Holiday Chapter 3: All Hallow's Eve's Eve's Eve, a glee fanfic

Thank you again for all your story favoriting and alerting. It really keeps me motivated to write. I truly appreciate it. So without further ado...

It was Halloween, well technically it was only the 29th, but the New Directions were celebrating early since Halloween fell on a Monday. Once again Rachel's dads were out of town on a mini-vacation leaving the house empty and just waiting for the Rachel Berry House Party Train Wreck Extravaganza Part Deux to begin. While Rachel had protested against throwing such a party again, she did have to admit it had been fun. It took a little more convincing than last time to finally get her to agree, but once Rachel did, she found she was actually excited to have everyone over again.

She was determined that this time around would be ever better than last time. People actually wanted to show up not just for the booze but because they actually wanted to hang out with her, she could actually make out with Finn at this party if she wanted to and Blaine would be back which Rachel was sure would mean more drunken duets. Plus, there were a few new additions to New Directions which meant even more people to enjoy the night with.

What Rachel was more excited about than anything however, were the costumes. Being Halloween they couldn't very well throw a party without it being a costume one. They had all decided to keep hush hush on what they would arrive as to keep things interesting but Rachel had found out what Finn was going as anyway. She wouldn't ever tell him this, but she wanted to be that cheesy couple that wore complementing costumes. So she coaxed it out of him by agreeing to take her shirt and bra off during their make out session in exchange for the information. His resolve to not tell her had been quite steady until the owl covered sweater popped over her head. Then he was putty.

Rachel had to do a little research after his costume confession to determine what would be best to match his. She wasn't entirely familiar with the mythology of his selection, but once she felt satisfied she had an answer, Rachel went to work on making her costume. She wanted it to be accurate but also something no one would expect from her, sexy.

Just as she finished putting on her bright red wig, Rachel heard a knock at the door. She assumed it was Puck since he said he'd be over early with the alcohol and to help set up. If she could get a reaction out of him in this costume, Rachel knew Finn would love it.

She answered the door and Puck nearly dropped the box of Bud he was carrying. "Damn girl, who are you and what have you done with Berry?" he asked as he moved into the house. Rachel shut the door behind him.

"Does it look okay? I'm not very familiar with Batman villains," she said as she brushed the wig hair out of her face. Puck eyed her up and down. She had on hunter green thigh highs and a strapless shimmery emerald green bodysuit with what looked like little vines painted onto the chest that hugged every curve perfectly and made her boobs look incredible. Her make-up was a little over the top with the bright red eye shadow that went up to her eyebrows and the deep blush that swept up her cheeks and the equally bright red lipstick, but it was Halloween so crazy make-up was expected. Puck also noticed she had the same type of little vines painted onto her chest, arms, hands and edges of her face. Then there was her wig. It looked just like Poison Ivy's from that super cheesy Batman flick with Mr. Freeze.

"You're pretty much spot on. I'm kinda surprised though. Didn't take you for one to dress as a Batman villain for Halloween," Puck said turning away from Rachel and heading into her basement to begin setting up. She followed him.

"Well, it's not my first choice, but I wanted to surprise Finn and sort of complement his costume," Rachel explained as she sat down at the bar. Puck opened the box of Bud and began putting the cans in the fridge.

"Since you're Poison Ivy, I'm gonna assume Finn is Batman?" Puck said raising his eyebrow.

Rachel shook her head in confirmation. "Where's your costume?" she asked, realizing Puck was just in jeans and a shirt.

"It's in my car. I'm gonna change once we're done setting up and no, I'm not telling you what it is yet," Puck silenced Rachel's question before she could ask it. She harrumphed slightly.

"I just want to know what everyone is coming as! It's been killing me since we decided to not tell each other." Rachel hopped off the chair and followed Puck back up the stairs. "I'd help you bring stuff in from the car but I don't really want to go outside like this. This is a strictly indoor costume."

"Whatever, why don't you turn some music on or something, it's too quiet in here," Puck said as he opened the door and went out to his car to grab more booze. Rachel ran upstairs to grab her iPod to plug it into the dock in the basement. When she got back downstairs she found she was not alone. Finn, Kurt and Blaine had arrived and let themselves into her home.

