entered the room.)
"That better not be my first beauty contest" Rachel commented as she sat down next to Emily.
"No this is way more funnier than that!" Kurt laughed. Suddenly Finn raised an eyebrow.
"Is that Miss. Sylvester?" he asked as Kurt and Mercedes carried on laughing.
"Yeah me and Sophia stole it from her office after she sent us to get her hormone replacement injections after Cheerio practise" Kurt chortled through laughter.
"Well where is she then?" Emily commented after noticing that Santana, Brittany and Sophia weren't in the room. Kurt shrugged and carried on laughing with Mercedes.
"This is going on YouTube for sure!" Finn grinned getting ready to swipe the laptop.
"Do you think that`s such a good idea? She might kill us!" Rachel exclaimed. Emily nodded in agreement.
"Oh let her have a taste of her own medicine" Mercedes replied. Jessie nodded and Emily shot the older boy a glare. She still wasn't a hundred percent sure about him.
"I agree with Finn you guys need to stop being asses and start being bad asses" Jessie replied. Finn shot a look at his rival and then picked the laptop up and pocketed it. Emily just shook her head as the warning bell sounded for the rest of classes as the Glee Clubbers left the room.
(Will sighed as he surveyed the group. Figgins had informed him that one of the Glee Clubbers had set up what was called a "Glist" which was basically a list of all the Glee Clubbers in what was the order the writer believed was the worst behaved.)
"It wasn't me!" Emily protested looking round the room "Just because I`m new" she glared at Puck who looked smug "Bet it was Puck!" she exclaimed.
"Back off it wasn't me!" Puck replied.
"So why is your girlfriend on the list?" Tina chimed in.
"I dunno but it's more likely to be Sophia everybody knows she has a crush on me" Puck smirked.
"And why am I last on the list?" Rachel looked mad "Just because I wouldn't put out when I dated you" Rachel crossed her arms and sat beside Jessie.
"Woah woah woah!" Will exclaimed as he then glanced Puck. "Puck seriously did you do it?" he raised an eyebrow.
"I said no," Puck replied "Sure I like setting stuff on fire and beating up people and tossing people in dumpsters but I`m no liar."
"He's right," Sophia admitted as everyone's heads turned to face the blonde cheerleader "If it was Puck he would be taking full responsibility."
"Ok beside this and posting Miss. Sylvester's video on YouTube you guys are getting quite a bad reputation. I know you guys are under a lot of stress what with Regionals coming up and you haven't got the recognition you would have liked from winning Sectionals" Will explained as he passed round sheet music. Emily glanced at it and burst out laughing.
"Something wrong Emily?" Will glanced at the red head who shook her head.
"No just bringing back an old memory" she smiled embarrassed. Sophia gave her friend a weird look.
"Your assignment for the week is to find songs like these and try to make them great again" Will smiled.
"This song should be arrested for the crime of sucking" Jessie mumbled. Emily glared at Jessie as Will just smiled and motioned to Mike and Matt to switch the C.D. player on. The room then filled with the sound of 'Ice Ice Baby' as Emily squealed and joined Brittany, Mike, Puck and Sophia on the floor. Emily then smirked as she ran forward and dragged Finn up as he looked confused. The song then carried on as the group all joined together.
"That song was awesome!" Emily exclaimed as she wandered out of the room chatting to Sophia who just smiled.
"I better get to Biology class" Emily explained as she left Sophia but didn't notice Miss. Sylvester watching her.
"Dear Journal" Sue wrote "My video has now reached two thousand hits and I have reached the point where I can't walk the corridors without being laughed at. I must find out who did it before it's too late and beside I also need to check up on the welfare of Emily's Aunt. She had the unfortunate point of being checked into the local hospital after a bad case of food poisoning." Suddenly her thoughts were broken by a knock on the door as Emily entered.
"Come in I was thinking about you" Sue smirked. Emily glanced at the Cheerio coach confused.
"What do you want? I have to go and visit my aunt" Emily lied knowing full well there wasn't an Aunt and that she had made the story up.
