Two for the Price of One

by wannabeastarshipranger

This is an AnderBerry!Sibling Story. What if Shelby had been pregnant with twins and gave one away to another couple? M/M, M/F, Family, AU, Rated M for future chapters.

3. The Phone Call

AnderBerry!Siblings, Klaine, Finchel

Chapter 2: The Phone Call

Rachel tapped her foot in frustration while the phone seemed to ring on end. Finally a familiar voice answered on the other end.

"Hello, Shelby here!" Shelby said in a perky voice as Beth softly cooed in the background.

"M-mom? It's Rachel…." Rachel said softly into the mouthpiece.

"Rachel? What's wrong, baby?" Shelby said as she sat her baby down in her playpen to give Rachel her full attention.

"Um… I met this guy today…. H-he looks a lot like you. I know… this is probably stupid, but… I-I'm not a twin, right?" Rachel asked as she twirled the phone cord around her finger. She listened for Shelby to laugh and quickly ease her fears, but… why wasn't Shelby laughing and calling Rachel paranoid? "I'm not, right?" she asked again, fear causing her voice to pitch. "MOM?" Rachel practically screamed as Shelby still refused to step in and calm Rachel's fears.

"Baby…. It was supposed to be just you…." Shelby started.

"OH MY GOD I KISSED MY BROTHER?" Rachel screamed.

"WHAT? YOU KISSED BLAINE?" Shelby shouted in shock.

"IT REALLY IS BLAINE? OH GOD!" Rachel screamed again. She sat on her bed and regained her composure. Blaine was her brother. He was her brother. HE WAS HER BROTHER!

"I HAVE A BROTHER!" Rachel squealed excitedly. She had always wanted a sibling and now, she had a twin!

"Rachel…. I don't know if you should… tell your dads….. I was scared that if they knew… they would think I was sleeping around while pregnant with you and… I was 18. I couldn't handle one baby, let alone two. I-I was scared…." Shelby said as tears started to fall.

"But… Blaine is my… Who is older?" Rachel asked quickly, crossing her fingers.

"You are, by 2 minutes, 37 seconds?" Shelby said in confusion.

"BABY BROTHER! BLAINE IS MY BABY BROTHER!" Rachel shouted into the phone happily.

"Rachel! You are not understanding! If you tell your dads, they might try to take Blaine from his home and I'm sure he is very happy there! You can tell Blaine since I am sure you will anyways, but… keep it from your dads, please," Shelby begged.

"I understand. Thank you for telling me, Mom. I have to go hug my baby brother now," Rachel said as she said goodbye to her biological mother. 'Blaine Anderson, you are about to meet your big sister,' Rachel thought to herself as she hummed "Only Child" while grabbing her coat. She was off to Dalton.