"Holy crap, Rachel!" Finn exclaimed upon seeing his girlfriend dressed as a very sexy Poison Ivy. Kurt gaped at her as well and Blaine just waved hello. "That's quite the costume."

Rachel blushed and walked up to Finn to greet him with a kiss. "I told you I had a reason for wanting to know what you were going as." She stepped back from Finn and took in his appearance. He was wearing every bit of the Batman costume except for the mask. Apparently he had difficulty seeing anything in it so he only wanted to wear it once more people showed up. After appraising her boyfriend's chiseled chest, which much to Rachel's disappointment was just a fake chest plate, she greeted Kurt and Blaine who were sitting on the couch.

"Hey guys! I love your costumes!" Blaine was dressed like a sailor and Kurt was wearing what looked like buildings all over his person. "I'm not entirely sure what you're supposed to be Kurt, but it looks interesting," Rachel offered.

"I'm New York City! See here's the Empire State Building and the Brooklyn Bridge and Times Square. I've just been so inspired by New York lately I just wanted to show off to everyone!" Kurt explained excitedly.

"Blaine you look so cute in your sailor hat!" Rachel squealed.

"Thank you. Kurt told me once he liked men in uniform so…" Blaine looked at Kurt and smiled. Kurt couldn't help but lean over and kiss his adorable face. "So Rachel, I expect another duet with you tonight!" Blaine exclaimed as he pulled away from Kurt.

"You know it!" Rachel shouted back as she left Kurt and Blaine to themselves. She wanted to see if Finn and Puck needed any help. She could hear them upstairs in her kitchen talking animatedly. "What are you two doing?"

"Did you plan on feeding people or are we just gonna feast on beer all night?" Puck asked sarcastically. "I've been looking for food and all I've found is your vegan crap."

"Calm down, Noah. I'm going to order some pizza once more people start showing up and there are chips, pretzels and plenty of candy in bowls downstairs. And my food is not crap!" Rachel huffed in annoyance.

"Whatever, I'm hungry. By the way, do you think we could crack open some of your dads' stuff? I swear I'll replace it before they get back," Puck asked hoping she'd say yes.

"I thought the point of me giving you all that money to buy alcohol was so that we wouldn't have to open my dads' stuff again?"

Puck glanced at Finn who shrugged. "Well, yeah, but your dads have awesome stuff. I didn't know I'd want it until I saw it. I replaced their stuff last time, I can do it again."

Rachel sighed in defeat. "Fine! But you better replace it!"

"Yes!" Puck fist pumped into the air like a little kid being told he could stay up an hour later to watch a movie. He walked out of the kitchen and left Rachel and Finn alone.

"He is such a child!" Rachel exclaimed.

Finn laughed. "You look amazing, Rachel; seriously, sexiest Poison Ivy ever." He leaned forward and captured her lips with his. As he tried to deepen the kiss however, Rachel pulled away.

"We'll mess up my make-up if we go any further and it took forever. I promise you though, later when no one cares, you can kiss me as much as you want," Rachel giggled grabbing Finn's hand and pulling him back towards the basement. On their way down, they heard the doorbell ring. Rachel stopped to see who was arriving next.

"Holy hell, Rachel!" Santana yelled as she entered her house, followed by Brittany and Artie. "Poison Ivy? So did not expect that."

"Thank you, Santana…I think," Rachel replied cheerily. "Finn! Puck! Artie's here!" Unfortunately, Rachel did not have an elevator in her house which meant the guys would have to help Artie get downstairs. Finn came up immediately and greeted the girls and Artie.

"A pimp, nice, and are these your ho's?" Finn joked as he waited for Puck to get his ass downstairs to help him.

"I ain't no pimp. I'm Al Capone. Totally different," Artie said with mock offence.

"And we're not ho's," Santana said through her teeth as she punched Finn in the arm.

"I'm Lord Tubbington," Brittany said dully. Finn finally noticed what they were wearing. Santana had on a rather revealing black and maroon corset with a short black puffy skirt and fishnet stockings and boots. She actually did look like a hooker but the parts that made it a costume were the big black curly wings strapped to her back and the sparkly swirls of make-up covering her face, chest and arms. Her hair was done up in a giant bun on the back of her head.

Then there was Brittany. She had on what appeared to be a fat suit covered in fur. Cat ears graced the top of her head and a little pink dot and whiskers were plastered on her nose and cheeks. On her feet were cat paw slippers and on her hands were cat paw gloves. Finn smiled. Can't wait to see her try to get out of that later, he thought to himself.