"The truth is I know there is no Aunt," Sue replied "And so I don't know what I should do. Should I tell Figgins and make him bring the proper truth out or should I make you join the Cheerios?"
"Don't tell Figgins" Emily begged. "Ok there is no Aunt. I made it up the truth is..." Emily paused and Sue leaned forward waiting for the juicy truth "I live alone" she continued. "I only made up my Aunt so that I wouldn't get in trouble for living on my own. But if you will cover it up I'll join the Cheerios." Emily bit her lip not knowing that Mr. Schuester wouldn't like that but she had no choice. Sue just nodded smirking.
"I think that will be best" Sue nodded holding out her hand and Emily shook it. "Next practise will be tomorrow and don't be late." Emily then exited the room her head low.
"Now the next puzzle I have to solve is who her parents are" Sue mumbled to herself as she sipped on her protein shake.
"Did you do it?" Will glanced at Sophia who shook her head.
"It wasn't me Mr. Schue" Sophia's blue eyes filled with tears. "I know that I might have some beef with Quinn but if I did do the list then would I have put her at number one. That to me seems like it's her!"
"Can you bring Emily in now?" Will looked at Sophia who nodded and left the room. A few seconds passed and Emily entered still angry over Miss Sylvester.
"Before we start I heard about you joining the Cheerios" Will looked annoyed not at Emily but that one of his Glee Clubbers was jumping ship.
"I didn't mean to it just sorta happened" Emily replied lamely before bursting into tears. Will moved across and put an arm around the girl.
"I just don't want to be here anymore I want to go home!" she exclaimed through tears.
"A lot of people think that" Will smiled. Emily shook her head.
"You don't understand Mr. Schue" she mumbled before looking down at the ground.
"Come on I know I'm not "down with it" as Mercedes likes to say but I mean I was young once I know what you young people are going through" Will smiled at Emily who hiccupped nodding."Beside I don't think you did the 'Glist' so you are free to go whenever you want" Emily smiled.
"Thanks dad" she whispered under her breath and Will pricked up his ears.
"I mean you remind me of my father" she replied. "I'll send Kurt in next" she said blushing getting up off the chair and walking out of the room. Will just sat there confused.
"She called me Dad?" Will paced around Emma's office "And I still don't know who made the 'Glist'."
"Well you do act like a father figure to most of the Glee Clubbers maybe she's just feeling more maternal" Emma shrugged. "Beside she's new maybe the emotions are getting to her that's all."
"I suppose," Will sighed "It just felt really weird that`s all. And she`s joined the Cheerios as well."
"Really?" Emma looked surprised. "I didn't think Emily was that type of girl. I mean being more interested in popularity rather than enjoying something for the sake of enjoying it."
"You mean like Glee Club" Will smirked and Emma blushed. Will smiled and kissed the top of her head "You always know what to say" he whispered as he exited Emma's office and almost bumped into Sue.
"Just the person I wanted to see," Sue smirked "I'm so pleased with your Glee Clubbers for posting the video of me dancing to 'Physical' online. Oh and Emily great addition to the Cheerios" she quipped. Sue then walked away leaving Will confused.
"Sometimes I don't understand that woman" he mumbled as he walked towards the faculty lounge.
"Ok guys it has been nearly a week since the 'Glist' went up and if I don't find out who did it today I'm gonna have to get Principal Figgins involved" Will informed the group to mumbles and groans. Emily dressed in her new Cheerio uniform next to Sophia didn't say anything "Ok Rachel can you show your Bad Reputation project." Rachel nodded then stood up leaving Will to occupy her empty chair. Rachel started talking but Emily started to zone out again.
(Emily and Josh each entered McKinley High's auditorium where a few of the other members of the Glee Club were scattered around either practising or talking to Mr. Hudson who had taken over Mr. Schuester as the clubs director. Finn smiled as Emily and Josh came nearer to him.)
"Hey Emily, Josh," he grinned "Just who I wanted to see."
"Yeah we came to practise 'Run Joey Run' Josh explained. Finn had given Josh one of the three male leads and Emily the female lead. "Plus Em and her father had another falling out" Josh whispered to Finn.
"Really?" Finn looked surprised as he glanced at Emily who looked upset "Suppose all teenage girls are like that my daughter is only five so me and Mrs Hudson have a long way to go yet" he smiled and Josh gave a nervous laugh.
"I'll go and practise" he replied as he climbed onto the stage and started to sing. Finn then went to the chairs and sat down next to Emily who crossed her arms in anger.
"Look your dad means well," Finn sighed "I mean when I was sixteen I slept with the first girl I could and I regretted it, I knew I should have waited until me and Mrs. Hudson were together. It all came out eventually and I nearly lost her."
"You would say that," Emily huffed "You and dad are tight so you would side with him."
"Em, I'm not siding with anyone." Finn looked confused as Josh looked up from the stage to see his director and girlfriend arguing. Emily then stood up and then walked out of the auditorium slamming the door behind her as she exited. Finn shot Josh a confused look as Josh just shrugged. Finn then nodded at Josh to carry on then made a mental note to go and find Emily once there was a break in the proceedings.
"Just so you can look like some slutty girl singer!" Finn yelled "How could you do this to me!" he exclaimed as Finn exited the room. Emily blinked as Jessie also left the room.
"W-what happened?" Emily replied confused.
"Well why you spaced out Rachel's video was just basically her with Finn, Jessie and Puck so as Finn said she was trying to bring down his reputation" Sophia smirked as Rachel shot a glare at her. Emily just nodded as the Glee Clubbers left the room.
"Why do you keep spacing out all the time?" Sophia looked confused as she unlocked her locker. Emily just sighed as she leant against it
"I dunno Soph," she mumbled "But I'm getting sick of it and I want them to stop." Suddenly she paused as she noticed Quinn getting a piece of paper out of her locker.
"Soph I'll just be a minute" Emily paused as she walked towards Mr. Schue's office but it was empty. Nodding Emily smiled as she walked towards Miss. Pilsburys office. Knocking on the door she opened it to see Mr. Schue standing there.
"Sorry," Emily replied blushing "But I think I know who made the 'Glist'."
"Who?" Will asked. Emma's eyes raised upwards staring at Emily.
"Just come with me" Emily replied. Will just shrugged as he walked out of Emma's office following Emily.
"It's Quinn" Emily whispered to Will who eyes raised towards Emily. "I saw her with a piece of paper and it makes sense she's lost everything and she did put herself first. Just question her" she smiled as Emily walked away.
(Sue sat by her desk writing facts down. Emily had a decent singing voice there was no question about that and her distinctive curly hair surely pointed towards him being the father. But was that enough proof she needed?)
"The mother," Sue thought "Who is the mother. It can't be the guidance counsellor they haven't been going out long enough." Sighing Sue lifted up her phone and dialled a number.
"Find out all you can on Emily Smith." Sue replied before putting the phone down. Meanwhile Emily walked out of the Glee Club as what seemed like a showdown between Rachel and Jessie causing Rachel to sing 'Total Eclipse of the Heart'. Suddenly Emily knelt down on the floor and held her head in pain as a flashback of the school filled with smoke and people running from it screaming filled her head. Emily then sat back and rubbed her head feeling more confused than ever.
"When can I go home!" the red headed girl screamed stamping her foot on the ground but then stopped as she noticed some of the football players were watching her. Emily just glanced at them as she walked down the corridor.
So is Sue right is Will the father? And if he is then who is the mother. Sorry if this chapter wasn't as well written as the others I struggled to get scenes from Bad reputation that would be used well and then there was the whole "slut" incident but because of previous events in my fic they were cancelled out. Anyway I always appreciate your reviews.
Chapter Five: Illness and Changed Personalities
When Emily and Rachel both are hit with sore throats is that it for the Glee Club. Meanwhile Sophia, Mercedes and Santana all try to get Puck with different results and Kurt changes personalities but will it work?