"Well isn't that the most ironic sight ever," Santana said as she watched Puck saunter downstairs. He was dressed in a cop uniform which looked at least a size too small. "Planning on giving out lap dances later, Village People?"

"Eat me," he said evenly. "It was the last one they had."

"Dude, why didn't you just go as something else?" Finn asked trying so hard not burst out laughing.

"Because I have plans for this outfit tonight, dickwad. Can we just get Artie downstairs and start drinking already?" Puck grumbled as he grabbed the front of Artie's chair.

As Puck backed into the basement he heard Kurt cat-call him. "Talk about a man in uniform!" Kurt had zero interest in Puck but he had to rib him a little about how tight his pants were.

Puck flipped him off as he sat Artie down and headed over to the fridge. He really needed a beer. "Where the fuck is Lauren?" he said quietly but apparently not quietly enough.

"Ohhh, is that what this…look is for?" Kurt said as he walked over to the bar and grabbed a wine cooler. Unlike at the last Rachel Berry House Party Train Wreck Extravaganza, Kurt had decided to drink. Blaine certainly had no qualms about getting sloppy in front of him, so why should Kurt have any?

"Fuck off, Kurt." Puck took a long pull from his beer and wiped his mouth with his hand after.

"You know Rachel will kill you if you try to have sex anywhere in this house, right?" Kurt proclaimed on Rachel's behalf. "You should be careful."

"Who's having sex in my house?" Rachel yelled out, walking over to Kurt. "Noah, I swear to God if you and Lauren have sex while you are here, you are never allowed over again. I will not be cleaning up that mess!"

"You and Finn have sex here!" Puck countered.

Rachel's mouth dropped. "First of all, no, we don't have sex here because we haven't had sex yet! And secondly, even if we did, it's my house and Finn is my boyfriend. If you want sex, you can go to your own house." With that Rachel and Kurt walked off leaving Puck alone to nurse his beer.

A half hour later everyone from glee had finally arrived. Everyone's costumes were amazing. Mike and Tina showed up as Superman and Wonder Woman, Mercedes arrived as a Greek goddess, Sam showed up as a character from Avatar, Lauren arrived as a German bar maiden, Quinn showed up as Cinderella and the new kids to glee, Kyle, Marie, Riley and Trace arrived as Harry Potter, a can-can dancer, a sexy vampire and Wolverine respectively.

Almost immediately everyone began drinking. Rachel ordered their pizzas and gave the delivery guy a handsome tip because she couldn't do math very well by the time he arrived. Finn could tell the delivery guy was checking Rachel out so he made a point to kiss her in front of him to let him know she was taken. He glared at the guy as he stepped off the porch after handing the pizzas to him. Finn couldn't help it. He'd had a few by the time the guy arrived and was starting to feel it. Even sober his jealous streak could be bad, it was worse when drunk. If anyone looked at Rachel weird, they were not going to like Finn.

They headed back downstairs and announced to the room full of tipsy teenagers that food had arrived. It was like the running of the bulls to get to the greasy cheese and pepperonis. Even Rachel had to admit it smelled delicious and she never ate regular pizza. Once they had eaten, everyone immediately went back to drinking.

About an hour and a half later the Halloween decorations were nearly destroyed and everyone was sloshed. Brittany had managed to get out of her Lord Tubbington fat suit and was now running around in Artie's gangster suit jacket and not much else. Quinn was passed out on top of the bar, Mercedes's face was covered in blue from her making out with Sam on the couch and Santana's wings and fishnets were ripped to shreds from mackin' on Riley so hard. Kurt and Finn sat on the floor giggling about something no one else found funny, Artie was patting Marie's back as she vomited into the washing machine, Tina and Mike were slow dancing to whatever song was playing, Kyle was now in his underwear just staring longingly at Quinn sleeping on the bar while Trace was sitting in the corner just staring into the wall. Puck and Lauren were nowhere to be found.

"Blaine! Where's my Blainey, Blaine?" Rachel called out as she crawled across the floor to where Blaine lay spread eagle staring at the ceiling. "Blaine, we gotta sing! Come on, Blaine!"

He sat up unceremoniously and blurrily looked around the room. His eyes landed on Rachel's face. "Oh hey, Rachel! Wha's goin' on?"

"Come on!" Rachel yelled, standing up wobbly, trying to pull Blaine with her. Eventually he stood up and zigzagged his way toward the stage. Rachel found her microphones and handed one to Blaine. She found the music she wanted but before hitting play had to make an announcement.

"How's everyone doin' tonight?" Rachel yelled into her microphone startling everyone. It was turned up much louder than she expected. "Everyone havin' fun?" The group cheered and whistled and clapped. "I just wanted to tell you all thank you so, so, so, so, so much for coming to my party! This one is so much better this year because we have new members with us and we're all dressed up and I have a boyfriend again!" Rachel cheered and threw her fist in the air. "This song is for you, Finn," she purred into the microphone in what she thought was a sexy voice. Finn stared at Rachel looking like he wanted to cry.

Rachel hit play and the opening to Starship's Nothing's Gonna Stop Us Now rang throughout the basement. She danced around stage to the beat as Blaine started singing.

Lookin' in your eyes I see a paradise
This world that I found is too good to be true
Standin' here beside you want so much to give you
This love in my heart that I'm feeling for you

Blaine stared at Kurt the entire time he sang his verse, trying to convey everything he felt for him despite being very drunk. Then it was Rachel's turn.

Let 'em say 'We're crazy', I don't care about that
Put your hand in my hand, baby, don't ever look back
Let the world around us just fall apart
Baby, we can make it if we're heart to heart

Though the song was very cheesebucket, Rachel felt the sentiment behind it. Even being intoxicated, she knew the lyrics' meaning and knew that it applied to her and Finn. Then the chorus came and Rachel and Blaine sang together.

And we can build this dream together, standing strong forever
Nothing's gonna stop us now
And if this world runs out of lovers, we'll still have each other
Nothing's gonna stop us, nothing's gonna stop us now
Ohh, whoa, ohh

Then Blaine sang to Kurt again.

I'm so glad I found you, I'm not gonna lose you
Whatever it takes I will stay here with you
Take it to the good times, see it through the bad times
Whatever it takes is what I'm gonna do

Once again it was Rachel's verse. This time she moved from the stage and made her way over to Finn. She tried pulling him up so he'd dance with her but he was way too heavy and she was way too drunk. Finally he got the hint though and stood on his own.

Let 'em say 'We're crazy', what do they know?
Put your arms around me, baby, don't ever let go
Let the world around us just fall apart
Baby we can make it if we're heart to heart

The chorus played again and Rachel noticed that the others were joining in. They were all holding someone and swaying to the beat. Rachel and Blaine, having the microphones, were the loudest and they belted out the song together.

The chorus repeated three more times but by the end of it neither Blaine nor Rachel really cared about the song. They were much too busy making out with their boyfriends. That was until Finn grabbed Rachel's bedazzled microphone and made his way to the stage. He flipped through Rachel's iPod and found the song he had wanted to sing to Rachel for forever.

The beat pounded out of the speakers and Finn started low just staring at his girlfriend. She looked at him like he was a rock star.

I gotta take a little time
A little time to think things over
I better read between the lines
In case I need it when I'm older
Aaaahh whoa-ah-aah
Now this mountain I must climb
Feels like a world upon my shoulders
And through the clouds I see love shine
It keeps me warm as life grows colder
In my life there's been heartache and pain
I don't know if I can face it again
Can't stop now, I've traveled so far
To change this lonely life

Foreigner's I Want To Know What Love Is had been dancing around in Finn's mind for ages. He felt the chorus especially summed up how he felt about Rachel. He wanted to know love with only her and he wanted her to show him all of her love. Finn knew it was a little cheesy but music had always helped him in the past with expressing himself.

I wanna know what love is
I want you to show me
I wanna feel what love is
I know you can show me
Aaaahh whoa-ah-aah
I'm gonna take a little time
A little time to look around me
I've got nowhere left to hide
It looks like love has finally found me

Finn began belting out the song like he was on a stage surrounded by thousands of screaming fans instead of just a bunch of his drunk friends. He felt alive in that moment singing his heart out to Rachel.

In my life there's been heartache and pain
I don't know if I can face it again
Can't stop now, I've traveled so far
To change this lonely life
I wanna know what love is
I want you to show me
I wanna feel what love is
I know you can show me

Before Finn could even finish the song Rachel hopped up on stage and practically tackled him. She kissed him mercilessly and the microphone fell from his hand as he picked Rachel up and wrapped her legs around his waist. Everyone cheered them on as if they were at a football game instead of watching their friends grope each other on a small stage in a basement.

Through her drunken haze Rachel could vaguely tell what was going on. She untangled her legs from around Finn and pulled her mouth from his. He was aggravated by the loss of contact but followed Rachel when she gripped his hand and pulled him through the basement and up the stairs. They didn't stop until they reached her empty room.

Finn was very out of it but something inside told him that things were about to get very good. His cheeks flushed at the thought and he felt very warm all over. "I gotta get this thing off," he mumbled as Rachel shoved him back onto her bed. His costume was so hot and he could feel his underwear and t-shirt sticking to him grossly.

"Rach, I gotta…" he trailed off as Rachel pulled him up and helped unzip the back of his costume. She peeled it off of him then threw it against her wall knocking things off her desk. Once he was down to nothing at all Rachel proceeded to peel her own costume off only leaving her thigh highs on.

The wig was the hard part. In order to keep it on, no less than 20 bobby pins had to be used and now it was coming back to haunt her. "Stupid wig!" Rachel said angrily pulling at the synthetic hair on her head. Finally she ripped it off her head. She'd deal with the bobby pins later; her head was just so hot.

Finn stared at Rachel's naked body with an extra goofy grin on his face. "You're soooo pretty, Rach," he said slurring slightly. Rachel pushed Finn back onto her bed forcefully and straddled him. Slowly she leaned down and kissed Finn hard, shoving her tongue into his mouth. Finn moaned in pleasure and ran his hands down Rachel's sides until he reached her bare ass. He gripped her hard and she pulled away from him, sat up, and smiled wickedly.

Before she could over think it and stop herself, Rachel shimmied down Finn until she was comfortably between his legs, her head hovering over his hips. If Finn didn't have a hard on before, he certainly did now; seeing his girlfriend that close to his junk was turning him on so hard. Then he felt her hand wrap around him. "Oh GOD!" he practically screamed out, his head falling back against the bed. He could feel Rachel moving her hand up and down his shaft, stroking him gently. Then he looked down just in time to watch Rachel take his tip into her mouth. He was so happy he was drunk because if he wasn't he had a feeling he'd have come right then.

She licked his tip like she was eating a lollipop and just sucked on him lightly tasting his skin. Wanting to view the effect she was having on her boyfriend, Rachel looked up and couldn't help but smile. Finn was staring at her, mouth agape, just not believing what was happening to him. He was getting his first blowjob ever.

Before diving in and taking his whole length into her mouth, Rachel licked the underside of his penis from the base to the tip then opened her mouth wide and took in as much as she could. She idly thought if this was what Ms. Pillsbury was referring to when she said not having a gag reflex would be a gift.

Drunk or no, Finn could feel himself getting ready to explode now. He tried signaling Rachel that he was about to blow his load but she wasn't paying attention. Before he could stop himself, he released into her mouth.

Rachel balked a bit as the sticky substance assaulted her buds but once she understood what happened, she didn't really mind. Honestly, it didn't taste all that bad and it slid down her throat easily. It was gone in two swallows. She sat up releasing Finn from her mouth and moved up his body to kiss him. Only when she got to his head she heard him snoring and noticed he was passed out cold. "Of course," she mumbled to herself.

Unable to turn him so he was lying on her bed in the right direction, Rachel grabbed a pillow and placed it under his head. She then went over to her hope chest, grabbed a spare blanket and draped it over Finn's giant sleeping form. She grabbed her own pillow and cozied up next to her unconscious boyfriend under the blanket. The skin-on-skin contact felt so nice as she ran her hand over his chest. Her hand stopped on his beating heart and she couldn't help but move her ear to the spot to just listen to its steady rhythm.

Rachel let the sound of Finn's heartbeat lull her to sleep, happy and content with everything in her life. When she woke up next to him a few hours later however, she had a raging hangover and a scary looking man standing in front of her bed.

"Hi, Dad," she said uneasily knowing she was in for a world of trouble.

Uh oh! Caught in the act...again.